Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Sept. 18th - Oct. 20th, 2024
The ancient Mesopotamian netherworld is prescribed its own set of modern biases and presumptions. Modern projections devalue, alienate, and simplify the cultural complexities of the era. Whereas the review of works such as, the Epic and Gilgamesh, Nergal and Ereshkigal, the Descent of Ishtar to the Netherworld, and Dumuzid’s Dream, among others, serve to build a holistic view, free of modern bias. A challenge which requires the examination of the ancient Mesopotamian netherworld through its myth narratives, and its deities, in conjunction with their effect on cultural values, religion, art, superstitions, and cult worship.
The surviving historical documents are marred with incompletion and linguistic confusion. Gods, cities, characters and monarchs were referenced in different languages or dialects. What theonym was used for a god or what toponym was used for a city, was entirely dependent on forces which were in constant change. However, to eliminate confusion we are focusing on literature from what Assyriologist Benjamin Foster refers to as The Mature Period (1500-1000 BCE). Often referred to as the Mesopotamian “dark age,” The Mature Period was characterized by foreign rule and a repression of Mesopotamian culture. The documents from that period are somewhat incomplete and occasionally selections are substituted using other versions of the story. This has created poetic inconsistencies and mismatched names. For example, in the hymns Dumuzid’s Dream and Descent of Ishtar to the Netherworld, a figure named Belili is mentioned. This figure is assumed to be a sister of Dumuzid; however, the name has no traceable etymology and is sometimes used in conjunction with other primordial deities whose etymological links are missing (Rubio, 39). In hymn Dumuzid’s Dream, some words or phrases are left completely untranslated, such as the toponym “Ku-birec” (ETCSL, 181-191). It is likely a temple since ku has several meanings in Sumerian: “pure, holy,” or “radiant, silver,” or “to enter” (Bowen and Lewis, 231). Here the challenge of translating three-thousand-year-old work is evident. Nevertheless, these stories have an extraordinary familiarity to them.
The ancient Mesopotamian netherworld (sometimes referred to as the Underworld, Arali, or “The Land of No Return”), is perhaps the most fascinating place within ancient Mesopotamian mythology. While contemporaries often refer to it as the “Underworld” for, no doubt, a “theatrical flair,” the term netherworld is more accurate. This is because Underworld has cross-cultural meanings that do not always refer to the afterlife. It can refer to life underneath a city, such as the Catacombs of Paris, or the connections between criminal elements. Whereas netherworld, while not as alluring, is an afterlife where the dead reside. It is sometimes even a respectable place, such as in Mesopotamian theology. For the people of ancient Mesopotamia, the netherworld was a part of their daily routine. Every soul in Mesopotamia was destined for the netherworld and it was up to their living relatives to make sure they were not forgotten. This description of the netherworld is found in Tablet 12 of the Epic of Gilgamesh titled Gilgamesh, Enkidu, and the Netherworld. The epic recalls Enkidu’s journey to the netherworld, upon his return he relays what he has witnessed. In Mark and Shukir lines 286-303, Gilgamesh asks, “did you see …?” and Enkidu replies “he eats the food offered to him, he drinks the water offered to him.” For the dead to eat flavorful food, they must be honored by their living relatives, otherwise they would be forced to eat dust and mud. Their living relatives must bring them perishable offerings of sustenance which would be transposed into the netherworld.
Consequently, Gilgamesh, Enkidu, and the Netherworld (Tablet 12) is removed from modern translations of the Epic of Gilgamesh for several reasons. Firstly, it does not coherently fit within the narrative. This would indicate that it was a piece written outside of the central narrative, like today's pastiche fiction. Secondly, it is glaringly obvious to the reader that Tablet 12 is a propaganda piece. Gilgamesh oddly asks how men with a certain number of sons fared in the netherworld. A man who only produced one son during his lifetime “weeps bitterly at the wooden peg which was driven into his wall" whereas a man with seven sons is “a companion of the gods…” who “sits on a throne and listens to judgments” (Mark and Shukir, 254-267). This indicates Tablet 12 was likely a piece commissioned by a clerical order, city-state elites, or possibly the king. A city-state or imperial power in Mesopotamia would benefit from families having many sons as they could work the fields and be drafted into war.
