Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Mar. 7th - May. 9th, 2023
In 2016, the Urban Indian Health Institute found that murder is the third leading cause of death for Indigenous women; and that Indigenous women make up a remarkable amount of missing persons cases. With these struggles of the modern era, it is necessary to understand how colonialism led to this environment of abuse. The first part of this essay seeks to explore this through administering the literary concept of deconstruction outlined in How to Interpret Literature: Critical Theory for Literary and Cultural Studies, by Robert Dale Parker, to Rebecca Roanhorse’s short fictional story, “Welcome to Your Authentic Indian Experience.” This story follows Indigenous man Jesse Turnblatt, and his journey into finding his authentic self in a world which suppresses authenticity. The following will explore Jesse and Theresa (Jesse’s wife), in relation to the main antagonist White Wolf. The administered deconstructionist concepts used in exploring this narrative are of double reading. Jesse and Theresa’s exchange represents both the colonial history of Indigenous women being traded to European traders in exchange for alcohol, and the tendency of Western society to disrupt non-Western relationships.
The story depicts a future United States in which some Indigenous peoples commoditize their culture to customers called Tourists, by leading virtual reality simulations using a program called, the Experience. Jesse works at one of these facilities where he specializes in leading Vision Quests for Tourists wanting to experience “authentic” Indigenous spirituality. One of these Tourists that Jesse encounters is a man by the name of White Wolf. Jesse and White Wolf become friends and start meeting weekly at Hey USA, the local bar.
In the story Jesse and White Wolf’s only bonding moments are when they are at the bar. Alcohol becomes the key factor in the two’s initial friendship. The themes in these interactions invoke the historical relationship of alcohol by European men and Indigenous peoples. That alcohol was used as a gesture of friendship in early colonial contact with Indigenous peoples. Historically, “most American Indians and Alaska Natives knowledge and use of alcohol coincided with White contact (16th and 17th century)... Alcohol soon became a valued trade commodity and was used in exchange for furs, land, and sexual favors” (Abbott et al. 1). In the story, we specifically witness the historical representation of alcohol being presented in exchange for sexual favors, which this essay will illustrate.
Later, Jesse gets sick and asks his wife, Theresa, to meet with White Wolf at the bar. Theresa doesn’t return to Jesse until almost 1am. Upon returning she is described as having “a rosy flush in her cheeks” Jesse probes her, “‘What took so long?’ She huffs. ‘Did you want me to go or not?’” Then when Jesse asks if she saw White Wolf, “she nods, smiles a little smile that you’ve never seen on her before… something inside you shrinks,” Theresa responds with “‘a nice man. Real nice. You didn’t tell me he was Cherokee’” (Roanhorse). Previously in the story, Theresa guided Jesse as a spouse, but after meeting White Wolf she becomes disenchanted with Jesse. The reasons for this are present in the implications of Jesse and Theresa’s interaction, and the colonial history of Native women. Theresa staying with White Wolf till 1am and descriptions of a “rosy flush in her cheeks,” a smile “never seen on her before,” and Theresa twice commenting on him being “a nice man,” signals to readers that Theresa has a surprising infatuation with White Wolf. Broberg denotes, in referring to Indigenous women and alcohol that, “It did not take long… for the women to fall prey to alcohol and become indebted to white traders who used them as prostitutes” (55). Tribes would also trade their women in exchange for alcohol. Theresa’s sudden infatuation with White Wolf signifies these historical relationships of European traders and Indigenous tribes. While Jesse does not trade Theresa, sending her in his place substantiates these historical relationships. This symbolism is further indicated when White Wolf is found in Jesse’s home, indicating details of Theresa’s whereabouts (info which Jesse does not know). White Wolf representing the role of European traders is present in his initial rapport with Jesse. The two bond over shared interest, White Wolf learns some Lakota, he presents as humble, curious, and trustworthy. These are the attributes of a salesman, or in our case, a European trader of colonial America.
