Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | May. 30th, 2025
In Plato's (428-347 BCE) supposed recount of the events of Socrates' (470-399 BCE) trial, the Apology, Socrates argues that “the unexamined life is not worth living” (Plato 38a5-6). The issue with the notion “the unexamined life is not worth living” is that it necessitates an unexamined life to be an unworthy life; or even misconstrued to be a life unworthy of life, a belief that could lead to unjust actions. Secondly, the unexamined life is neither worthy or unworthy, because worth is subjective and predicated on societal notions of value. Thirdly, it is apparent that one can lead a fulfilling and productive life that has been completely unexamined and yet still provides value to society. Therefore, an unexamined life does not necessarily mean an unworthy life.
First, it is of utmost determination to understand the meaning of “worth.” The Ancient Greek word for “worth” is axios (Ancient Greek: ἄξιος): meaning “weighing as much, of like value” or in a moral relation, “estimable, of persons and things, worthy of, deserving” (Goldenberg and Shanahan). This is similar to the modern Oxford English Dictionary definition of worth as “the level at which someone or something deserves to be valued or rated.” In both meanings, worth must prescribe a value for it to be adequately rated or ranked. To be worthy of something is to be given sufficient value both externally and internally. While it is documented that Socrates did not value the opinion of the majority, he still existed and participated in Athenian society. As such, he had a collective of students who respected him and valued his teachings. In other words, he was given worth externally via other human beings around him.
This is known in evolutionary anthropology as prestige and is perhaps the most foundational of human cultural characteristics. Prestige was a way for early humans to identify leadership characteristics within certain individuals in a social group with the belief that they would help the group survive. This generally included the transmission of culture or knowledge necessary for survival. It is why many human cultures valued their elders, since the eldest members of a community had lived longer and therefore accumulated more information about their environment over time. It is important to note that prestige is a noncoercive form of worth, whereas the other form of worth in this dynamic is coercive. This coercive form of worth is categorized as dominance and prioritizes fear, threat, or physical aggression. Dominance is common throughout the animal kingdom; however it is not the most valuable to humans. Worth based upon dominance usually related to physical characteristics and an individual's ability to utilize said characteristics. For example, if you are choosing two individuals to play on a rugby team where one has the physical strength to dominate the field, but the other is older and weaker with more knowledge of the game — most will be inclined to choose the stronger individual. This is because rugby is a sport which necessitates physical aggression, fear, and threats of violence. The culmination of these evolutionary anthropological definitions of worth is known as the dual strategies theory or prestige and dominance theory (Henrich and Gil-White 165).
Several scientists in 2019 corroborated the aforementioned theory when conducting a study by running individuals through a series of quizzes and competitions to determine their prestige and dominance within a social hierarchy. Brand and Mesoudi found that “those who were initially rated as someone from whom others would like to learn had higher prestige” and that team captains “had higher ratings of both dominance and prestige than other group members.” They also found that age was a factor with older individuals being more prestigious than younger individuals. There were similar correlations between age and dominance amongst men, which may be reflective of modern society being less violent (towards like-members of a social group) and therefore not needing young men to defend social groups through violence. It also may be reflective of the fact that older individuals, in a setting absent from physical activity, will have the benefit of dominant characteristics by virtue of lived experience, confidence, education, and a greater-ability to relay information. Nevertheless, worth can be understood as synonymous with the evolutionary anthropological associations of prestige and dominance processes in human social interaction. What becomes important is examining how worth (prestige and dominance) interacts with human civilization and the imposed social or class hierarchies it has introduced. This means examining the historical reality in which Socrates lived.
Where concerns can be raised around the “the unexamined life is not worth living” is that it necessitates an unexamined life to be an unworthy life. This can even be misconstrued to be a life unworthy of life, a belief that could lead to unjust actions: wrongdoings, the breaking of laws, actions antithetical to goodness (things Socratic thought is against). In the same 2019 experiment, Brand and Mesoudi point out that women, despite having similar scores to men, were not nominated by their groups for having prestige. In other words, they were not recognized to be as worthy as the men in representing their social group. The reasons for this are perhaps all too obvious in that the United Kingdom (where Brand and Mesoudi conducted their study), like Ancient Greece before it, could be considered a patriarchal society. While the United Kingdom is making strides towards gender equality, women are still underrepresented in local government councils, as senior judges, and in parliament (Ministry of Justice; UK Parliament). It wasn’t until the Equal Franchise Act of 1928 that women got the same voting rights as men, whereas the British Empire had a long tradition of introducing laws limiting the rights of women into their overseas colonies.