The tablets propagandistic inclinations give useful insight into Mesopotamian attitudes surrounding the family, sex, warfare, and the netherworld. For example, if a man or woman didn’t have sex with their spouse when they were alive, then they weep over inanimate objects (Mark and Shukir, 268-285). The inanimate object being incapable of showing affection, and serving, ironically, as the mirrored rejection of the intimacy that the individual gave their spouse when they were alive. It becomes apparent that sex was viewed as a necessary element to marriage. This cultural view would eventually be adopted into Islam, where if a man does not, please his wife sexually, then she is permitted to divorce him (Nasr, Quran 2.226-227). Tablet 12 also illustrates the fate of children who do not live to maturity. When Enkidu is asked of stillborn children in the netherworld, he replies "they play at a table of gold and silver, laden with honey and ghee” (Mark and Shukir, 286-303). To make that pain of child loss bearable, the text indicates that dead offspring live joyously in the netherworld. Not only would this comfort mothers, but it would also ensure that they keep producing offspring. In a society which values children, especially sons, it is important to ensure that women fulfill a duty of motherhood.
When it comes to warfare, a soldier's parents “are not there to hold his head, and his wife weeps” (Mark and Shukir, 286-303). At first glance, it would seem that the ancient Mesopotamians viewed warfare negatively. However, it doesn’t comment on the state of the fallen soldier, but instead their family. Meaning we do not get insight into how fallen soldiers live in the netherworld. This obfuscation would follow the logic of a propagandistic piece of literature. The ruling class wants men to fight their wars, thus they will not reveal how soldiers live in the netherworld, but rather romanticize their deaths. Notice how the parents cannot “hold his head,” as if he has, by the weight of his body, grown from a boy to a man. War was perhaps a right-of-passage for a son and signified maturity. And with the phrase, “his wife weeps,” what is more romantic than a widowed wife whose husband died in battle? Her husband did not die of illness, adultery, or assassination — but instead died defending his family. As the widowed wife of a fallen soldier, she can live pridefully as her status in society is raised.
Burney Relief or Queen of the Night from Iraq (1800-1750 BCE).
Bronze statuette of the demon Pazuzu from Iraq (800-700 BCE).
Ereshkigal, goddess of the netherworld, existed in ancient Mesopotamia as a revered goddess who had complete sovereignty over her realm. In some myth narratives she is referred to as the netherworld, with the netherworld itself alluded to as being alive. Ereshkigal has only one surviving art of her; that is the Burney Relief or Queen of the Night (Iraq, Babylonian art, 1800-1750 BCE, carved stone). Its disputed name comes from debate amongst Assyriologists as to who it represents. Some believe it to be Ishtar (Inanna), yet while she does have the voluptuous appearance associated with fertility, she lacks the traits of Ishtar found in other art. This would be the ornate robe which signifies her radiance. Despite her being a goddess of fertility, it may have been disrespectful to represent her naked, as there is no known surviving relief with a nude representation. Whereas it would make sense for Ereshkigal to be nude, as nudity was common in the netherworld, due to the prohibition of fresh clothes. Furthermore, the Queen of the Night relief shows the deity with bird feet. Ishtar always has human-like feet in her representations. Only demons, such as Pazuzu, are shown with bird feet; as reflected in the bronze statuette of the demon Pazuzu (Iraq, Assyrian art, 800-700 BCE, statuette). The Queen of the Night relief also has two owls flanking her on either side. Owls in ancient Mesopotamia were largely associated with the forces of depression, evil spirits, and bad omens. In the Cursing of Agade, the ukuku (Sumerian for owl) brings depression to a joyous city, and in Dumuzid’s Dream the owl transforms into an evil man. This is a superstition which continues till this day in the region (Al-Sheikhly and Aidek, 5). Ishtar would not have an owl beside her, but Ereshkigal is a commander of an army of demons. She threatens to unleash them on the mortal realm in many myth narratives. Worshippers may have been frightened to sculpt demons, instead using the owl as its animal equivalent. Ereshkigal is among the gods, being propped up by two lions, but she is also amongst demons with two owls standing at the ready. And she awaits giving her judgment upon the dead, as she stands with her palms outward, stopping anyone at the gates.