The former described is our first reading of a deconstructionist double reading. According to deconstructive analysis of literature, we must now present a second reading. This is where the exchange between Jesse and Theresa articulates the Western societal tendency to ruin culturally non-Western relationships. The dominance of Western culture has led to Western ideals relating to masculinity and femininity having a hegemonic presence throughout the world. This has proven detrimental for men and women presenting relationship traits relating to their individual culture. Specifically, this article will seek to analyze Western masculinity and non-Western masculinity.
In the same interaction between Jesse and Theresa, it is noticeable Theresa’s enchantment with this new man in her life. Theresa indicates White Wolf’s mention of himself being Cherokee. White Wolf only claimed to have a great-grandmother who was Cherokee. Further, this claim is suspicious because White Wolf only applies the attractive elements of Indigenous culture to his identity. We also learned earlier that Theresa has a bad opinion of people claiming Indigenous culture with little to no evidence, categorizing them as “pretendians” (Roanhorse). Theresa seemingly overlooks this upon meeting White Wolf. The use of cultural appropriation by White Wolf raises his social standing amongst Indigenous culture. He becomes a member of the tribe, despite him being far removed from his Cherokee roots. This gives him authority amongst Indigenous women, because he only appropriates the attractive elements of Indigenous culture. White Wolf essentially becomes a “perfect” representation of the Indigenous male.
It is these societal contexts which strain Jesse and Theresa’s relationship. Theresa wants a man who isn’t going to end up an alcoholic, a common fear amongst Indigenous women. The archetype of a strong Indigenous warrior, which White Wolf presents as, further complicates Jesse and Theresa’s relationship. His name evokes the “stoic Indian” stereotype, and when White Wolf steals Jesse's job he embodies that Indigenous warrior in his attire. He wears a “bone choker around his neck,” armor worn by Indigenous warriors, and his skin is “a little tanner” (Roanhorse) indicating he spends time in nature (as a “good Indian” should). In the Western societal context, White Wolf remarking “she needs a real man” (Roanhorse) in regard to Theresa, refers to the “stoic Indian” archetype that White Wolf appropriates.
For Theresa and Jesse, the strains of maintaining one's culture in the urban-White dominated setting of Sedona, Arizona and Western hegemonic United States, becomes apparent. Theresa can’t help but feel “a rosy flush in her cheeks,” and Jesse can’t help but feel “something inside… shrink,” (Roanhorse) because under the pressures of Western hegemony the “movie Indian,” which White Wolf embodies, is the ideal Indigenous man. Non-Western relationships are destroyed due to the incessant presence of Western social tendencies. Indigenous culture does not value the same Western masculine ideals, yet in the Western societal context the authenticity of being Indigenous is irrelevant. Western society presents something better and more appealing. Why have Jesse when you can instead have a “real man,” capable of enacting the fantastical elements of being Indigenous. White Wolf presents the Western masculine bastardization of the Indigenous masculine ideal, and in essence is the catalyst for Theresa leaving Jesse.
To conclude, the historical parallels in Roanhorse’s fictional story outline the abuse of Indigenous women in the real world. Thus, it becomes important in recognizing the multitude of interpretations for Jesse and Theresa’s interaction. How it is a symbolic metaphor for European traders' abuse of Indigenous women during the colonial period; and the pervasive existing barriers for non-Western relationships to flourish in Western society. Jesse and Theresa exchange represent two conflicting readings, and in those readings even more interpretations.
A Destructive Display of False Consciousness
The capitalist construction of the economy gives way to the practice of false consciousness which normalizes the accumulation of profit to the detriment of greater society. For the character of Jesse Turnblatt, this ignorance of false consciousness leads to self-oppression, self-sabotage, and an environment of abuse. Jesse loses his sense of self in a struggle to remain authentic in a capitalistic society which suppresses authenticity based on the means of profit. This next part will analyze Rebecca Roanhorse’s short fictional story, “Welcome to Your Authentic Indian Experience” in relation to Marxist political theory. The discussion will follow the description of Marxism outlined in How to Interpret Literature: Critical Theory for Literary and Cultural Studies, by Robert Dale Parker, as well as contemporary understandings of Marxist theory. This discourse will demonstrate how the main character, Jesse Turnblatt, loses his authenticity through false consciousness.
