Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Dec. 20th, 2020
“An ecosystem is the aggregate of many species’ habits of transformation, their ways of moving energy from its origin in the sun across space and condensing it over time. To be alive is to take a place in a chain of conversions” (Demuth 4). Humanity has begun to push the boundaries of this ecosystem in earth’s oceans. For thousands of years humans have hunted whales as a means of livelihood and glory. Specifically, one of the oldest records of whaling is found on the islands of Japan. Today, against the clear protest of the international world, Japan continues its practice of whaling. The protection of Japan's whales from whaling requires dedicated study on the environmental impact of whales, cause of whale death and the history and politics of Japanese whaling.
Whales’ Effect on the Environment
The impact whales have on the earth is profound. Scientists from the International Monetary Fund estimate great whales have an economic value of $1 trillion dollars. They believe that whales are a low budget nature-based solution to solving the climate crisis.
Whales absorb carbon into their bodies throughout their long lives. When they die they take that carbon with them as they sink to the bottom of earth’s oceans taking that carbon out of the atmosphere for hundreds of thousands of years. Each great whale absorbs and sequesters 33 tons of carbon, which is equivalent to 1,500 trees. Whale feces are also a primary nutrient source for one of the world’s most important oxygen producers, phytoplankton. These microscopic creatures produce 50% of the world’s oxygen and capture 40% of the world's carbon. This is equivalent to 1.70 trillion trees, four Amazon forests’ worth of carbon absorption.
While phytoplankton feed on nutrients from river sediments, wind and wave upwelling, and dust storms blowing in the ocean, these sources lack the necessary iron from phytoplankton to grow. Whales provide this iron mineral for phytoplankton to grow; and more phytoplankton means less carbon.
Collective reasons for why great whales are worth a total of $1 trillion dollars chart by the International Monetary Fund.
Causes of Whale Deaths
For over 4,000 years, human beings have been hunting whales. Before whaling it is estimated that there were up to 5 million whales in earth’s oceans. Now that number has decreased significantly to 1.3 million whales with endangered species like the blue whale, being just 3% of what they used to be. While the majority of countries have stopped commercial whaling, estimates say that some whale species will not reach even half their pre-whaling population numbers by 2100.
Number of whales intentionally killed by humans each year for economic, scientific, and cultural purposes graph by Statista.
Commercial whaling is not the only cause of whale deaths. Whales face significant threats from being struck by ships, plastic waste, fishing nets and noise pollution. The International Whale Commision (IWC) estimates that there have been 1,200 ship-to-whale collisions between the years 2007 and 2016, but whale experts believe the number of deaths are far higher than the IWC estimates. Experts from the Great Whale Conservancy (GWC) consider IWC estimates should be 10 or 20 times higher. Michael Fishback, founder and CEO of the GWC says “If the whales were not negatively buoyant there would be so many bodies floating on the surface, in the shipping lanes and near certain ports that this never would have been allowed to continue as long as it has. People would not have stood for seeing so many whale bodies floating in the ocean…” Today there are over 50,000 ships traveling across the globe, including oil tankers, cargo ships and cruisers. Shipping lanes commonly overlap with whale migration roots, raising the number of ship strikes. Many ships are massive and take miles to maneuver slightly. Whales have not yet evolved to know that ships are dangerous, and they are also confused by the mass of noise pollution in the ocean, which affects whale navigation.
Plastics in the ocean contribute 100,000 marine mammal deaths every year. For animals like whales with extremely low reproduction rates this can be devastating. Most plastics do not kill whales but instead get lodged in their stomachs. This makes whales feel full and causes severe nutrient deficiency. Another significant threat is fishing nets, as studies indicate that 308,000 whales, dolphins and porpoises are killed by fishing gear annually. Whales often get caught on nets used by fishermen which can cause them to drown or die from starvation. New models estimate an increase in whale deaths due to ocean acidity, declining sea ice and warming of ocean temperatures.