During The Mature Period, Ereshkigal eventually shares power with her husband in the story Nergal and Ereshkigal. Nergal (Gugalanna) or “The Bull of Heaven,” which was slain by Gilgamesh and Enkidu. The story of Nergal and Ereshkigal is a poem which tells of how Nergal’s place beside Ereshkigal came to fruition. It was through a very dramatic series of sexual tensions, threats of executions by one another, and passionate love-making sessions which led to their joint netherworld rule. The story in many ways reflects the “tortured romance,” where two lovers are noticeably incompatible, yet deeply and uncontrollably infatuated with each other. This archetypal romance is all too familiar for the modern reader and demonstrates a temporal cultivation of romantic drama. Ancient peoples weren’t too dissimilar to people today, a fact which can be reflected in some of capitalism's most popular and profitable industries.
This value of loving one's partner isn’t uncommon in Mesopotamian literature relating to the netherworld. The Descent of Ishtar to the Netherworld is one the most emphatic displays of Ereshkigal’s power. In the poem, Ishtar visits her sister, Ereshkigal, in the Mesopotamian netherworld. Ishtar wishes to attend Nergal’s funeral, after being slain by Gilgamesh and Enkidu. But Ereshkigal blames Ishtar for her husband's death, since Ishtar recruited Nergal to kill Gilgamesh. In a violent display of power, Ereshkigal and the Anunnaki (judges who decree one’s fate) execute Ishtar, then place her corpse on display. Ishtar is eventually resurrected by the other gods, and she escapes the netherworld. In a fit of rage, Ereshkigal threatens to unleash her army of demons into the mortal realm unless Ishtar is returned or alternatively someone takes her place. Ishtar’s husband, Dumuzid, takes her place in the netherworld. In one version of the story, Ishtar sends him down as punishment for being unfaithful, whereas in another version, Dumuzid volunteers as her valiant savior. The latter version seems more congruent, because in the poem The Return of Dumuzid, Ishtar mourns the loss of her husband. She decides to negotiate with Ereshkigal and makes a deal in which Geshtinanna (Jectin-ana), Dumuzid’s sister, will replace her brother for half of the year. The myth stories of Ishtar and Ereshkigal enhance the anthropomorphic character of the gods. They are passionate lovers, mourning widows, and vengeful spirits. The imposition of juxtaposing female characters, one the representative of fertility, and the other Queen of the Dead, is a set of archetypes more relatable than the simplicities of “good” and “evil.” This isn’t to say that the ancient Mesopotamians didn’t have their superstitions. Rather their anthropomorphic display of human flaws makes them more relatable than the quasi-authoritarians of Biblical scripture.
Dumuzid, the husband of Ishtar, is the god of shepherds, beer, grain, and death of the seasons (summer solstice). He is the sister of Geshtinanna, goddess of grapes and wine. Their deaths, and the return of Dumuzid to Ishtar, in The Return of Dumuzid, is cited as the myth narrative which explains the changing of seasons. A conjoining prequel to this myth narrative, the story of Dumuzid’s Dream, depicts Dumuzid having a dream in which the galla (netherworld demons) are chasing him. Terrified that this dream is a prophecy, he consults his sister Geshtinanna, a “wise woman, who knows the meanings of dreams” and she determines that this dream is that of his death (ETCSL, 19-25). Dumuzid’s Dream, in a beautiful poetic rendition, conveys poignant repetitions, nerve racking chase scenes, and courageous battles. For the polytheistic worshippers of Mesopotamia, Dumuzid is a hero. He is someone whose trials and tribulations make you care for his well-being. Yet, a shift happens within the monotheistic traditions which seek to twist Dumuzid into the very demons he was trying to flee from.
