Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Sep. 2nd - Dec. 12th, 2023
The exploratory age in human history marked an important shift in global power dynamics. Civilizations in their quest for dominance generated new strategies in the acquisition of resources. Through the sharing of technologies, introduction of tributary systems, conquest of foreign lands, and enslavement of foreign peoples the Age of Exploration (15th-17th century) drastically changed global hegemony.
One of the first civilizations to expand on the curiosities of exploration was the Ming Dynasty (1368-1644). Existing as the overthrowers of the Mongol ruled Yuan Dynasty (1271-1368), the Ming Dynasty aimed to keep control of its newly acquired dynasty by going on a military offensive. The Ming Dynasty, led by Chinese Emperor Yong-Lo (1360-1424) took China by force. He led military campaigns into Mongol territories, constructed a massive naval fleet, and expanded upon a tributary system which ensured the submission of nearly 50 states. Ming exploration was successfully led by the Muslim court eunuch Zheng He (1371-1435) and his fleet of junk ships (“treasure ships”).
The primary motivation for this exploration was to accumulate wealth and “exotic” treasures for the Ming court. However, the focus on exploration also existed as a means of displaying the Ming Dynasty’s “strength, power, and prestige.” Grand boasts of military might prevented invasion from foreign militaries. In the words of Sun Tzu, it is important to “appear weak when you are strong, and strong when you are weak” (The Art of War). While the Ming garnered a massive military, it was notably ineffective, as proven later in history with the Manchu invasion. Zheng He’s exploration served as a feigning military might. The fleet sought to appear strong. If states feared the prestige presented by the Ming naval fleet, they wouldn’t risk denying tribute to Ming rulers. This tactic solidified the Ming Dynasty’s legitimacy as a new empire and ensured the submission of smaller states. For the Ming Dynasty this appeared to be a “paper tiger” moment, as they quickly shut down continued exploration.
Meanwhile, Europe was beginning to launch their own naval forces across the Atlantic coast of Africa and into the Indian Ocean. After the Reconquista (1000-1492) of the Iberian Peninsula by Christian Kingdoms in Northern Spain, Christian forces began to conquer beyond their previously established territories. Christian forces from the Iberian Peninsula, namely the Portuguese, began conquering Muslim kingdoms in North Africa. A turning point in this conquest was the Battle of Ceuta (1415) which established a military presence across the Strait of Gibraltar. This gave the Portuguese more military capabilities in North Africa. The conquering of Ceuta by the Portuguese meant access to a plethora of novel nautical maps and skilled Jewish cartographers. Prince Henry the Navigator (1394-1460) took these cartographers and nautical maps back to Portugal. This decision brought about European exploration and expansion.
European exploration was motivated by four notions: gold, god, glory, and Prester John. Gold was the desire to extract riches from Africa and Asia. God existed as an evangelizing tool and motivation to conquer Muslim territories. Glory was two-part, a legal distinction of gaining hereditary titles in the homeland for conquering new territory abroad; and personal prestige. The myth of Prester John (a fictitious Christian ruler in Africa) served as further motivation for European conquests, as a yearning grew to unite the two civilizations. Interestingly, there were Christian kingdoms throughout the regions of Ethiopia, Eritrea, and Nubia which likely fueled the myth of Prester John. Prince Henry the Navigator, using his newly acquired navigational tools, would eventually sail Westward into the Atlantic. There he would find the islands of Madeira and Azores. These islands were resource rich and paved the way for a new economic system based on slavery, servitude, and human trafficking. Portuguese explorers would sail down the West African coast and start a trade network which funneled enslaved peoples to plantation colonies. They would use their advanced weaponry to subjugate African peoples and continue their conquests Eastward toward the Indian Ocean.
European expansionism became a race for dominance in resource rich regions of the globe. This would prove extremely tragic, as it also became a race to dehumanize those deemed marginally “different” from themselves. Interestingly, there are similarities in the conquest of both Portugal and the Ming Dynasty. The spark of “exploration” came out of a military desire to preserve one's own empire. In both instances, the two empires sought out the subjugation of other civilizations as a way of solidifying their own. The most important factor of this being the acquisition of resources which would ensure hegemonic dominance. Perhaps where the Ming Dynasty went astray in their proto-colonial pursuits is the lack of a mythos surrounding expansion. If the Ming Dynasty surrounded its conquest in a mythical persona of divinity and legal tradition of commissioned conquests, like the Portuguese, the history of China may have turned out drastically different.
The Old World and the New World
In the year 1492, the merging of the Old World and New World commenced in what is now referred to as the Columbian Exchange. The colliding of these two worlds was a step in making the world far more connected. A great homogenization commenced as societies exchanged resources, riches, plants, animals, and diseases. However, this great homogenization came at a cost of intense death, destruction, and existential reexamination. Centuries later, our modern day society has constructed narratives around these events to allow us to more easily comprehend the horrors that ensued. While the historical facts are far less fantastical, they reveal an important notion. That history, when examined properly, is far more complex, undefined, and unmotivated by strict notions of good and evil.
The year 1492 saw the completion of the Reconquista (718-1492), which was led by Queen Isabella I of Castile (1474-1504) and King Ferdinand II of Aragon (1479-1516) under the banner of their newly united Spain. After the completion of the Reconquista, the Catholic Monarchs of Spain issued the expulsion of Sephardic Jews in the Alhambra Decree and generated the Capitulations of Santa Fe. This was a document which detailed a reconnaissance mission, led by Christopher Columbus (1451-1506), that would journey westward through the Atlantic. Upon this voyage, Columbus would unveil a continent previously unknown to the Old World. In that new continent, Columbus would meet new peoples that would unravel the Abrahamic theological narratives about the creation of humanity. The myth of the “noble savage” would generate new discussions on the nature of humanity throughout Renaissance Europe, but in the face of all this, these narratives would prove detrimental to New World peoples. In the expeditions of Columbus he would meet two very different ethnic groups: the friendly and peaceful Taínos, and the violent cannibalistic Caribs. These two polar extremes would fuel stereotypical myths of Indigenous peoples in the Americas for centuries. It is these fictitious narratives which would serve to justify colonial subjugation of Indigenous Peoples.
Months after Columbus’s first expedition he would undertake a new task of setting up colonies in the Americas. With a total of 17 ships and 1,500 men, Columbus would bring new plants and animals never before seen in the Americas. Tragically, however, Columbus and his men would bring new pathogens which would kill 90% of the Indigenous population. This unintentional epidemic is often credited as an intentional genocide by modern-day viewpoints. The need to explain away the horrors of history through a binary lens of morality is often fueled by the human need to latch onto stories. Many human beings mean to make sense of our modern post-colonial and neo-colonial world by narrativizing our descent into an “apathetic madness.” Though much of histories colonial exploits can be explained away with a full understanding of the historical trends in that era. When examining colonial empires we can easily find an arrogance, ignorance, Eurocentric and Christocentric view of the world. One need only look at the Treaty of Tordesillas (1494) which sought to divide the entire world into the regions of Spain and Portugal. However, this view of the world was fueled by a variety of factors. A somewhat isolated Europe was inundated with the riches of the Silk Road, stories of wealthy African empires like that of Mansa Musa’s (reigned 1312-1337), the ugly-head of religious insecurity in the aftermath of the Black Death (1346-1352), and the dominance of Ottoman trade throughout the Mediterranean. Factors like these pushed Europeans westward into these previously unexplored territories. In a way Christian Europeans wanted to expand Europe and its Christian homogenization, as we see with the mass forced Christian conversions of Indigenous Peoples in the Americas. For the Christians of Europe, more Christians meant more Crusaders, more souls saved, and more wealth for previously established Christian-led empires.
It is apparent that modern humans have not changed and arguably have become slightly less intellectually inclined. The rise of the internet, social media, short form content, a lack of reading, media literacy, and unwillingness to learn about other cultures (specifically American unwillingness) has led to a narrativizing of a wide range of issues. Instead of looking at the motivations for the actions of global actors, we narrativize it to something which fits our worldview. Those “different” from us are deemed as slanted more towards “evilness.” Countries and nations suddenly do things out of spite, rather than economic insecurity, class imbalance or ideological assertions. Humanities' insistent need to simplify a complex world comes from a lack of education surrounding history, economic trends, and the political distributions of power, violence, and authority. Many of the narratives present in the Age of Exploration still infuse our modern day narratives of ourselves. Much of our lives in the modern world are steeped in misconceptions which can only be quelled through a rich understanding of history. And much of modern-day anxieties stem from a lack of understanding the external systems which cause our anxiety. The systems which we have no control over.