History and Politics of Whaling in Japan
The consumption of whales in Japan dates back to 10,000-300 B.C.E. during the Jōman period. During this time whales that washed up on the beach were prepared for food, and it wasn’t till the 12th century that Japan began whaling on the open sea with hand thrown harpoons. By the mid-20th century Japan was one of the dominant industrial whaling nations along with the United States and several European nations. From the 1940s to 1960s whale meat was the single biggest source of meat in Japan and in 1964 Japan killed over 24,000 whales in one year. This is because after World War II, Japan was struggling to find a substantial source of protein for its people. Now as a highly-developed nation, Japan does not have that issue and only 5,000 tons of whale meat are consumed each year opposed to 200,000 tons during the 1960s. In 1946 the IWC was established, which saw Japan join in 1951, during U.S. occupation. In 1982 the IWC finally introduced a commercial whaling moratorium. Japan objected to the imposed whaling restriction and in 1987, Japan was given a “special whaling permit” which permitted whaling under the bases of scientific research.
From 1987 to 2019, Japan operated several large-scale whaling operations. The largest was in the Antarctic, in which 333 minke and 50 fin whales were killed at its peak (specific numbers are vague as the Japanese government fails to report all whales killed). This Antarctic zone was declared a whale sanctuary by the IWC in 1994, but Japan refused to recognize it as such. Japan’s Northern Pacific programs continued as offshore hunts of sei whales (second largest endangered whale species), Bryde’s whales and sperm whales. While some whale parts were given to the Institute of Cetacean Research (ICR), whale meat was sold to shops, restaurants, fish markets and put through government funded programs to try and promote whale meat. These sales contribute to some of the following years' hunts, but $50 million of subsidies are funded exclusively for whaling. The ICR is also a large contributor in funding of whaling.
In 2019 Japan left the IWC with the intention of officially resuming commercial whaling with the primary focus on hunting sei, minke, and Bryde’s whales in Japan’s waters. Whaling operations are driven by a small influential group of politicians and whaling industry stakeholders. Kyodo Senpaku remains the primary company that conducts the whaling and sells the meat. It still remains dependent on government subsidies to stay in business, much of which is from tax paying citizens. According to spokesperson for Greenpeace Japan, Hisayo Takada, Japanese people have “mixed feelings” about whaling. The industry has been propped up by politicians as a national tradition. In Hisayo Takada’s view whaling “has become a sensitive, nationalistic topic. It’s not about whaling itself. It’s more about Japanese pride and standing up for what people see as their culture.” Advocates against whaling say it ruins Japan’s international reputation for a society where people only eat 40 grams a year per capita of whale meat.
Proposed Resolution
When it comes to limiting whale to ship collisions several mitigation efforts can be put in place. One of those is called the “traffic separation scheme.” This initiative has been done successfully in places like the Gulf of Panama, where a narrow shipping route has been put in place to reduce collisions as estimates showed a 90% drop in collisions. Traveling at night, when whales mostly feed, in high risk areas, would also reduce collisions, along with reducing ship speeds. The United Nations estimates that 15 million metric tons of plastic end up in the ocean globally each year, affecting over 900 species. Government's and companies need to reduce production of single use plastics. Political leaders must support and fund laws to protect endangered species and wildlife agencies need to increase reporting on plastics effects on marine life.
In Japan advocates against whaling have pointed out Japan’s misuse of funds intended for the Fukushima disaster. Japanese taxpayers pay $2.5 million each year for whaling. Other countries must apply political pressures on Japan and condemn Japan’s whaling as illegal. The IWC and United Nations should not allow Japan, Norway and Iceland to continue whaling efforts without punishment. Whale meat should be an illegal substance in ports across the globe.
In Japan the government and Kyodo Senpaku have undergone extensive marketing schemes including trying to get whale meat used in school lunches. Many of these government marketing schemes are unsuccessful, this is because whale meat is undesirable. Japanese citizen Etsuo Kato says “I don’t need whale hunting. Once you have eaten beef there is no need to eat whale meat.” For the generation who came after World War II, whale meat was a huge part of their childhood. In fact, the American occupational authority at the time encouraged Japan to use whale meat as a cheap source of protein. While it may be a source of nostalgia for some, many do not find it tasty and think beef, pork and chicken taste better than whale meat. Japanese citizens need to speak up and tell the government that they don’t want whale meat.