In Akkadian, Dumuzid is cited under the theonym Tammuz. This theonym is found in the Book of Ezekiel of the Old Testament. It states, in reference to the idolatry within Jerusalem, “he said also unto me… thou shalt see greater abominations… then he brought me to… the Lord’s house… and, behold, there sat women weeping for Tammuz… then said he… turn thee yet again, and thou shalt see greater abominations than these” (KJV Bible, Ezk. 8.13-15). The insistence on using the theonym “Tammuz” is likely due to the historical period in which the Book of Ezekiel was written. After 1500 BCE, Akkadian became the lingua-franca of Mesopotamia and thus Ezekiel, during his Babylonian exile, would have been privy to its usage. Tammuz, chosen as an example of heretic idolatry, is because of his relationship to the Mesopotamian netherworld and the rate at which he was worshiped. In Mesopotamia, Tammuz represented the changing of seasons. As a god of agriculture, Tammuz was worshiped through spring. During summer it was believed that he died, and the people would mourn him. After summer, he would be born again, simulating cycles of rebirth. His death likely garnered an eclectic and ecstatic form of worship that led to ire amongst monotheists.
In the 1930s, an excavation trip by archeologists at the University of Chicago revealed Tammuz cult worship by the Bajilani tribe in rural Iraqi Kurdistan. There they describe witnessing a rain-dance ritual in which a woman pours water over a supposed dead man to resurrect him (Frankfort, 137-138). The cult at the height of its popularity was often a joint worship of Tammuz and Ishtar, as Tammuz would join his lover in the spring after being released from the netherworld. The woman in the ritual likely represents Ishtar and the dead man, Tammuz. In essence, Tammuz, by means of divine or magical expression, is being resurrected from the netherworld. Generations later, the cult of Tammuz continues in its most primordial form. And this shouldn’t be unexpected; farming is an erratic lifestyle. Droughts, floods, locusts, and warfare were all external factors which greatly impacted farming communities. Tammuz, as the agricultural deity of the region, was worshiped in the belief that he would bring efficient harvests. Later, the theonym “Tammuz” would be adopted into modern Assyrian, Hebrew, Turkish, Levantine and Iraqi Arabic calendars as a term signifying the beginning month of summer. It’s also of significant note that modern holidays, such as Easter and the May Day festival have taken significant inspiration from the cult of Tammuz (Meek, 2).
What the ancient Mesopotamian netherworld reveals is the likeness of ancient peoples to ourselves. They may not have had prime-time television or movie stars, but they had hymns, myths, epics, and heroes who inspired. The netherworld was a comfort, as much as a fear. Through its dreariness and decay came the hope of spring, and lush harvest. It is an ornate display of a society foraging the framework of existence and making reality meaningful.
Ancient Greece: Adonis and the Cult Politics of the Mediterranean
The Mediterranean Sea served as a central force for cultural exchange between Afro-Eurasia. Societies adopted each other's customs, languages, rituals, and gods. In such instances, the Mesopotamian gods of Inanna (Ishtar) and Dumuzid (Tammuz) would be adopted into the Greek pantheon under the theonyms Aphrodite and Adonis. Their popularity would grow into an eclectic form of cult worship of pervasive influence. During the Greco-Roman period, the cult of Adonis served as a tool by which women could centralize their power in society through the monopolization of rituals, poetics, and displays of metaphysics.