In essence, our trend of trying to “make sense of everything modern” has led to further confusion about what it means to be modern. Our hyper-connectedness over a synthetic collection of data floating around in some incomprehensible ether has predictably led to further alienation, isolating, and dogmatism. It is only through reinvigorating a culture around learning and especially learning of the past, can humanity return to that which makes us human.
The Quest for Silver
Silver and the quest to gain it, became the catalyst for global trade networks around the world. Through Spanish conquests of the Americas and exploitative labor practices in their colonies, the production of silver paved the way for the global trade network seen today. When examining the 16th century, it is apparent that the silver trade led to significant economic, political, and social changes for people around the world.
Along the Andean Mountain ranges in South America there existed a civilization, known as the Incan Empire (1200-1533). When the Spaniards arrived in the region, the Incan Empire was in a severe state. Atahualpa (1502-1533) was the ruler of the Incas during this time and was just beginning his emperorship when he was invited by conquistador Francisco Pizarro (1478-1541) to meet in Cajamarca. What was a meeting, was quickly revealed to be an ambush by Pizarro and his men. This was known as the Battle of Cajamarca (1532) and led to the capture of Atahualpa. In captivity he was held for ransom by the Spanish. The Spanish requested a large sum of gold in exchange for the Incan ruler, but when the Incan people paid it the Spanish killed Atahualpa anyways. This marked a turning point in the Spanish conquest of the Americas. The Spanish Empire would begin setting up the Viceroyalty of New Spain (North America) and the Viceroyalty of Peru (South America). By 1545 the Spanish Empire began the extraction of mineral ores in Cerro Potosí, a silver ore rich mountain located in modern-day Bolivia. For centuries the Spanish would exploit indigenous workers in the mining process, utilizing the Mita public service system developed by the Incan Empire. The miners would experience horrible conditions that would lead to high rates of death and disease. Much of the silver would be exported to Manila, Philippines through a cyclical trade network in the Pacific Ocean using transport ships known as Manila Galleons.
It is through these Pacific and Atlantic maritime trade routes set up by the Spanish that we see a global shift in economic, political, and social policies. Economically, 80% of silver from the Americas would be funneled through Manila into mainland Asia. There it would upturn the value of China’s paper currency and pave the way for a new economic system. In Spain political change would occur, as word from Spanish colonies in the Americas would reveal the horrid slave-like working conditions which would spark debate around colonial labor practices. In the year 1542, the Spanish Empire would impart Los Leyes Nuevas, which would ban slavery throughout its empire. However, much of these slave-like working conditions would continue as Los Leyes Nuevas could not be enforced in many of the colonies. Socially, it is apparent that cultural practices of indigenous peoples across South America completely changed. The Incas went from being ruled by a god-king and building wondrous structures like Machu Picchu, to being forced to work in extreme working conditions for the Spanish Empire. In Spain, the debates around the morality and ethics of these forced labor practices also denoted a cultural shift. The banning of slavery was a massive economic, political, and social choice for the Spanish Empire, as their participation in the coming Atlantic Slave Trade (1501-1867) would be greatly reduced.
When examining the trends of the 16th century we find that much of it aligns with our current capitalist global trade networks. Much of the products in the developed world are made through exploitative labor practices in developing nations and shipped across vast oceans. Many individuals in developed nations do not know the hands in which these products were manufactured. In fact, much of our modern-day technologies are sourced from various places around the world. Cobalt is mined in the Congo, many garments are manufactured in Bangladesh and these are all obtained and manufactured in highly exploitative labor conditions. Thus, when examining the past we see that a precedent was set for our present and possibly our future. The silver trade of the 16th century resulted in a massive global shift in which its repercussions are felt today.
A Breif History of Japan
Over the course of several hundred years, Japan would unify under the leadership of three rulers. These three rulers and their unique way of leadership would drastically set the course for Japan’s history. In a way, these three rulers each represented three phases by which Japanese militarism, heritage, and statehood was changed.
The Japanese social hierarchy between 1185 and 1868 was a caste system. Within this caste system existed the daimyo (Lords) who ruled over states in a fractured Japan. These daimyo consolidated their power through the use of samurai: a highly effective warrior class. However, due to little power from Japan’s Emperor and Shogun, the bureaucratic authority to control the daimyo and their provinces was absent. This led to an era known as the Sengoku period (about 1467-1568), in which various daimyo fought each other over land and resources. It wasn’t until the rise of brutal warlord and daimyo to the Owari province, Oda Nobunaga (1534-1582), that Japan would begin to unify. Nobunaga in his quest for power would adopt “dishonorable” means of combat. He would do this by utilizing the firearm technology brought over by Portuguese ships. Nobunaga would conquer half of Japan and would make many enemies along the way. One of these enemies would betray Nobunaga and ambush him, leading to Nobunaga’s death. However, his legacy would reveal a crack in the Japanese social hierarchy. With the use of firearms, suddenly the lifestyle of the samurai as a warrior class started becoming obsolete. Now peasants could wield similar power and force with very little training, due to the innovation of firearms. This shook at the foundations of Japanese nobility and the distributions of power used in the subjugation of Japanese peasantry.
After the death of Nobunaga, Japan would once again break out into civil war. This would lead to Toyotami Hideyoshi (1536-1598) avenging Nobunaga’s death. By 1590, Japan would become unified under Hideyoshi’s leadership. During his time he would impart Japanese societal reforms which would assist in consolidating his power. Firstly, Hideyoshi and the ruling class feared a peasant uprising. Thus, he enacted the prohibition law of katana kari (“Sword Hunt”). This law ensured that weapons culturally associated with the samurai (along with firearms) would be confiscated from townships in the countryside. This was seen as a cultural attack, as many of these weapons were heirlooms passed down from generation to generation. Through the fear of a militarized peasantry and daimyo betray, Hideyoshi maintained strict control. Samurai and the family of daimyo would mainly be confined to urban centers where Hideyoshi could keep tight knit control. Hideyoshi sought to double-down on the feudal system's rigid structure in order to preserve the noble classes. In several ways, firearms were a driving force in the Japanese nobility reacting the way it did. Firearms were feared to serve as a great equalizer which could overpower the samurai: the last line of defense for the nobility of Japan.
In the aftermath of a failed invasion of Korea, Hideyoshi would die and be replaced by Japan’s third “Great Unifier,” Tokugawa leyasu (1543-1616). This change in leadership would once again split Japan, however Tokugawa would take Japan in the year 1600. He would declare himself the Shogun of Japan and his leadership would usher in a new era known as the Edo period (1603-1868). During this period, Japan’s ruling classes would develop a fear of foreign influence and especially Christianization of the country. This period of statehood would lean heavily isolationist in its foreign policy decisions. Outside influence would be heavily monitored and conducted mostly via trading with the Dutch. While the Edo period had strict foreign policy and social order, the people of Japan enjoyed an era of peace, economic growth, and new found appreciation for the arts. After centuries of chaos, the state achieved some sense of stability despite the glaring social inequalities.
In the modern era, Japan still has many of the social issues remnant of its past. Japan still imposes anti-immigration, which has led to a severe decline in population. There are several reasons for this attitude, but one can be attributed to a maintaining of cultural stability. However, there are obvious leanings towards xenophobia and ethnocentrism. This obsession with “preserving culture” is revealed when observing Japan’s modern social issues. Japan is the only country that still engages in whaling, under the guise of “culture.” Gender norms in Japan are not nearly inline with other developed nations. This has led to an increase in sexism, homophobia and transphobia on the governmental level. The bureaucracy of Japan leans pretty clearly towards conservatism and nationalism with the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) being the largest.