Parker defines false consciousness as “a way of thinking that is so interpellated into oppressive ideologies that it leads people to act against their own interests'' (247). False consciousness attempts to hide capitalism's perpetuation of wealth accumulation. For this to be successful, the political and philosophical ideologies present in a capitalist society must be taught as in the best interest of the working class. If the working class is not being paid their labor value, the capitalist economy must show instances of individuals being paid way less. For example, the common American phrase of “there are starving kids in Africa” or allusions to “children working in sweatshops” in Asia reinforce that workers in America must be grateful for what their bosses pay them. If they are shown instances where a worker is being paid way less, they are less likely to complain about their current material conditions. This is just one example of perpetuation of false consciousness within society. It is an approach that undermines the awakening of individuals to their class position and relative status in society. For Marxists, the idea of false consciousness attempted to explain why capitalist societies have not yet revolted against the oppressive system which they live under.
In the case of “Welcome to Your Authentic Indian Experience,” the protagonist Jesse actively works against the positive and accurate perception of what it means to be Indigenous in broader society. He does this through his work as a Vision Quest guide in Sedona Sweats. When customers of the establishment (Tourists) order an Experience, they expect an authentic Indigenous experience. However, what they receive is explicitly inauthentic. Jesse is expected to display the hegemonic notion of how Indigenous Peoples are perceived. This detail is present in the commodification of culture which Jesse practices. Regarding Vision Quests, Jesse states that all they require “is a dash of mystical shaman, a spirit animal… and the approximation of a” drug like “peyote” that is all that is needed for Tourists to emerge “feeling spiritually transformed” (Roanhorse). This unenthusiastic view of Jesse’s own culture signifies that the perceptions of reality under the capitalist structure are more important than the truth of reality. Jesse does not need to display authentic Indigenous culture, because that is not what makes money. It is the fantastical elements of Indigenous culture that Jesse’s employer (Boss) and the Tourists want. The workers of the establishment are in between satisfying both the Tourists and Boss. In the capitalist organization of this economy, Jesse and his fellow working class are used to further the stereotypes which prove damaging to the material realities of Indigenous People. If the authenticity of being Indigenous is not displayed consistently, then participating in the capitalist structures profit accumulation would be based on being consistently inauthentic. However, being inauthentically Indigenous is impossible, because then one would no longer be Indigenous. The capitalist need for profit seeks to destroy that which it deems unprofitable. This is how stereotypes prove damaging to Indigenous Peoples material conditions. If they can no longer be themselves in the accumulation of wealth, then they are forced to become something else.
We see this happen when Jesse prepares for his work. He attempts to “memorize Johnny Depp’s lines from The Lone Ranger” and in his work locker he hangs “a picture of Iron Eyes Cody” (Roanhorse). Jesse studies figures that are explicitly not Indigenous and does this to placate the stereotyped notions of Indigenous Peoples present in society. This display of false consciousness proves detrimental to Jesse later in the story. When Jesse is fired from his job, Boss hires White Wolf and explains that he “is good, a real rez guy” (Roanhorse). Jesse does not attempt to defend himself in this instance. He does not reveal that White Wolf started off as a Tourist, that White Wolf is not Indigenous, or that Jesse was a mentor to White Wolf in the realm of being Indigenous. Jesse accepts that he is unworthy of being Indigenous and that White Wolf is far more worthy.
This is due to the culturally imposed Indigenous stereotypes. White Wolf embodies Indigenous stereotypes in The Lone Ranger and embodies figures like Iron Eyes Cody. Johnny Depp’s character in The Lone Ranger and Iron Eyes Cody, on many occasions, can both be seen wearing a bone choker. Iron Eyes Cody would also consistently wear a ribbon shirt in public. In the story, Jesse notes that White Wolf “looks different… Maybe it’s the ribbon shirt he’s wearing, or the bone choker around his neck” (Roanhorse). It is important to note that like Iron Eyes Cody, White Wolf does not remove the costume in his public life. White Wolf proudly wears these culturally appropriated items to the bar where he encounters Jesse. It becomes obvious that White Wolf attempts to embody these figures to better serve the purpose of the stereotypical Indigenous figure which the Tourists and Boss want. Jesse also questions whether White Wolf’s skin is “a little tanner” (Roanhorse). In these instances, Jesse looks for images of the Hollywood Indigenous figure to invalidate his own Indigenous authenticity.