Unlike the myths of ancient Mesopotamia, the myths of ancient Greece were largely passed down through oral tradition. This practice allowed for a horizontal dissemination in the generation of myth narratives. Individuals from various socioeconomic backgrounds could influence the formation of their mythos. This tradition was vastly different from the ancient Mesopotamian vertical transference of myth narratives, where an educated scribe or cleric generated myths through writing. The articulation of myth narratives through writing meant they were less malleable when being disseminated to the public. Since literacy was limited to the Mesopotamian upper class, many myths served as propaganda for the societal elite. While the mythology of ancient Greece had many similarities with ancient Mesopotamia, the tone and style were different. Greek myth narratives, because of their oral transmission, served as “life lessons” rather than a means of legitimizing the state. As such, the ancient Greeks valued poetic storytelling through the use of distinct verbalized metrical styles. While this oral tradition birthed a unique medium of poetics, it meant that the quantity of written source material from the ancient Greek mythos was limited. Documentation of Greek myth narratives would largely be done centuries after its original formation. Thus, the following contents may pull from Roman sources when trying to identify details in ancient Greek mythology and historiography.
When comparing the myth narratives surrounding Adonis and Tammuz, we find that their stories are almost identical. Both deities explain the changing of seasons through a system of rebirth, they are both torn between two worlds, two goddesses, and are both figures of significant cult worship. Sources indicate that the reverence and worship of these two figures were primarily conducted by women. The cult of Tammuz explicitly informed the cult of Adonis and in many cases the two were synonymous with each other. However, where the cult of Tammuz was centered around farming practices, the cult of Adonis became a serious political force. Initial indications of this cult worship in the Greek world are from the poet Sappho of Lesbos, where she recounts the story of Aphrodite and Adonis. Sappho writes: “Ah, for Adonis! / See, he is dying, / Delicate, lovely, / Slender Adonis. // Ah, for Adonis! / Weep, O ye maidens, / Beating your bosoms, / Rending your tunics // O Cytherea [Aphrodite], / Hasten, for never / Loved thou another / As thy Adonis” (24). In the story, Adonis is slain by a wild boar and as he dies Aphrodite holds him, weeping. Aphrodite grows adonis flowers out of the soil stained with his blood to honor him. It is an emotional story meant to symbolize the end of summer and the coming of winter. Women, as Sappho indicates, are called upon to play the role of Aphrodite in a vociferous display of misery. The women would remove their top garments and beat their chests. This display would have been seen as abhorrent in Greek society. Women were expected to cover their breasts and head when leaving the house. Ancient Greek women were regarded as property of their male kin, with their primary objective in life being childbearing. Sappho challenges this societal institution, and most interestingly calls upon a specific group of women. In the poem’s second stanza, Sappho proclaims: “Weep, O ye maidens” (24). The translation of “maiden” from Ancient Greek is used to refer to a “kore:” a young female, assumed to be a virgin, who has not married or has not consummated her marriage. Women who did consummate their marriage were called “nymphe,” or brides, and it was only when they had children that they finally became “gyne,” or women. Young women were seen as the “freest” because they would not have the responsibilities that came with marriage. In one of his plays, Sophocles said that “young women in their fathers’ homes lead the sweetest lives of all” (Blundell 124; Hemingway). By calling upon these women, Sappho was displaying the power they had as a community. It's believed that the cult of Adonis started on the island of Lesbos, and with Sappho’s fragment being the first known mention of the cult in Greek society, it’s possible she may have been a key facilitator in its rise to prominence.