While the Japan of the 15th and 16th centuries may be drastically different from what it is today, it is clear that there are strong cultural ties to that era. Japan’s past still has great influence over the attitudes of modern-day peoples. Tradition, heritage, social hierarchies, and the romanticizing of history lead to the nationalist sentiments common throughout Japan. In fact, most modern nationalistic and conservative political movements depend on a romanticizing or near-fictionalization of history to generate national fervor. Japan with its rich history is no exception to this fact.
Reformation and the Dutch
In the face of European disunity, war and chaos after the Protestant Reformation (1517-1648), the Dutch became extremely influential in global trade markets. Their quest for freedom through a revolt against Spanish rule would lead to long lasting economic and scientific impacts around the globe. It is here where the Protestant Reformation and subsequent Dutch Revolt (1566-1648) allowed for the societal freedoms that would make the Dutch a world power.
Abuse by the Catholic Church through utilizing the Sale of Indulgences system was illuminated by the monk Martin Luther (1483-1546). He revealed this abuse by posting complaints on the cathedral door in Wittenberg, Germany. It is there where Luther would begin preaching sola fide (“by faith alone”) and sola scriptura (“by scripture alone”). His movement would gain steam through media campaigns and would grow into a “mass movement” within the Holy Roman Empire (800-1806). The movement called for a theological change, where an individual's personal relationship with God superseded Papal Authority. This caught the ire of the Holy Roman Emperor and led to the excommunication of Martin Luther from the Catholic Church. Martin Luther was protected by Fredrick The Wise (1463-1525) and taken to Wartburg Castle. It is here where Luther begins translating the Holy Bible into German. This translation and the subsequent printing allowed commoners to read “the word of God.” What followed this act was a schism between the Catholic Church and the burgeoning Protestant Christian denominations. This schism led to a rupturing of power centers in Europe. Religious wars would ensue which would result in the death of millions, due to battle, famine, and disease.
During this era, the Dutch would begin to start their own revolt against Spanish rule. Here the Dutch would begin their resistance through iconoclasm: rejecting the beliefs, traditions, values, practices, and iconography of the Catholic Church. In 1588, the Dutch would gain their independence from the Habsburg Dynasty of Spain (1516-1700) and form the Dutch Republic (1588-1795) under seven united provinces. This would allow the Dutch to undergo The Dutch Golden Age (1575-1675) where trade, economics, science, art, and military prowess would flourish for Dutch society. The new found quest for freedom and cooperation would give way to collective investments, publicly traded stocks for all citizens, and the Netherlands becoming a sanctuary for persecuted peoples. The arrival of Protestantism in the Netherlands is what implanted the seeds of religious freedom. It is this desire for free worship which gave way for the desire of political freedom and self-determination of the Dutch people. The theological underpinnings of Protestantism also subverted the theology of the Catholic Church. If humanity could find salvation through their personal relationship with God, then the religious authorities within the Church would no longer serve much use. It is likely that these theological leanings of personal freedom led to the flourishing of Dutch society. This assertion becomes evident when examining the public trading of the Dutch East India Company (VOC) in the 17th century. People no matter their gender or class could all share in the riches of the VOC, thus making Dutch society fairly wealthy.
Protestantism by use of its theological, political, and cultural resistance to the Catholic Church caused great suffering across Europe. However, it also led to the development of a drastically different world. What followed the death and despair of medieval warfare was a new found freedom for worshipers, commoners, merchants, and noblemen. For specific societies, like the Dutch, this meant a new purpose. It meant taking one's destiny back from the Church and placing it in one’s own hands.
The Atlantic Slave Trade
Slavery has existed since the earliest known remnants of civilization. In 1640, it would expand greatly via the influence of European colonial powers. The reasons for this expansion reflect the massive global economic shifts of the era. Specifically, the demand for sugar, laborers, rise of the Dutch, reliability of forced labor, and its monetary incentives led to changes in the Atlantic Labor markets.
Atlantic Labor systems relied on a triangular trade network in which raw materials from the Americas would be shipped to Europe. Those raw materials would be manufactured into goods which were in turn traded for African slaves. From there African slaves were sent to the Americas to produce more raw materials and repeat the cycle. This generated massive amounts of wealth for societies engaged in the triangular trade and increased demand for luxury items (such as sugar) produced in the Americas. As Spanish and Portuguese colonial influence declined, the Dutch would begin dominating Atlantic slave markets. They would raid Portuguese ships, create the Dutch West India Company, and annex Northeastern Brazil from the Portuguese. This period marked a shift from Habsburg and Iberian supremacy (1492-1640), to the dominance of Dutch, English and French powers (1640-1800s).
The systems of forced labor and slavery existed in Africa long before the arrival of Europeans. War prisoners or captured individuals of rival tribes were utilized in forced labor practices and sometimes sold into existing slave trades. When Europeans arrived in Africa it coincided with their "unveiling" of the Americas, establishment of plantation colonies, and utilization of forced labor practices with Indigenous American peoples. This new societal structuring necessitated an abundance of labor to keep up with domestic and maritime profit seeking demands. Europeans capitalized on this labor market in Africa, greatly expanding the slave trade. Upon Dutch dominance of the Atlantic Slave Trade (1526-1867), the trade had increased seven-fold. The slave trade was brutal and engaged in dehumanizing rituals, such as human branding.
Dehumanizing measures became justified in the demand for luxury goods and increases in profit. In Africa during the 15th and 16th centuries, Europeans wanted gold which later expanded to sugar in the Americas. Domestically, many European companies didn't care how these luxury items were acquired as long as necessary profit margins were maintained. As the luxury items became household goods, the demand became more intense which exacerbated labor markets. Furthermore, there was a shortage of laborers which arose during the 17th century. This combined with the cheapness and reliability of slaves over indentured servants continued the practice for centuries.
The key factors regarding changes in Atlantic Labor systems centered around the maximization of profits. More specifically, mercantilist labor traditions facilitated competition between nation's in their quest for global monetary dominance. The outsourcing of laborers via enslaved peoples meant higher profits for said nation. Slavery also generated a system of high export and low import. This was preferable for mercantilist labor practices because it meant more precious metals (the signifier of wealth) for a nation. In many ways, this paved the way for modern capitalist labor practices. While modern slavery has been abolished there are still systems akin to it which are necessitated by competitive labor markets. Many revolve around the undervaluation of labor, but some can be as extreme as forced prison labor, or debt slavery.
The Industrial Revolution
The Industrial Revolution (1760 – 1840) drastically changed the way in which humans interacted with each other. Our production of goods, processes of labor, notions of time, places of dwelling and gender dynamics quickly shifted. Cultural stretches in the realm of fashion, demand for a multifunctional fabric, the necessities of new technology, and discovery of novel fuel sources all culminated in Britain's Industrial Revolution.
The Industrial Revolution is often attributed as the first mark of modernity. It began in England and was driven by the cotton industry in India. British trading companies, such as the East Indian Company (EIC) established trading posts in India. There they traded for indigo dyes, spices, cotton and saltpeter: a key ingredient in the manufacturing of gunpowder. Cotton was specifically in high demand back in England. This was due to rapid changes in the European fashion industry. Nobility, theater, literature and war changed the ways in which people viewed fashion. It was these views on fashion which brought about demands for high quality low cost fabrics. During this time, the fabric which met these standards was the calico: a type of Indian cotton.
The importation of calicoes upheaved the entire English textile industry. Wool was the staple of English textiles and when calicoes entered the scene, wool became obsolete to many. Without interest in wool this meant English textile workers lost business. In 1719, these workers began to riot. Their target was the EIC where rioters stormed their headquarters, blaming them for corrupting English women away from "Christian morals" and towards "extravagant spending." Women were doused in nitric acid as calico was ripped off their bodies. The Parliament of Great Britain (1707-1800) responded by passing legislation which banned calico textiles, known as the Calico Acts (1721). This was a form of economic protectionism by the government which forced domestic production of cotton.