Ancient Greece was also a patriarchal society and was designed around gender stratification. Legally ancient Greek women had no independence and had to be under the guardianship of male-kin, needed their guardian present for any legal changes, were excluded from the public sphere, and could have “their property” removed by said guardian without consent (Blundell 114-115). Giving additional context to the quote in question, Socrates states that “it is the greatest good for a man to discuss virtue every day and those other things about which you hear me conversing and testing myself and others, for the unexamined life is not worth living for men” (Plato 38a3-6). Socrates mentions men twice in his statement on the subject, however, does not include women. In fact, he clearly states that “the unexamined life is not worth living for men” and in doing so reveals patriarchal notions regarding the worth of women. That it is not necessary for women to lead an examined life or that women are somehow unworthy or perhaps incapable of leading an examined life. If such is the case, that women cannot or should not lead an examined life, then a concerning possibility reveals itself. That women may be unworthy of life, or at least, the very life which Socrates regards to be the only life worth living: the examined life. But then, what does Socrates mean when he refers to the examined life?
The examined life simply refers to a life steeped in philosophy: a practice of seeking answers to the fundamental nature of reality and existence by utilizing logical thought. When Socrates says the “unexamined life,” he means a life without philosophy; that a life without philosophy is not worth living. On these notions, we run into a second paradox regarding the role of women and philosophy. Many women philosophers have existed throughout human history, including during the time of Socrates. Most notably, a woman philosopher by the name of Aspasia (470 — after 428 BCE) is mentioned by several individuals (followers of Socrates included): Aeschines, Antisthenes, Plato, and Xenophon. In these writings Aspasia is portrayed as an educated and wise woman skilled in rhetorical discourse. In other words, she is a philosopher — one in which many throughout the Ancient Greek world were fond of. While the surviving writings on Aspasia are unverifiable, Pomeroy astutely points out that “Aspasia was a woman who was influential and powerful enough to have inspired these stories” (650). Even if she was not a philosopher, the very fact she is described as such would mean that women philosophers were believed to be possible and valuable to Ancient Greek society. If women philosophers were believed to be possible, and in fact seen as having worth, then the “unexamined life” according to Socrates should not be worth living for both men and women. Despite this, the vast majority of women were not allowed to lead an examined life. They were subjects of their guardians and in most cases were expected to serve two roles: bearing children and taking care of the home. If the unexamined life is not worth living, but women are barred from leading such a life, then the life of a woman is not worth living. Therefore, it can be easily justified that women are unworthy of life. Unjust actions would then be directed at women. This same logic can be extended to slaves and even animals, since animals would be considered incapable of reason.
Secondly, the unexamined life is neither worthy or unworthy, because worth is subjective and predicated on societal notions of value. Like in the case of the women in Ancient Greece or prestige and dominance theory, society prescribes worth onto individuals. This could be based on sex, gender, age, beauty, perceived strength, an individual's wealth, or whether they are of “royal blood.” These factors change depending on the society which one may find themselves in. For example, during the Peloponnesian War (431-404 BCE) the worth of individuals was entirely different between Ancient Greek city-states. It could be argued that Spartan society valued dominance over prestige, as they were entrenched in militarism, physical strength, duty to the state, and the importance of their aristocracy. Whereas the Athenians valued prestige over dominance, as they centered around intellectual pursuits, the arts, individualism, and democracy. When the Spartans conquer the Athenians at the end of the Peloponnesian War, they put in place an oligarchy. This oligarchy-controlled Athens through new laws which stipulated that only the wealthy had citizenship rights. Athens went from a citizen population of 30,000 to just 3,000 and from them 30 men were elected to run the state. These oligarchs were aptly named The Thirty and executed a reported 1,500 people without trial (Aristotle 35.1). The Spartans determined that Athenians who lacked sufficient wealth were not valid citizens. Therefore, the Spartan values of worth had to include wealth: a form of dominance.
Athenians rejected the rule of The Thirty and formulated an armed resistance to defeat them. In 403 BCE, the Battle of Piraeus led to a reconciliation between Sparta and Athens which allowed the Athenians to reestablish their democratic government. In this case, the Athenians saw worth in the ability to practice democracy. The practice of democracy is considered to be one of the highest forms of prestige because it allows all voices to be heard. In a democratic society, individuals are allowed to pass knowledge freely and use said information for the betterment of society. In Athens, women and slaves were excluded from the democratic process, which reaffirms the subjectivity of worth across civilizations. However, the differences between Sparta and Athens, the conflicting values between dominance and prestige, demonstrate that worth is entirely subjective. It is predicated on a variety of factors which include culture, class, religion, governance, and valued social hierarchies. As such, what is seen to be worthy within a single society can change almost entirely over time. Today in Athens, the Constitution of Greece, established in 1975, stipulates in Article 4.2 that “Greek men and women have equal rights and equal obligations” (27). The simple reconfiguration of Athenian society in the modern-day is historical proof that the values which a society deems to be of worth is based on the subjectivity of human beliefs.