Conclusion
Hunters use exploding harpoons on ships to penetrate whale flesh, sometimes causing suffering for hours. Whaling is inhumane and cruel. Future studies should focus on the dolphin industry of Japan and the culling of smaller cetaceans. Specifically, the controversial dolphin killings at Taiji Cove in Wakayama. Whales are a keystone species not just in the oceans, but to the entire world. While “tradition” and “culture” may be important to some, many would argue that there is nothing traditional about a fleet of ships with high-tech equipment and explosive weaponry hunting down gentle giants of the sea. Endangered species which can potentially solve the climate crisis deserve more than dying only to be canned and sold at the local grocery store.
References
Demuth, Bathsheba. Floating Coast: An Environmental History of the Bering Strait. V. Illustrated Edition and W.W. Norton & Company. 2019 “Prologue” The Migration North 1 (4): 1-14
Lavery, T., B. Roudnew, P. Gill, J. Seymour, L. Seuront, G. Johnson, J. Mitchell, and V. Smetacek. 2010. “Iron Defecation by Sperm Whales Stimulates Carbon Export in the Southern Ocean.” Proceedings of the Royal Academy 127:3527–31.
Lutz, S., and A. Martin. 2014. “Fish Carbon: Exploring Marine Vertebrate Carbon Services.” Blue Climate Solutions report, The Ocean Foundation, Washington, DC.
Pershing, A., L. Christensen, N. Record, G. Sherwood, and P. Stetson. 2010. “The Impact of Whaling on the Ocean Carbon Cycle: Why Bigger Was Better.” PLoS One 5 (10): 1–9.
Roman, J., J. Estes, L. Morissette, C. Smith, D. Costa, J. McCarthy, J. B. Nation, S. Nicol, A. Pershing, and V. Smetacek. 2014. “Whales as Marine Ecosystem Engineers” Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 12 (2): 377–85.
Smith, C., J. Roman, and J. B. Nation. 2019. “A Metapopulation Model for Whale-Fall Specialists: The Largest Whales Are Essential to Prevent Species Extinctions—The Sea.” Under review.
Animal Welfare Institute. “Japanese Whaling.” https://awionline.org, AWI, August 2020, https://awionline.org/content/japanese-whaling#:~:text=Japan%20has%20a%20centuries%2Dlong,(10%2C000%E2%80%93300%20BC).&text=Japan%20was%20not%20an%20original,end%20of%20World%20War%20II.
Chami, Ralph, et al. Nature's Solution to Climate Change. 4 ed., vol. 56, Finance & Development, 2019. https://www.imf.org, https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2019/12/natures-solution-to-climate-change-chami.htm.
Dooley, Ben, and Hisako Ueno. “Japan Resumes Commercial Whaling. But Is There an Appetite for It?” New York Times, 1 July 2019, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/01/business/japan-commercial-whaling.html.
Hunter, Fergus, and Steve Jacobs. “'Extremely disappointed': Australia lashes Japan's decision to restart commercial whaling.” The Sydney Morning Herald, 26 December 2018, https://www.smh.com.au/environment/sustainability/japan-to-start-commercial-whaling-in-july-20181226-p50oa8.html
Sato, Junichi, and Greenpeace. “3 Ways We Can Shut Down the Japanese Government’s Whaling Program.” The Environmentalist, 2016. https://www.greenpeace.org, https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/3-ways-can-shut-japanese-governments-whaling-program/.
Wahlquist, Calla. “Endangered whales won't reach half of pre-hunting numbers by 2100, study says.” The Guardian, Whales ed., no. Marine Life, 22 August 2017, https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/aug/22/endangered-whales-wont-reach-half-of-pre-hunting-numbers-by-2011-study-says.
Whale and Dolphin Conservation. “Stop Whaling.” https://us.whales.org, WDC, 2019, https://us.whales.org/our-4-goals/stop-whaling/.
Whale and Dolphin Conservation. “Whaling in Japan.” https://us.whales.org, WDC, 2020, https://us.whales.org/our-4-goals/stop-whaling/whaling-in-japan/.
Wingfield-Hayes, Rupert. “Japan and the whale.” BBC News [Tokyo], Asia ed., no. World, 8 February 2016, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-35397749#:~:text=From%20the%20late%201940s%20to,meat%20from%20Australia%20and%20America.
Image courtesy of Silvana Palacios