The ban of calicoes meant that the English engaged in domestic production of cotton. However, the demand for cotton in England was high and unsustainable with the current manufacturing methods of the time. This led to a trend of English tinkers who challenged themselves in finding new manufacturing methods. From them the steam powered loom was invented. This invention required a new and more stable fuel source. Coal was the obvious choice in filling this void. With cotton coming in via free slave labor from the Americas and England sitting on an abundance of coal deposits, the industrial revolution was quickly underway. Farmers (who soon found themselves out of work) flooded cities, employed as factory workers. By 1851, urbanization saw 51% of people living in English cities. This trend created a gender gap between men and women, as new cultural notions of a "provider" and a "family manager" took place within the home. Additionally, the new economy saw time as a currency where workers were paid hourly. The factory system created new divisions in labor which led to increases of productivity, with the caveat of manufactured goods being of lower quality.
One of the major societal impacts exasperated by the Industrial Revolution revolves around the formation of the working class and labor exploitation. Society's middle class became factory owners which oversaw and dictated worker labor. In many instances working class laborers were exploited by the factory owners in order to maximize profits. It wasn't till the 19th century that we began to see the popularization of labor rights and formation of unions. Following this time period, government's began placing restrictions on child labor. Leading into the 20th century, societies which shaped our modern world (such as the Soviet Union and China) began entire revolutions against these forms of labor exploitation. However, with the current capitalist organization of the economy, labor exploitation still exists around the world. In developing nations, laborers are often at the behest of demand from developed nations. This creates severe strains on the production of goods, often resulting in child labor, low wages, and manufacturing waste. In some instances developed nations help enable organized crime groups in developing nations who oversee workers and maintain adequate production rates. United States manufactured firearms usually end up in the hands of Mexican cartels, Congolese militias are generally ignored by international powers (provided that they provide cobalt), and U.S. presence in Afghanistan saw a drastic increase in opium production. In fact, Britain's East India Company often commissioned mercenaries to dominate territories and ensure their commercial interests. Factory guards were often employed to oversee production and defend assets in "foreign lands." While modern practices in the enabling of organized crime are not likely so confrontational, it is obvious that there are trends in what government's focus on. As long as drugs keep flowing in, and gun manufacturers keep making money, the U.S. government will continue to ignore the trafficking of firearms down south. Perhaps, this is why many politicians are resistant to "common-sense" gun laws, because it would require more robust tracking of firearms. A trend which may leave a money trail right into their pockets.
Suffice it to say, the Industrial Revolution caused extensive cultural and economic shifts in how society viewed labor. It shook the political power centers of the world and changed how societies engaged with one other. Mutual benefits and profit maximization made it easier to ignore humanitarian atrocities. The Industrial Revolution sped up the world, for better or for worse. We went from quiet mornings in front of green pastures, to scoffing down toasts while looking at our watch, hoping that our boss won't fire us for being 5 minutes late.
The Enlightenment
The Enlightenment (1685-1815) was considered a period in which society transitioned into a “rational” state of being. It was an era where the ideas of the church, the monarchy, and the government were questioned. The Enlightenment saw Middle Age humanity culminate into the modern era through processes of secularization, technological progress, and tolerance.
Europe before the Enlightenment was a place in which rulers exercised absolutism. This meant that monarchical power structures were unrestrained by the institutions which allowed society to function. Absolutism relied heavily on the Divine Right of Kings (17/18th centuries) where kings were regarded as divinely chosen by God. Therefore, to disobey a monarch with said rights was akin to disobeying God. This time period is usually marked by the creation of grand-palaces and fancy theaters to demonstrate this “absolute” power. It was also marked by the overlapping of superstition and politics. Kings were said to have “supernatural powers,” allowing them to cure disease with a simple touch. Monarchs used this facade in order to legitimize their reign and demonstrate “divine right” to rule.
The birth of Enlightenment thought is often credited with French philosopher/scientist René Descartes (1595-1650). Descartes popularized the use of skepticism in challenging the authority of God, government, and even reality itself. His Meditations of First Philosophy published in 1641 articulated a process by which humanity could reject belief in order to combat deception. The document delineated the nature of one's mind and body, while also attempting to prove the existence of the world and God. To sum up Descartes' conclusions on reality he said “cogito ergo sum” or in English, “I think therefore I am.” The Enlightenment inspired other philosophical thinkers, many of whom influenced modern society, such as John Locke, Voltaire, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and Mary Wollstonecraft. In the case of Rousseau, he conveyed a methodology of coexistence known as the social contract. It is a way of living, impressed upon a society's subjects, which benefits the whole of society. For example, stealing from a shop while pretending to be a customer (shoplifting) violates the social contract because you went there under the guise of doing business and instead violated said business. This exercise of personal freedom damages the collective freedom of individuals and relays to said business that they can no longer trust their customers. The social contract in turn is a sacred unspoken rule between individuals in a society that states we must help one another. This idea coincided with John Locke and his views of personal liberty, consent to governance, private property, and political equality. These are the ideas of Liberalism and is the construct which modern society is based on.
Enlightenment philosophers revived the notions of Deism: the idea that God was a “clockmaker” who made the world and stepped away. The Deist belief in God stepped from reason, rather than revelation. It emphasized that religion should help humanity attain the heights of moral behavior and work with the mechanisms by which reality is constructed. Interestingly, these mechanized notions of reality were influenced by the technological progressions of the time. New technology saw humanity exercise greater manipulation of the natural world and with it humanity saw time as linear. Humanity was seen as progressing and propelling into a future in which reality overcame superstition and tolerance overcame cruelty. Tolerance was the glue of the social contract in which humanities new societies were envisioned. In order for everyone to coexist, the ruling authority and its subjects must exercise the capabilities of acceptance no matter religious background. This was a reaction to the violent religious wars of the era which crippled societal progress.
From these foundations Western Europe transitioned from a feudalist society ruled by absolutists, to a capitalist society whose purpose was to expand upon an individual's rights of “life, liberty and property.” The Enlightenment inspired the American Revolution (1765-1783), the French Revolution (1789-1799), Haitian Revolution (1791-1804), and reforms in England. It led to the emancipation of slaves, such as with the Haitian people, and the eventual emancipation of American slaves following the American Civil War (1861-1865). The authority of the church was lessened as countries began separating church and state. Women's rights were fought for and hurdles of inequality were overcome. The impacts of the Enlightenment were immense. They are the very foundations in which modern society is constructed and expected to function. When government's violate these basic principles it undermines the entire system by which our society functions. It is in these instances of violation and degradation that it is put upon the people to remind governing authorities of these ideals. This is why the freedom to protest, to speak freely, to express one’s own political views, and the freedom to think are so integral and vigorously fought for.
The Enlightenment was a beautiful era. Without it, society today would look very different. The philosophies of the Enlightenment set moral foundations in which societies must not drift away from. In an era in which humanity trudges into many unknowns, it is the principles of the Enlightenment which must be held onto. For us to remain just and sane, modern society shouldn’t fray from the foundations which it was built. To do this would likely return us to a time of absolute monarchs, intense political violence, and intolerance.
The French Revolution
The French Revolution (1789-1799) cemented the desire of the people to be free from the “divine right of kings.” It was a balancing of ideologies, where nationalism became opposed to monarchy, democracy opposed to tyranny, and where the ideas of liberalism began to unfold. The objectives of the French Revolution followed the ideals of freedom, nationalism, and self-determination in coexistence with a united Europe.
French society in the 1780s was suffering a massive economic crisis. The unemployment rates were 50%, people were starving, and many did not make it through winter. In contrast to the suffering of the peasant classes, the wealthy aristocracy and nobility of France was living in opulence. They lived in lavish palaces funded almost entirely by France’s colonial exploits overseas. Poverty in France was partly due to this aristocratic extravagance, but it was also due to another factor. France at the time had funded the American Revolution (1765-1783) in order to humiliate and outpower their rival England. This military spending bankrupted the country, but also gave the peasant classes new ideas on governance.