Sappho as a key leader in spreading the cult of Adonis throughout the Mediterranean would be congruent with what we knew about her existence. She was an accomplished lyrical poet who came from a noble family on the Aegean Island of Lesbos. Her parents gave her an education, and she would eventually head a thiasos, which were academies devoted to the worship of a god or set of gods. Later sources indicate that Sappho’s thiasos was for young unmarried women devoted to the worship of Aphrodite and her son Eros. However, these details on Sappho’s life largely come from the Suidas, a Byzantine lexicon written over a thousand years later. In that time frame many of Sappho’s works were lost or deliberately destroyed. Historical obfuscation regarding a cult of Adonis would have served the interests of the patriarchal elite in Greece and later Roman society. The cult of Adonis threatened the status-quo, as it sought to create a collective of women who challenged tradition. Greco-Roman society would have worked to revise Sappho’s historical narrative from a woman resisting cultural precedent, to someone teaching young women how to be devoted to their husbands. Exclusive worship of Aphrodite, as the goddess of fertility and sexual desire, would have served this purpose. The cult of Adonis characterized by Sappho would eventually spread East, away from the Greek heartland. Adonis would gain major influence on the island of Cyprus, where he would become a central figure in worship. According to Stanford University’s geospatial network model, traveling fast in the spring from Mytilene, Lesbos to Akama Pr., Cyprus would have only taken five days on the open sea during the Roman period (Scheidel). Sappho’s resources and quick access to the sea meant that her acolytes could have easily spread their practices throughout the Mediterranean. It’s no coincidence that the cult would also gain prominence in Byblos, a city in the Roman Province of Syria-Phoenicia, where the cult most likely encountered its Eastern counterpart, the cult of Tammuz. While the cult of Adonis was most definitely born from the cult of Tammuz, it is unclear how that happened. The cult of Adonis was its own entity; therefore, it likely formed its own identity before melding with its Eastern equivalent. This would suggest that Tammuz, along with elements of cult worship made their way to Greece, but not the cult itself.
Statuette of Adonis-Tammuz from Lebanon (100-150).
Woman with Wax Tablets and Stylus from Italy (50-79).
Relief-carved Fragment from Persepolis from Iran (486-465 BCE).
The explicit connection of Adonis and Tammuz can be most obviously found in the art depictions of the Greco-Roman period, such as with The Statuette of Adonis-Tammuz (Lebanon, Classical antiquity, 100-150, sculpture). It depicts Adonis, as a bronze figure, gesturing outwardly in a regal manner. Abnormally, the figure is shown in a more effeminate hairstyle, not common to Roman men. The hairstyle resembles that of Woman with Wax Tablets and Stylus (Italy, Classical antiquity, 50-79, fresco), a fresco often misinterpreted to be a portrait of Sappho. Consequently, beardless details of the statuette harken back to Julius Caesar solidifying it as a Roman style for men through his fastidious grooming routine. Caesar, often being referred to as an effeminate man, or to quote Curio: "’every woman's man and every man's woman’” (Olson 182). Greeks, Macedonians, and Romans famously viewed the men of Southwest Asia, particularly Persians, as effeminate. Hence, it would be understandable to depict Adonis in such a way. A more astute observation would be Persian depictions of themselves such as the relief portrait of Artaxerxes II on his tomb, Apadana Hall, or the Relief-carved Fragment from Persepolis (Iran, Persian art, 486-465 BCE, carved stone). The hair styles are almost identical to the Statuette of Adonis-Tammuz, with their intricate shoulder-length curls. Additionally, the figure looks like it should be wearing a Persian hat, with its creased and flattened set of top hair. That combined with the beardless nature and toga makes one believe that the statuette is ethnically Greek and Persian. The blending of two deities, from two different cultures, who largely serve the same purpose, is a fascinating display of syncretism. Worshippers would have had to reconcile with conflicting expressions of myth narratives, ritualistic ideation, language, and cultural intricacies. It’s possible that the overcoming of these barriers and conjoining of cults was due to political necessity. At this time, women all throughout the Mediterranean were dealing with the same oppressive structures. They could not afford a territorial war over cult dominance; thus, syncretic forms of worship were adopted.
This shift in Tammuz becoming an effeminate character can also be understood through the androgyny of Adonis. According to the Hellenistic scholar Ptolemaeus Chennus, documented by Photius the Great, Ptolemaeus conveys that “Adonis, having become androgynous, behaved as a man for Aphrodite and as a woman for Apollo” (Photius 190.42). Adonis, as a god of beauty and desire, did not just gain the admiration of a specific gender. In the Greek mythos, Adonis was described as having many lovers, including other male presenting deities the likes of Hercules, Dionysus, and Apollo. This reference to the behavior of Adonis describes the role he’d fulfill during intercourse. Ancient Greeks tied gender expression to the penetrative and receptive roles during intercourse, Adonis would fulfill those roles depending on his lover. The androgynous nature of Adonis unveils a potential clue behind his worship. Adonis, as an androgynous figure, can traverse the realm of both genders. In a highly gendered society, by which women were regarded as inferior, the worship of Aphrodite would not have fulfilled the metaphysical need to extend within the boundaries of patriarchy. It’s possible that women made Adonis androgynous overtime as they came to this realization.
