Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Apr. 28th, 2023
The characteristics which marked the Haitian Revolution were unique to human history. Haiti became the first independent Latin American nation, the first nation to permanently abolish slavery, the second free and independent colony in the Americas, and single handedly stopped the expansion of Napoleon's French empire. The ideas and influences which accompanied this struggle for freedom are present in the revolutionary figureheads, enemies, and religious structures present during the time period. This essay will investigate the ideas accompanying the Haitian Revolution (1791-1804) in relation to Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712-1778), Karl Marx (1818-1883), artwork by Karl Girardet (1813-1871) and Vodou liberation theology.
Saint-Domingue was a highly racialized and classist society. At the top was the grand blancs, a French aristocracy who had full administrative control of the colony. In the second tier were the petit blancs, who were White shopkeepers, artisans, and day laborers. Below them were a class of freed people of color, known as the affranchi. The affranchi were a broad category of mixed-race individuals and freed Black slaves who were heavily segregated from Whites but permitted to partake in the agrarian slave economy. At the lowest class were the slaves, who accounted for the vast majority of the population. The slave population would be the catalyst in cementing the Haitian Revolution, however the first revolts would start with the affranchi. After the events of the French Revolution, and with it the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man by the newly installed French national assembly, the well-educated affranchi searched for their place in French society. In the first amendment of the Declaration of the Rights of Man it affirms that “men are born and remain free and equal in rights” (Matthews and Platt, 186), however this was not the case for the affranchi. Due to the mixed-race status of many affranchi they were not given the same rights as their White compatriots. Among these affranchi was Vincent Ogé, a former Dominican Creole slave, French revolutionary, military officer, and the richest Black merchant on the island. Ogé would petition the national assembly for the right to vote among the affranchi in Saint-Domingue. The national assembly would agree to his requests but fail to put these laws into practice. This would lead to Haiti’s first uprising, a failed affranchi uprising led by Ogé, which would result in his brutal execution.
The affranchi were well educated and like much of French society, aware of Rousseau's teachings. In relation to slavery, however, the account was contradictory among the affranchi. Ogé joined abolitionist causes, but owned slaves and petitioned for the right to own slaves with the national assembly. Affranchi born free, often viewed slaves similar to their White counterparts. They saw slavery as a social class only being occupied by individuals innately subhuman. This belief was so influential that during the second uprising, affranchi were surprised that slaves were capable of organizing a rebellion against the White dominant classes. Rousseau on the other hand presents very clear views on slavery stating, “the right to slavery is null and void… slavery and right are contradictory; they are mutually exclusive” (249). The caveat to this belief is the equivalence between the slave and the free individual. For the formerly enslaved affranchi, the brutal conditions of slavery on the island implies a worthier condition for former slaves. It is likely that a culture of superiority amongst freed slaves was cultivated. This system of class stratification was integral to the design of the Saint-Domingue colony. If individuals of African descent could be divided on the basis of class, then they would participate in the oppression of their own race. Simultaneously petit blancs saw themselves as oppressed due to the fact they couldn’t own slaves, but grand blancs and some affranchi could. Due to these factors, society functioned through resentment and hatred of one's own class position. Ownership of property, capital, and other human beings was the very foundations of Saint-Domingue success and eventual demise. Interestingly, it is these very factors which Rousseau points out as being the basis for inequality. “The first person who, having enclosed a plot of ground, thought of saying this is mine and found people simple enough to believe him… what miseries and horrors, would the human race have been spared by someone who… cried out to his fellow humans: ‘Beware of listening to this imposter…’” (Rousseau, 165). In the mind of Rousseau, the advent of property ownership solidified the self-oppression of humanity. Nature is collective ownership of all beings. Dividing it amongst ourselves is antithetical to the natural state of being by which humanity can find a true sense of self. Rousseau categorizes humanity's natural state as a combination of self-preservation and self-pity. Through our natural state humanity compares itself to others in an effort to become perfect. Thus, the creation of property creates competitiveness which leads to conflict. In the case of the petit blancs they placed their value on the ownership of another human being. Self-worth in the context of Saint-Domingue's class system was dependent on one's ability to infringe on another's freedom. It is this which destroys what little is left of humanity, in Rousseau’s context it is ironically the slave owners which become subhuman.
Rousseau may have found the Haitian slaves to be freer than their oppressors. Rousseau states, “as for men like me, whose passions have forever destroyed their original simplicity, who can no longer… do without laws and leaders… they will scrupulously obey the laws and the men who are their authors and ministers” (133). In this discourse, Rousseau commits that hopelessness and complacency in society has led to humanity's imprisonment. The belief in hope, or an optimistic future, is the key factor for individual freedom in civil society. The call for revolution among Haitian slaves is the passion and romanticism by which humanity enters its natural free state of being. It is there, in the moments of revolution, where humanity is truly free. Those moments were the only time one could break free from the society which continually oppresses one another.