Enlightenment ideals were key in supplanting the French monarchical structure. One key figure in this part of the French revolutionary struggle was Abbé Emmanuel Sieyès (1748-1836). In his pamphlet What is the Third Estate? — Sieyès facilitated the idea that France belongs to all by incorporating French peasants and bourgeoisie, in direct opposition to the ruling 1% class. This manifesto transformed France’s Estates-General (1789) into the National Assembly (1789) by creating further divides in France’s governing powers. These transitions in French society eventually culminated into the Storming of Bastille (July, 14th. 1789) and the end to the regime. King Louis XVI of France (1754-1793) and Queen Marie Antoinette (1755-1793) became political prisoners of the revolution. They attempted to escape the new revolutionary government in what would be known as the Flight of Varennes (1791). Their goal was to meet with their royalist forces outside of Paris and retake the country. However, this plan was unsuccessful and led to the former-monarchs executions during the Reign of Terror (1793-1794). This was a period in which the newly appointed Committee of Public Safety (1793-1795) initiated executions of all alleged “sympathizers of the monarchy” and led to the death of 40,000 individuals.
The actions during and after the attempted escapes of the former-reigning monarchs terrified both the French revolutionaries and monarchs throughout Europe. In a counter-offensive to the failed counter-revolution, French revolutionary forces attempted to export their revolution to other countries. They hoped that ideas of freedom, liberty, equality, and popular sovereignty would invigorate the rest of Europe. However, this attempted ideological wildfire was miscalculated, resulting in chaos across the continent. Fear of losing all that which they had lost, France established nationalistic practices throughout the nation. A national anthem became the country's soul and the flag became its heart: to be defended in the fight for freedom. This sentiment led to victory in the Battle of Valmy (1792) against Prussian forces, and ignited the French Revolutionary Wars (1792-1802). During this period, “esteemed” military commander Napoleon Bonaparte (1769-1821) became First Consul to the French Republic (1792-1804) and eventually Emperor of the French Empire (1808-1815). This time period would become known as Napoleonic France and would lead to the Napoleonic Wars (1803-1815): a series of wars throughout the European continent in opposition to Napoleonic rule.
In the mind of Napoleon Bonaparte, he believed "Europe thus divided into nationalities freely formed and free internally, peace between States would have become easier: the United States of Europe would become a possibility." While the French Revolution was incomplete in cementing its governing values into French society, the foundational ideas (however distorted) remained. French revolutionaries in their witnessing of unjust monarchical rule, feared the return of that rule over France. Thus, the creation of national identity, separate from kingly or clerical rule, drastically changed the way France and its residents viewed itself. It was free from the constructs which had been so ingrained into the European mind. This and the Flight of Varennes ultimately led to an offensive response in defending said ideas, governing structures, and newly discovered national identity. This offensive approach terrified the European monarchies, leading to years of warfare. However, the underlying sentiment of “freeing” Europe from monarchal structures was maintained and in this quest for dominance Napoleon reinstated a French empire. Napoleon, however flawed in his approach, maintained the vision (at least militaristically) of a united Europe. Republicanism ultimately dominated its way into the modern-age and the self-determination of states, with the constraints of international coexistence solidified.
Revolutions in the Americas
The revolutions of Latin America and the Haitian Revolution (1791-804) were turning points in post-colonial reforms. The inhabitants of former-colonies solidified their desire for independence in armed revolts against colonial powers. Both revolutions required the use of a centralizing mixed-status class, stabilizing-indigenous narratives, and nationalist sentiment in their struggle for freedom.
During the mid-1700s in Latin America, Spanish colonies were relatively self-sufficient from Spain. Colonies of Spain were run by corregidores, who were administrators with judicial power in both cities and districts within the colonies. Corregidores ruled through breaking the law and exploitation of indigenous labor. In an effort to re-establish tighter control on the colonies, the Spanish monarchical powers replaced the corregidores with intendants. The intendants were far more loyal to the Spanish crown and paid well for carrying out their orders. This replacing of corregidores was also combined with the racial and class differentiations of the region. The Spanish crown preferred peninsulares (upper-classes born in Spain) rather than the European descendent creoles born in the Americas. During this period, creoles were asserting themselves as “Americans” which would prove instrumental in the coming revolutions.
The revolutionary struggle of Latin American countries was a reaction to the Napoleonic take over of the existing Spanish monarchy in 1808. Many colonies within Latin America felt that they should not be ruled by a Frenchman. Therefore, governing bodies throughout the colonies began forming juntas, which acted as a combining of centralized local government structures. Río de la Plata (1810) was one of these successful juntas which not only democratically overthrew 10th Viceroy, Santiago de Liniers, but also crushed his counter-revolution. The revolt in Río de la Plata inspired other resistance movements across Latin America. One of these revolutions was led by creole commander Simón Bolívar. In the rampant chaos that was the Republic of New Granada (1831-1858), Bolívar gained prominence as a “liberator.” By 1821, Bolívar would use nativist and nationalist sentiment to liberate the regions of Panama, Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, Venezuela, and parts of Brazil. However, the revolutions throughout Latin America were unsuccessful in their struggle as they did not establish the Enlightenment ideals which they strived for. Instead, the creoles took power within the former-colonies and established their own governance structures.
Geographically north of Latin America, a small island in the Caribbean, hosted the extremely wealthy colony of Saint Domingue (1659-1804). The French colony of Saint Domingue was a plantation colony that produced vast amounts of cotton, coffee and sugar. During the 18th century, Saint Domingue was regarded as the single largest slave market within the slave trade. The colony existed within a strict racial and class hierarchy. The highest class was the grand blancs (upper-class White plantation owners), followed by the petit blancs (lower-class White day laborers/artisans), then the gens de couleur/affranchi (“free people of color”), and at the lowest class were slaves. Haitian society at this time was extremely complex, especially among the affranchi. They were a highly educated class of mixed-race individuals whose position in society was not well-defined. In reading the Declaration of the Rights of Man (1789) it claimed to afford all men free and equal rights, but among affranchi that liberty did not apply due to their racial status. Haiti would go through a series of uprisings, the first of this being led by affranchi Vincent Ogé. His revolt would be consolidated only among affranchi and eventually fail, leading to his execution by the French government. Just a few years later, slaves would gather in the Bois Caïman ceremony: a Vodou ritual led by clerical leaders Dutty Boukman (1767-1791) and Cécile Fatiman (1771-1883). The details of the ceremony are steeped in Haitian myth and legend, but it is that night in which the Haitian people swore to overthrow their White oppressors.
The Haitian slaves and affranchi of Saint Domingue would eventually take control of the colony. They would be led by affranchi and military general Toussaint L'Ouverture in which they would abolish slavery, gain independence and formulate their own constitution. L'Ouverture would eventually be betrayed by Jean-Jacques Dessalines, were he would be deported back to France and die in prison. Dessalines was far more radical than L’Ouverture and felt he needed to expel all French influence from the colonies. In the Haitian Declaration of Independence (1804), Dessalines and his political cabinet called for the ethnic cleansing of the former-White ruling classes. In their post-revolutionary final act, the Haitian people went door to door killing their former oppressors.
The revolutions of Latin America and Haiti were similar in the sense that they used Enlightenment ideals, inspired by European movements, to mobilize their cause. Interestingly, both movements were led by a European ruling class individual who had access to these ideas. In the case of Latin America, Bolívar was of creole identity and became the military commander of the revolution. Similarly, L'Ouverture was of the affranchi social class and became the military leader for the Haitian people. Vodou theology was also essential to the Haitian Revolution. It cemented a nationalist identity and indigenous coalition amongst Haiti’s Black and mixed-race population. In Latin America, Bolívar did not lean too heavily on nationalism, but instead used nativist sentiment in coalition building. The revolutions of Latin America are considered to be incomplete, whereas the Haitian revolution is generally considered to be a complete revolution among historians. This is due to the successful overthrow of the ruling class and establishment of a state. Sadly, Haiti would be economically sanctioned by neighboring countries like the United States in fear of inspiring slave revolts, enriching Pan-Africanist sentiments, and promising safety/freedom for Blacks globally. Business in the United States would also fund propaganda campaigns in the villainization of the Vodou religion, leading to the Southern Black “with-doctor” stereotype common in popular media. Haiti was far more successful in establishing the Enlightenment ideals of the era. While its declaration of independence did not reflect those ideals, the Haitian constitution did and has been an inspiration for liberation movements around the world for centuries since.