In the ancient Greek comedy Lysistrata by Aristophanes, the women of Athens and Sparta withhold sex from the men until the men end the Peloponnesian War (431–404 BC). Our Athenian female protagonist, Lysistrata, at one point seizes the Acropolis of Athens and with it, the Athenian treasury which is needed to fund the war. After a relatively playful battle for the gates of the Acropolis between the Athenian men and women, the magistrate arrives with his police force. The magistrate monologues a misogynistic tirade about the nature of women and blames the men of Athens for not controlling them. In his rant, the magistrate mentions the cult of Adonis, he says “Adonis been wept to death on the terraces / … a woman, throwing herself about in a dance / Lopsided with drink, was shrilling out ‘Adonis, / Woe for Adonis’ / And there the woman, up to the ears in wine, / Was screaming ‘Weep for Adonis’ on the house-top, / The scoundrelly politician, that lunatic ox, / Bellowing bad advice through tipsy shrieks: / Such are the follies wantoning in them” (Aristophanes). In this segment, the magistrate complains that the worship of Adonis is turning women into “scoundrelly politicians” and “lunatic oxen:” the ox being an overtly masculine symbol, in ancient Greece. Aristophanes, like Sappho, mentions the weeping for Adonis as a key ritualistic practice. This time, however, Aristophanes reveals that the true nature of this practice is a defiance of Greek patriarchy. Through the act of wailing from the rooftops, the women become astute observers that irritate the men. They morph into political analysts who make their voices heard and are even compared to men. Adonis then fills his androgynous role as a figure who can guide women into the realm of men. By harnessing the spirit of Adonis, women are granted the ability to insert themselves in perceived masculine traditions. While the details of what the Athenian women are saying is not conveyed, one can confer that “bellowing of bad advice” is the engagement in political debate. Since women are excised from the political sphere, they use Adonis as a means of voicing their political opinions. Aristophanes, like many comics, was known to base his writings off reality. From this fact it would seem the cult of Adonis, several hundred years after Sappho, grew into a pervasive political force which threatened to topple existing power structures.
Women, since the beginning of written history, have been subjected to oppression through the abuse of hierarchy. This oppression, however, did not come without its fair share of resistance or breaks in cultural norms. From the Oracle of Delphi to the cult of Adonis, and the eventual cult of Diana; women defiantly set their boundaries throughout ancient Greece. They worked in changing the perceived reality of existence through the creation of myth narratives, poetry, art, and ritual. Through the shared gender of women, the cult of Adonis served as a unifying political force which shook the foundations of ancient Greek society. In essence, Adonis fulfilled his purpose as a god of rebirth for which women could hope for the death of patriarchal tradition, or in the lyrical expression of Sappho: “Ah, for Adonis! / No more at vintage / Time will he come with / Bloom of the meadows” (24).
Work Cited (Mesopotamia)
Al-Sheikhly, Omar F., and Ahmad E. Aidek. “Queens of the Night, the Owls of Iraq and Syria - Species, Current Distribution, and Conservation Status.” Owls: Clever Survivors, edited by Heimo Mikkola, IntechOpen, 2023, https://www.intechopen.com/chapters/85703.
Bowen, Joshua, and Megan Lewis. Learn to Read Ancient Sumerian: An Introduction for Complete Beginners. Digital Hammurabi Press, 2020.
Church of England. Holy Bible (King James Version). Christian Art Publishers, 2020.