Thirdly, an individual can lead a fulfilling and productive life that has been completely unexamined and yet can still provide value to society. A common soldier or blacksmith of Athens does not live an examined life, but they still bring value to their society. The soldier defends the city from raiders, warring city-states, and those who wish harm upon the city and its populous. Whereas the blacksmith makes the weapons for the soldier, manufactures ship parts for Athenian vessels to trade, and creates metal instruments used by Athenians in their everyday life. The worth of a soldier and a blacksmith are never in question in a society like Athens. These individuals do not lead an examined life, nor do they have the requirement or privilege to engage in such things. Instead, the soldier and blacksmith are required and encouraged to perform their duties, otherwise society would be worse off. The idea that “the unexamined life is not worth living” essentially posits that the individuals who partake in a productive profession, but lead their lives unexamined, are living an unworthy life; a life that has no value. However, it has been established that their lives do have value, for many people; and since value is proven to be subjective, worth is determined by what best assists in the welfare, wellbeing, and continued survival of all parties in a social group.
It is in these delineations that worth in its purest evolutionary anthropological formation is the human capacity to engage in selfless action. The dominance of an individual or collective only goes insofar as the ability for said dominant actions to benefit the majority of society. Such human practices can be studied by examining the American Revolution (1765-1783), the French Revolution (1789-1799), the Haitian Revolution (1791-1804), the Russian Revolution (1917-1923), or the Carnation Revolution in Portugal (1974). These human societies definitively decided that dominance from the state was detrimental to societal wellbeing. The same relationship can be observed with prestige, as a society that cannot defend itself or instill fear in its enemies will be subject to ruin. Such is the case with the Minoans (2000-1450 BCE), or even with the collapse of the Roman Empire (753 BCE — 1453 CE). From these realities worth becomes an intricate dynamic between prestige and dominance, whereby the most valued worth becomes a balance between the two social practices. Philosophy is important, perhaps now more than ever before, but it should not be considered the only source of value. Certainly, it should not be measured by the worth of someone's life. These notions can lead to dangerous ideas which may facilitate the disintegration of the social fabric.
In short, the Socratic beliefs surrounding an unexamined life fail to recognize the evolutionary anthropological means by which human beings value themselves. The idea that such a life can be of less value precisely devalues the lives of individuals who choose not to, or are barred from living an examined life. It becomes a means to justify actions which go against justice and simultaneously undermine the very foundations of philosophical pursuits. This becomes apparent by the fact that worth is a notion dependent on external factors, which are subject to constant change. Such conditions of our existence demonstrate that an unexamined life can be fulfilling, productive, and still provide immense value to society. Thus, an unexamined life does not mean an unworthy life.
Work Cited
Oxford English Dictionary, Oxford University Press, https://www.oed.com. Accessed 28 May 2025.
Aristotle, and Sir Frederic G. Kenyon. “The Athenian Constitution.” The Internet Classics Archive, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 1994-2009, https://classics.mit.edu/Aristotle/athenian_const.html. Accessed 29 May 2025.
Blundell, Sue. Women in Ancient Greece. Harvard University Press, 1995.
Brand, C.O., and A. Mesoudi. “Prestige and dominance-based hierarchies exist in naturally occurring human groups, but are unrelated to task-specific knowledge.” Royal Society Open Science, vol. 6, no. 5, 2019. National Library of Medicine, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6549959/. Accessed 28 May 2025.
“The Constitution of Greece.” Hellenic Parliament, 7 June 1975, https://www.hellenicparliament.gr/UserFiles/f3c70a23-7696-49db-9148-f24dce6a27c8/THE%20CONSTITUTION%20OF%20GREECE.pdf. Accessed 29 May 2025.
Goldenberg, Josh, and Matt Shanahan. Logeion, University of Chicago, 2011, https://logeion.uchicago.edu. Accessed 28 May 2025.
Henrich, Joseph, and Francisco J. Gil-White. “The evolution of prestige: freely conferred deference as a mechanism for enhancing the benefits of cultural transmission.” Evolution and Human Behavior, vol. 22, no. 3, 2001, pp. 165-196. Science Direct, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1090513800000714. Accessed 28 May 2025.
Ministry of Justice. “Diversity of the judiciary: Legal professions, new appointments and current post-holders - 2023 Statistics.” GOV.UK, 8 September 2023, https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/diversity-of-the-judiciary-2023-statistics/diversity-of-the-judiciary-legal-professions-new-appointments-and-current-post-holders-2023-statistics. Accessed 29 May 2025.
Plato. Five Dialogues: Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Meno, Phaedo. Translated by George Maximilian Anthony Grube and John Madison Cooper, 2nd ed., Hackett Publishing Company, 2002.
Pomeroy, Sarah B. “Reviewed Work: Prisoner of History: Aspasia of Miletus and Her Biographical Tradition by Madeleine M. Henry.” The American Journal of Philology, vol. 117, no. 4, 1996, pp. 648-651.
UK Parliament. “Women in Politics and Public Life - House of Commons Library.” The House of Commons Library, 4 March 2025, https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01250/. Accessed 29 May 2025.
Image courtesy of Anne O'Sullivan