Colonization and Semi-Colonization
During the 1800s, the British saw their global presence as a force for “good,” no matter the brutality it inflicted. They were spreading Western ideals, capitalist principles, and exporting the “civilized nature” of British culture. This meant that in both India and China, the British colonial presence sought out any means in solidifying control. The traits surrounding British colonial successes in the 19th century revolved around their dominance of trade markets, their superior military, and lack of respect for foreign cultures.
Throughout the centuries, British trade with China created a trade imbalance which severely dented Britain's economy. As a result the British began selling opium to the Chinese in order to fulfill their economic imbalance. The opium trade for the British was highly successful, but led to drug addiction throughout China. Instead of going to work, the Chinese citizenry would spend most of their time in opium dens. This led to criminal investigations in Canton by the leadership of the commission on trade, Lin Zexu (1785-1850). Canton (Guangdong Province) was a coastal province where the British mainly did trade. Lin in his investigations found that the British were lying about their criminal activity, and thus violated all trade agreements. He also viewed the British actions as morally reprehensible, by trading the Chinese people “poison” (opium) in exchange for porcelain, tea, silks and spices. In retaliation, Lin ordered the destruction of 1.2 million kilograms of British opium and the arrest of over 1,700 Chinese opium dealers. Finally in 1839, Lin announced a ban on opium.
The Qing Dynasty (1644-1911) underestimated how valuable the opium trade was to the British Empire (1497-1997). In response to the destruction of British commerce, the British sent warships to China. The British effectively declared war on China, which led to the First Opium War (1839-1842). With superior naval forces, the British defeated the Chinese, leading to the Treaty of Nanjing (1842). In the treaty, the British layed out their means of engagement. China was expected to pay all British expenses of the war, to pay for the opium destroyed, they kept control of Hong Kong and were allowed to open trading posts throughout Chinese controlled-areas. This was humiliating for the Chinese empire, leading to a period of decline and disgrace.
Opium was grown in India and parts of Central Asia, as it required that type of climate. This meant that Britain needed to maintain full control of India in order to maintain global economic dominance. At the start of the opium trade with China, the East India Company (1600-1874) had colonized India. The East India Company (EIC) had gained control of much of the Indian subcontinent during the Battle of Plassey (1757). During the periods of 1757-1858, jurisdiction of India was under “company rule.” In the year of 1857, “company rule” led to an uprising known as the Sepoy Rebellion. The sepoys were ethnically Indian soldiers serving British forces in the region. During “company rule,” the sepoys felt as though the British were actively attacking Indian culture. They had laced Enfield P53 paper cartridges in beef and pork fat in order to prevent malfunctions from water getting into the firearm. A decision in which India’s Hindu and Muslim population felt disrespected and repulsed. The British also allowed Christian missionaries into India, began spreading Western medicine, issued heavy taxation and failed to resolve land disputes. These many issues led to a revolt within the sepoy, against EIC military occupation.
By 1858, the revolt was crushed after reinforcements arrived from the British Empire. Quick deployment of reinforcements was due to the telegraph allowing superior communication between British forces. The empire put in place “crown rule,” which meant Queen Victoria (1819-1901) assumed full control of the Indian subcontinent. Rebels were also severely punished and publically humiliated, in order to “deter” further uprisings.
The traits of British colonial successes were mainly due to the ruthlessness of British military tactics, occupation, and commerce. In commerce, the British had no problem in lying, cheating or criminalizing their way through trade agreements. Their successful exploits from this type of commerce led to the need for occupation in places like India. Without the resources generated from Indian occupation, the British would not be able to trade with the Chinese and generate such wealth. Societies which refused cooperation with the British were quickly dealt with through the flex of military superiority. This was what led to the semi-colonization of China and colonial occupation of India. The British economy was built on an intricate series of plots which all intersected with one another. Britain needed India for its opium and China for the mass amounts of wealth the country generated.
The New Imperialism
Africa is widely considered the wealthiest continent in non-renewable natural resources. However, centuries of colonialism have led to mass suffering which continues to the present day. It is evident that Europe changed the trajectory of Africa, transforming it into a divided continent with rampant poverty, brutal regimes, and high rates of disease.
After over twenty years of warfare, the people of Europe implemented Enlightenment ideals. In accordance with these ideals, the British ended slavery in 1833. During this time period Europeans control 35% of the landmass on the planet. The abolishment of slavery and the potential of new machineries led to the European need for natural resources. Specifically, Europeans needed the raw materials of tin, copper, rubber, and petroleum. This acquisition of natural resources would assist in reigniting the European economy in their post-war and post-slavery era. Europeans turned their sights to Africa, a continent previously known as the “White Man’s Grave.” The failed colonization of Africa in previous centuries led to this mythos surrounding the African continent. Previous conquests led to the mass deaths of European forces, due to disease. This fear of disease would fuel racial theories surrounding Africa and facilitate the creation of the West India Regiment (WIR). The WIR was a military regiment mostly made up of ethnically African slaves, from regions outside Africa. For the British, they theorized that diseases were racially specific and therefore an ethnically African regiment would be immune. They were false however, and the WIR garnered the similar amount of casualties as ethnically European dominated regiments.
The Old Imperialism of the 16th and 18th centuries was replaced with a new form of imperialism. New Imperialism during the late 19th and early 20th centuries was fueled by the Age of Enlightenment (1685-1815). Europeans wanted to bring Christianity, commerce, and “civilization” to the rest of the world. They believed that by bringing their “rationality” and industry to “uncivilized” peoples, it would help in “civilizing” them. While this was the myth they told themselves, it was apparent that the material conditions of Europe at the time “necessitated” their colonization efforts. During the Berlin Conference (1884-1885), the nations of Europe would come together and allocate parts of Africa to each other. During the Scramble for Africa (1833-1914), Europe would invade, annex, divide, and colonize the entire continent. They would do this successfully through the use of new technologies. The use of medicine in Africa would become the hallmark of these various technologies utilized by Europeans. Medicine would help Europeans combat diseases which previously hindered their armies in the conquests of Africa. The use of the steamboat (for upstream travel across African rivers) and the telegraph would facilitate: movement, communication, and the economies of colonial powers. Another key ingredient for Europeans in Africa was the advancement of firearm technologies. The invention of the first fully automatic machine gun by Sir Hiram Stevens Maxim ensured that any resistance from local populations was “swiftly dealt with.” Later utilization of railroads, electricity, and light bulbs would also aid in this colonial expansion.
By the end of the Scramble for Africa, Europe added 9,000,000 square miles to its colonial possessions. In 1913, Europe held the entirety of the continent apart from a few resistance strongholds like Volta Bani, the Ikazkazan Tuareg Confederation, and the Senusiyya Order. Europeans also did not hold the sultanates of Darfur and Darawiish along with the Ethiopian Empire, and the country of Liberia. Despite the European promise of “ending slavery,” forced labor would still be utilized throughout Africa. The regime of Leopold II in the Congo would be cited as one of the most brutal in the region. The colonization of Africa would lead to the destruction of traditional African ways of life. Constant European travel, combined with inhumane labor conditions would lead to the spread of disease among the African populous. European rule would also needlessly terrorize the local populations.
Much of the effects of European colonialism in Africa are still prevalent today. In recent years, old conflicts are being reignited throughout the continent. What looked like a positive democratic revolution for Sudan, quickly turned into a civil war between the Wagner-backed Rapid Support Forces (RSF) and Sudanese Armed Forces (SAF). This has resulted in a reignition of ethnic cleansing campaigns in Darfur by the RSF (previously known as Janjaweed: “devil on horseback”), in which the burning of villages, the mass killing, and the mass raping of Darfur’s population are being reported. In the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), a 20 year conflict has resulted in the death of 6 million people. The current escalations between Rwanda-backed M23 militia and the DRC has resulted in the displacement of 7 million people. Human Rights Watch reports that M23 committed unlawful killings and rapes in the village of Kishishe. In Ethiopia it looks as though leader Abiy Ahmed is gearing up to invade Eritrea. And the current ethnic cleansing of Gaza’s population by the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) is leading to a humanitarian crisis at Egypt’s border. Suffice it to say, the effects of colonialism are obvious and undeniable. Much of the conflict in the region is either ignored or fueled by Western governments and the United Nations. In the 20th century Western government's facilitated the assassination of countless African leaders and in the 21st century they have destabilized several African nations. For many in Africa, the colonial abuses of the West are not over. As a result, many African nations are choosing to align themselves with China. A decision which may lead to drastic political consequences for the Western world.