White Wolf is the epitome of the commodified Indigenous individual which Hollywood perpetuates. Boss, in the struggle to make profit, understands that in the capitalist economy White Wolf will make him the most money. Like Johnny Depp in The Lone Ranger and Iron Eyes Cody, White Wolf is a White man playing an Indigenous person. Boss understands that this is what the Tourists want, and the Tourists subconsciously seek this. Both the Tourists and Boss want a White man who pretends to be Indigenous, because that is what modern Hollywood presents. They do not want to be met with the reality of what it means to be Indigenous and on a fundamental level, Jesse understands this as well. False consciousness within Jesse is so strong that he understands and accepts this reality. Jesse, even met with the prospects of losing his job (the means which necessitates his survival), he cannot free himself from the false capitalist construct of Indigenous authenticity. This is a perfect display of false consciousness, because in the perfect capitalist world a worker that is met with their own survival will still seek to perpetuate the capitalist structures which have led to their demise.
However, in the Marxian view not all of this is Jesse’s fault. These oppressive ideologies are so entrenched in society that Jesse has internalized his own oppression. Jesse in a conversation with his wife Theresa proclaims “‘we’re not the right kind of Indian’” (Roanhorse). In Jesse’s mind, the “authentic Indian” is ironically the “movie Indians” which he embodies in his work. Iron Eyes Cody is more Indigenous than Jesse because Iron Eyes Cody conforms to and creates Indigenous stereotypes, despite Iron Eyes Cody being of Italian-Sicilian heritage. Johnny Depp is more Indigenous because he embodies the Indigenous warrior archetype common throughout the media present in society. Jesse is steeped in these stereotypes so much that he loses himself and what it truly means to be authentically Indigenous. What is inauthentic becomes more appealing because of the standards which society has placed on Jesse. Ironically, if Jesse were to realize his false consciousness when he was still employed, he wouldn’t be able to do anything due to his own class position. If working towards your own self-oppression is what “pays the bills,” then Jesse would be forced to continue that work until his material conditions changed. This is the cycle in which the whole of Marxist analysis critiques. If workers do not have a say in their work and are not being paid their labor value, then they are subject to the whims of their employers. False consciousness is then reinforced greatly by the organization of the capitalist economy.
Jesse enters the trap of false consciousness in varying levels. He works against the broader societal perception of Indigenous Peoples, he’s entrapped by the inauthentic, and through that internalizes his own oppression. For the Indigenous community, the fantastical Indigenous personas which society expects is more powerful than reality. It is the most fascinating, alluring, and tantalizing. It is for these reasons that it makes the most profit and perpetuates the cycle of false consciousness required for the capitalist reality to function. In the Marxist sense, Jesse is the archetypal pre-revolutionary worker that is still enthralled by the delusion of capitalism. If he were to free himself from this enthrallment, then he could work towards freeing his fellow working class, and thus begin the revolution.
Work Cited
Abbott, Patrick J., et al. “American Indian and Alaska Native Aboriginal Use of Alcohol in the United States.” Edited by Spero M. Manson. American Indian and Alaska Native Mental Health Research, vol. 7, no. 2, 1996, pp. 1-13. Colorado School of Public Health, https://coloradosph.cuanschutz.edu/docs/librariesprovider205/journal_files/vol7/7_2_1996_1_abbott.pdf. Accessed 11 March 2023.
Broberg, Lisa Louise. Sexual Mores among the Eastern Woodland Indians. Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. no. Paper 1539625275, 1984. W&M ScholarWorks, https://scholarworks.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4797&context=etd. Accessed 12 March 2023.
Parker, Robert Dale. How to Interpret Literature: Critical Theory for Literary and Cultural Studies. Oxford University Press, 2020.
Roanhorse, Rebecca. “Welcome to Your Authentic Indian Experience.” Apex Magazine, 8 August 2017, https://apex-magazine.com/short-fiction/welcome-to-your-authentic-indian-experience/. Accessed 11 March 2023.
Image courtesy of Umut Dagli