“Dumuzid's Dream (English Translation).” The Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature (ETCSL), University of Oxford, 1998, https://etcsl.orinst.ox.ac.uk/section1/tr143.htm.
Foster, Benjamin Read. Before the Muses: An Anthology of Akkadian Literature. Pennsylvania State University Press, 2005.
Frankfort, H. “A Tammuz Ritual in Kurdistan(?).” Iraq, vol. 1, no. 2, 1934, pp. 137-145. JSTOR, https://www-jstor-org.norcocollege.idm.oclc.org/stable/4241568?searchText=tammuz&searchUri=%2Faction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dtammuz%26so%3Drel&ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_search_gsv2%2Fcontrol&refreqid=fastly-default%3A5e0780f9296bb79473b02f23b985aecf.
Mark, Joshua J., and Osama Shukir. “Gilgamesh, Enkidu, and the Netherworld.” World History Encyclopedia, 14 December 2022, https://www.worldhistory.org/article/2128/gilgamesh-enkidu-and-the-netherworld/.
Meek, Theophile James. “Canticles and the Tammuz Cult.” The American Journal of Semitic Languages and Literatures, vol. 39, no. 1, 1992, pp. 1-14. JSTOR, https://www-jstor-org.norcocollege.idm.oclc.org/stable/528683?searchText=tammuz&searchUri=%2Faction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dtammuz%26so%3Drel&ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_search_gsv2%2Fcontrol&refreqid=fastly-default%3Aedcd507e19ba488e37c4ee73bebed7bf&seq=1.
Nasr, Seyyed Hossein, et al. The Study Quran: A New Translation and Commentary. HarperOne, 2015.
Olson, Kelly. “Masculinity, Appearance, and Sexuality: Dandies in Roman Antiquity.” Journal of the History of Sexuality, vol. 23, no. 2, 2014, pp. 182-205. JSTOR, https://www-jstor-org.norcocollege.idm.oclc.org/stable/24616489?searchText=kelly+olson&searchUri=%2Faction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dkelly%2Bolson%26so%3Drel&ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_search_gsv2%2Fcontrol&refreqid=fastly-default%3A33e0221f7d7ac924f00691172e38.
Rubio, Gonzalo. “READING SUMERIAN NAMES, I: ENSUHKEŠDANNA AND BABA.” Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 62, 2010, pp. 29-43. JSTOR, https://www-jstor-org.norcocollege.idm.oclc.org/stable/41103869.
Work Cited (Greece)
Aristophanes. Lysistrata. Translated by Jack Lindsay, Project Gutenberg, 2005.
Blundell, Sue. Women in Ancient Greece. Harvard University Press, 1995.
Hemingway, Colette. “Women in Classical Greece.” The Metropolitan Museum of Art, October 2004, https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/wmna/hd_wmna.htm.
Olson, Kelly. “Masculinity, Appearance, and Sexuality: Dandies in Roman Antiquity.” Journal of the History of Sexuality, vol. 23, no. 2, 2014, pp. 182-205. JSTOR, https://www-jstor-org.norcocollege.idm.oclc.org/stable/24616489?searchText=kelly+olson&searchUri=%2Faction%2FdoBasicSearch%3FQuery%3Dkelly%2Bolson%26so%3Drel&ab_segments=0%2Fbasic_search_gsv2%2Fcontrol&refreqid=fastly-default%3A33e0221f7d7ac924f00691172e38.
Photius, et al. “Bibliotheca.” Codices 186-222 [Extracts], University of Wisconsin-Madison, https://www.tertullian.org/fathers/photius_copyright/photius_05bibliotheca.htm.
Sappho. The Poems of Sappho: An Interpretative Rendition into English. Translated by John Mayers O'Hara, East India Publishing Company, 2023.
Scheidel, Walter, et al. “ORBIS.” The Stanford Geospatial Network Model of the Roman World, Stanford University, https://orbis.stanford.edu. Accessed 20 October 2024.
Images of the Public Domain