The Russian Revolution
The Russian Revolutions (1881-1923) are a testament to how complex a revolution can be and how long it can take. It reveals to us the many layers and decisions behind sparking revolutionary sentiment within our modern history. In particular, the Russian Revolutions were extremely layered, with key players, conspirators, and numerous phases.
The first phase of the Russian Revolution was sparked from universities, like many revolutionary struggles (i.e. civil rights protests in America, the Red Guards of China, Myanmar resistance against the current military junta, etc…). This was partially the fault of Tsar Alexander II (1818-1881). After his trip to England he witnessed the benefits of their democratic reforms. Alexander II wanted to see the same reforms happen in his country, thus he implemented them. This liberal reform allowed for university level education, removal of corporal punishment and a drastic increase in railroad infrastructure. The increase in societal education meant that new ideas were entering the country and revealing the social inequalities with the country. Young patriotic Russian students wished these liberal ideals to their fellow citizens, however it proved to be unreceptive to Russia’s conservative peasant class. The students then thought to take measures into their own hands and created the Narodnaya Volya (“People’s Will”), a radical political organization engaged in acts of terrorism against the existing Tsar monarchy. Narodnaya Volya in their attempt to overthrow the Tsarist system eventually assassination Alexander II. This however, again, did not rest well with the peasant class of the country. As a result the social democrats of the country, decided to alter their approach to bringing about governmental reforms. They decided a two-step solution would be needed by first: overthrowing the Tsar with the assistance of the bourgeoisie, then bringing about a proletarian revolution to topple the bourgeoisie.
In 1905, a massacre of Russian peasants occurred by Tsarist forces. Around 200 were killed and 800 more were wounded. This event was known as “Bloody Sunday.” In that aftermath, protests erupted around the country against the Tsarist regime. The Tsar was forced to give into the demands of the people and brought about liberal democratic reforms. By 1906, the Tsar established a constitution, marking one of the second phases of the revolution.
The third phase of the revolution was the February Revolution of 1917 and came about from the economic and social instability caused by WWI. Tsar Nicholas II (1868-1918) left to fight in WWI which left the social democrats and Marxists within the state Duma to their own devices. During this time the Tsar was incredibly weak and its public reputation was further worsened when Empress Alexandra (1872-1918) invited Rasputin (1869-1916), a peasant holy man, to rule alongside her. The conspiratorial forces with the Duma saw this as an opportunity to topple the Tsar for good. The Duma began heavily criticizing the Russian monarchy and tarnished Alexandra’s public image. They did so by questioning her loyalties through xenophobic rhetoric with regards to her German ancestry. An estimated 200,000 workers protested in the streets which escalated into violence when Russian troops began firing into the crowds. As the violence escalated, Nicholas II was eventually forced to abdicate his throne and his family was placed under house arrest.
The fourth phase is referred to as the October Revolution (1917-1923). During this phase, Vladimir Lenin (1870-1924) and his Bolsheviks seized power within the government. Lenin put in place Marxist ideas centering around how the “state” should be run. They sought to abolish private property and give workers control of the means of production. The newly seized Russian territories were reborn as the Soviet Union (1922-1991). Marxist ideals did not play out in this new nation. Lenin created a one party state which exercised complete control of the nation and its people. This form of governance was never before seen in human history and began inspiring other nations around the world to adopt the Marxist-Leninist system of governance.
The Russian Revolutions did not come in one fell swoop, but were a series of key moments, ideologically led by a select few intellectuals with political power. The end result of these revolutions was a state more akin to fascism, then the Marxist ideas it espoused and desired. The Soviet Union, in order to keep said system from collapsing, formulated a mythology around Marx, Lenin, and Stalin in an effort to keep the facade of a “true communist system.”
A Cold War Case Study: UFC and CIA Intervention in Guatemala
After the events of World War II (WWII) and during the Cold War, the United States in its quest to secure economic, political, and militaristic hegemony — often violated the sovereignty of other nations around the globe. In the case of Guatemalan sovereignty, the U.S. prioritized the economic structures of American companies abroad, rather than the pursuit of proclaimed U.S. ideological determinations: “democracy, freedom, liberty, and equality.” It is in this instance that U.S. intervention, fueled by corporate greed, led to the rise of dictatorial powers, the end of progressive reforms, and the genocide of Guatemala’s indigenous population.
Guatemala during WWII was ruled by Jorge Ubico (1878-1946); a pro-Nazi, pro-Mussolini dictator, akin to the likes of Francisco Franco and Napoleon Bonaparte. American companies were fond of Ubico, because he let American-owned companies conduct business in Guatemala without taxation and with the use of “free” indigenous laborers. In return the U.S. propped up Ubico by way of military funding. During this era many politicians were controlled by the influence of American companies. One of these companies was the United Fruit Company (UFC), and was integral to the destabilization of the Guatemalan state. Towards the end of WWII, the Guatemalan people rose up in a revolution to remove Ubico from power. This was known as the Guatemalan Revolution (1944-1954) and resulted in the formulation of Guatemalan democracy, along with the election of two progressive presidents. This era is often referred to as the “Ten Years of Spring,” in which freedom of speech, labor unions, freedom of the press, social security, and a constitution was solidified. Within this movement, Guatemalan President Jacobo Árbenz (1913-1971) issued Decree 900 which generated massive land reforms throughout the country. Impoverished segments of society and indigenous peoples were given large plots of land for farming, including portions of UFC land ownings. An estimated 100,000 families received land holdings and approximately 1.5 million acres were gifted, including 17,000 acres of President Árbenz personal land holdings.
These progressive actions taken by the Guatemalan state drew the attention of the U.S. Secretary of State, John Foster Dulles (188-1959). He had numerous connections to the UFC and therefore sought to undermine Guatemalan democracy, in order to secure profit incentive for himself and other American corporate backers. Dulles ran disinformation campaigns against Árbenz, labeling him a “communist.” In reality, Árbenz had no communist ties or sympathies. However, the use of this language during a time of heightened tensions with the Soviet Union, U.S. President Eisenhower’s pledge for more rigorous “anti-communist” policies, and potent Red Scare propaganda, meant unquestioned support for Dulles. In true American nepotistic fashion, John Foster Dulles, U.S. Secretary of State, and his brother Allen Dulles (1893-1969), Director of the CIA (each with ties to the UFC), launched Operation PBSuccess (1954). Having just completed Operation Ajax (combined U.S. and British instigated overthrow of democratically elected Iranian leader Mohammad Mosaddegh), the CIA was primed to apply similar tried and tested tactics in Guatemala. Operation PBSuccess consisted of a strategic disinformation campaign and psychological warfare. The U.S. did this by dropping leaflets into Guatemala using unmarked U.S. aircrafts, in which the leaflets would indicate an incoming invasion of Guatemala. This prompted Árbenz to find weapons dealers in preparation for the “coming attack.” Árbenz landed on the acquisition of Czechoslovakian arms, which became the first instance of a Soviet-bloc country shipping armaments to the Americas.
The acquisition of armaments from a Soviet-bloc country, became the excuse needed for the CIA-backed invasion of Carlos Castillo Armas (1914-1957) forces. With massive support from the United States, Armas was able to take Guatemala and anoint himself president. In his first actions, Armas revoked Decree 900, and cracked down on “suspected communists.” The aftermath of the coup and the Armas presidency was a civil war between Guatemalan governmental forces and leftist rebel groups. During and after this civil war, Guatemalan governmental forces targeted the Mayan indigenous population for extermination. Over 362,000 were massacred, in what is referred to today as the Silent Holocaust (1960-1983).
What can be gleaned from these egregious actions of the U.S. State Department is that the privilege of “empire” often comes with a price. The products we consume, the people we condemn, the ideological assertions we make on the soil of “empire,” all culminate into, what can be, drastic political consequences for other nations. Guatemala is just the tip of the iceberg for U.S. intervention into supposed “communist-allied regimes.” And what we also learn from this, is that ideological assertions usually hide an underlying agenda. Whether that be resource extraction or the weakening of companies operating in supposed regions (such as the case with Guatemala). Understanding the economic or social instability of Guatemala, and nations like it, should be met with an open-mind and an astute level of historical understanding. It is only in this pursuit of a nation's past, that we can begin to inform about its present and future.
The Methods of Domination
The methods of domination in the colonial and “post-colonial” periods are perhaps one of the most debated and controversial subjects in our modern-day. Much debate revolves around the need for reparations among colonized societies as in accordance with the current international order. Whereas, current controversy delineates on whether the colonial period ever ended, or morphed into something more insidious. These questions around the subjugation of peoples often require a historical look at the beginnings of colonialism and its consequences. What this historical perspective teaches us is that the methods of domination have only minimally changed over the past 500 years, as new technologies were invented. The formula of domination still required the utilization of immunity against deadly pathogens, exploitation of cheap labor, proliferation of firearms, and the maintenance of the hegemonic order by use of violence.
In the lead up to the 16th century, early naval expeditions from Spain triggered the ‘Great Dying’ (1493-1593) in the Americas (Lecture 2, 39:10). This was a period by which pathogens from the Old World (Afro-Eurasia) were brought to the New World (the Americas), where indigenous populations did not have built-up immunity. This ‘Great Dying’ was responsible for the death of around 90% of the indigenous American peoples. While this spread of disease was unintentional it paved the way for Spanish domination of the Americas. The Spanish did not hesitate to use the aftermath of said epidemics to further its political goals. In later colonial projects, specifically the Scramble for Africa (1833-1914), vaccines preventing diseases were utilized as a tool for further colonial expansion (Lecture 12, 37:00). Previous colonial ventures into Africa resulted in mass casualties of European troops, due to malaria. However, in 1820 two French chemists by the name of Joseph Pelletier (1788-1842) and Joseph Caventou (1795-1877) discovered a prophylactic called quinine. This prophylactic would aid in the creation of a vaccine used to combat malaria, which allowed colonial forces to move further into Africa. The colonial project in Africa by European forces also further spread disease to Africa’s native populations, due to European troop movements and the invention of new transportation methods throughout the continent. It is in these instances where the power that controls the circularization of medicine dominates individuals without immunity to pathogens.
The exploitation of cheap labor from the indigenous populations in occupied territories around the globe became crucial for the growth of colonial nations. For Spain the successful conquering of the Americas, specifically the Incan Empire (1200-1533) in the Battle of Cajamarca (1532), led to a massive cheap labor force. Spain utilized existing indigenous practices, like the Mita public service system, in order to mobilize the Incan workforce (Lecture 2, 48:20). Laborers were forced to extract silver from Cerro Potosí, a mineral rich mountain. Similarly, the British Empire (1497-1997) would utilize slave-labor in the American colonies in order to enrich its economy (Lecture 7, 25:25). This pivot towards a reliance on slave-labor was due to the Calico Acts (1721), which banned the attainment of calico textiles in India. The use of slave labor became extremely popular for several European nations and the United States. This popularization led to the transatlantic slave trade. The French colony of Saint Domingue (1659-1804) was one of the prime examples of the wealth which slavery brought to its perpetrators. Saint Domingue was the wealthiest colony in the world and had the single largest slave market within the slave trade (Lecture 10, 36:10). Over 90% of the population of Saint Domingue were Black African slaves who worked in horrid conditions. The average life expectancy for slaves was 21 years, however some estimates say it was far lower (5-10 years). Petit blancs in the racial class hierarchy were also subject to less than ideal working conditions. This created an extreme class and racial divide within the Saint Domingue colony. Similarly, the Leopoldian system continued these brutal working conditions into the 19th and 20th centuries (Lecture 12, 42:00). Black African laborers who refused to work would have their hands removed as punishment. This excessive use of forced labor was often a result of massive demand for goods from European nations. Gold, cotton, and rubber were all high demand items in the 19th century, which exacerbated pressures on the African labor force. It becomes evident that throughout the colonial period, cheap labor is one of the main forms of dominance.
In the 19th and 20th centuries, the phrase “he who holds a gun, is he who controls his destiny” reigned very true. The proliferation of firearms in the hands of colonial powers and the evolution of firearm technology meant that brutality could be easily demonstrated. In the case of African colonization, firearms meant that Europeans could quickly overpower local populations and in turn subjugate them (Lecture 12, 32:00). The invention of the fully automatic machine gun in 1884, was a pivotal point in warfare. It meant that a small colonial force could wipe out hundreds of individuals in mere hours. Perhaps, the most well-known instance of this occurring (during the technology's infancy) was the Moro Crater Massacre (1906). A massacre perpetrated by U.S. forces, in which a fully automatic machine gun assisted in killing over 800 individuals on the Jolo Island, Philippines. The firearm also acted as a “great-equalizer,” meaning that skill and physical performance was no longer necessary to kill. While these traits could enhance one's marksmanship, the firearm created a very low barrier for entry. Firearms assisted in the escalation of war during the 20th century. The events of WWI and WWII, saw the death of almost 25 million military personnel killed in combat settings. Firearm technology was used to carry out mass atrocities, such as the Armenian genocide (1915-1916), the Holocaust (1933-1945), the Silent Holocaust (1960-1983), the Cambodian genocide (1975-1979), the Bosnian genocide (1992-1995), and many others. In fact, one of the first military decisions made by the Nazi regime in Germany was to confiscate firearms from every Jewish household. It is in this era where confiscation of firearms becomes a commonplace tactic for dictators, occupational forces, and invading powers. Firearms become a staple in dominating groups of people who do not possess them. This was the case in African colonization and it was the case in 20th century atrocities.
Above all, domination of a subjugated peoples required strategic maintenance of a nation's hegemonic position. In the First Opium War (1839-1842), Britain asserted its hegemonic presence when the Qing Dynasty (1644-1911) refused to trade opium. Chinese authorities ruled that Britain was violating trade agreements. This was accurate as the British were lying, cheating, and engaging in criminal activity in Chinese territory. In response to China ending trade access, the British sent warships to China. This led to the semi-colonization of China and acquisition of Hong Kong by British forces (Lecture 11, 24:35). Similarly, the British would use these same strategies of force during the Sepoy Rebellion (1857-1858) and the Irish Potato Famine (1845-1852). Moving into the 20th century, we find the United States would fund a coup d'etat in Guatemala during Operation PBSuccess (1954), which would put in place a leader more “friendly” to American business interests (Lecture 14, 19:00). The tactics used by Britain and the United States were identical in the establishment of hegemonic control. Differences between the two revolved around the strategy as it relates to the historical precedents of the time. During the mid-19th century the only international rule was Pax- Britannica (1815-1914), which meant that international stability was dependent on British commercial and military dominance. At the turn of the mid-20th century, international order was centered around the United Nations: a cooperative of nations around the globe. This was also a period of competing hegemonic powers. Which meant that the United States (in order to maintain legitimacy) could not send the full might of its military to countries it deemed were “misbehaving.” Thus, the U.S. engaged in strategies of ideological warfare, psychological warfare, espionage, and destabilization. Since 1945, the United States has attempted to overthrow 50 foreign governments in order to maintain its presence as a global hegemon. The end goal of Britain and the United States was the same, but their strategies differed as it related to the current historical and political precedents of the time period. These strategies reveal to us that being a global hegemon (in the colonial and “post-colonial” context) requires a great deal of political, economic, and militaristic maintenance.
On these delineations regarding the methods of dominance throughout the centuries, we find that the structures and formula for subjugating a peoples hardly changes. Disease and those immune to disease (whether through medicine or natural immunity) often have a major advantage over those not immune. Exploitation of foreign cheap labor became a “requirement” for colonial forces, especially to keep their domestic population privileged and content. Firearms became fundamental in expediting the process of subjugation, while also setting a new precedent in the “laws of violence.” While maintaining dominance over a population meant a delicate game of deceit and military strategy. The only change in these methods is that by each decade they got more brutal, more decisive, and far less messy. And as technology advances, the subjugation of peoples by governing and militaristic forces will continue in this trend of decisive brutality.
Images courtesy of Ch Jawad