Slaves did not have access to the teachings of Rousseau. Instead, Haitian Vodou became a key element in Haitian liberation. The second phase, but first slave planning of the Haitian revolt, was during the Bois Caïman ceremony, led by Vodou clerics Dutty Boukman (1767-1791) and Cécile Fatiman (1771-1883). It is that night when enslaved Haitians swore to kill their White oppressors, and quickly took the northern province of Saint-Domingue. Vodou plays on building relationships through reciprocity. Practitioners of Vodou (Vodouyizan) demonstrate these beliefs by asking guidance from the lwa (Vodou spirits). While there is a creator god in Vodou, the entity does not get involved in mortal affairs. Notions of reciprocity are heavily emphasized, which is in stark contrast with notions of worship common in many of the world's religions. This relationship is a direct result of the conditions of slavery. Vodouyizan did not want to serve a master and it was this reaction to colonial rule which was the leading factor for liberation. It is important to note that Haitian Vodou was not just a religion, but instead embedded in the psyche of Haitian people. To be Vodouyizan is to participate in a dynamic experience which interacts with body, soul, corporeal, incorporeal, living, undead, and divine.
While the intricacy of Vodou theology was liberatory, there were also practical conditions which resulted in the cultivation of Vodou. French upper classes in the Saint-Domingue colony attempted to push Christianity onto the slaves in an effort to get them to assimilate to Western culture. Vodou was crucial in resisting this oppression, as it helped maintain African dance, ritual, and song. This allowed the preservation of the African cultural identity among slaves, which the affranchi had disregarded. Ritualized cultural traditions inspired the slaves to rise up, whereas the affranchi rose up due to the injustice of not being recognized as full French citizens. This distinction marks the impact Vodou had on the slaves' recognizing their value as human beings. The very first lines of Haiti’s 1805 constitution, constructed by Jean-Jacques Dessalines (1758-1806) and his political cabinet, proclaims "in the presence of the Supreme Being before whom all mortals are equal” (Garrigus and Dubios, 192). This reference to the “Supreme Being” refers to the Vodou creator god Bondye. The constitutions mention of this theology cements the importance Vodou was to the liberatory efforts of Haiti. Dessalines and other revolutionary leaders after their death would go on to be regarded as lwa. There were practical uses for this as the imposition of prophetic voices during the revolution, like Boukman and Fatiman, used Vodou theology to delineate the organization of a revolution. This theological phenomenon allowed for a fast-paced liberation of the Haitian people. Haitians were direct participants in the evolution of their religion and coexisted alongside it, rather than practitioners relegated to stagnant historical precedent.
Vodou also created a strong sense of national identity. This national identity would evolve into a form of nationalism under the leadership of Dessalines. In Haiti’s fourth uprising, Dessalines would name Haiti independent from France and call for the genocide of the remaining White people on the island. In the 1804 Haitian Declaration of Independence, it pontificates “it is not enough to have expelled the barbarians… we must, with one last act of national authority, forever ensure liberty's reign… we must live independent or die” (Garrigus and Dubios, 189). It is in this address that Dessalines and his political cabinet sought to solidify their new nation in the ethnic cleansing of the Saint-Domingue colony. In the essence of nationalism, one is to accept their death if it means the securing of an independent state. It is important to note this was a slow gradual evolution then eventual dissipation of nationalism. After the death of Dessalines, the newly independent country would fall into a period of civil war. However, the country would eventually stabilize and become what it set out to be: a welcoming place for all oppressed peoples. The consistent factor in this political struggle is the Haitian former slave class led by Boukman. In the Bois Caïman ceremony, Boukman and Fatiman used Vodou to consolidate revolutionary sentiment in overthrowing an oppressive force. Vodou was a massive distinguishing factor for Haiti’s former slave class. Whereas Dessalines and his successors were all affranchi greatly influenced by European notions of leadership. This shows the stability of Vodou theology in pursuing liberation of the oppressed over nationalistic fervor. Nationalism is unscrupulous, foreign, and incompatible with Haitian Vodou.
After the death of Boukman, the revolution would enter a third uprising where it would evolve into a full military assault commanded by affranchi Toussaint L’ouverture (1743-1803). This is where we saw the culmination of ideologies. L'ouverture and the two groups' common ancestry assisted in the alliance of slaves and affranchi in the revolution. Rousseau and Haitian Vodou, representing the two classes' beliefs, played off one another and conjoined a revolution against their White oppressors. The collectivist nature of Haitian Vodou teachings proved congruent when compared with Rousseau’s ideas of the sovereign. Rousseau rejected Thomas Hobbes’ (1588-1679) monarchical structure of control and believed the sovereign to be in the common will of the people, referred to as general will. Through general will the people were meant to collectively decide on the direction of their state. The sovereign is seen as a separate entity meant to represent and benefit all citizens. This sense of mystical harmonic bonding coincided with Vodou reciprocity between nature, humanity, and spirit. Vodou and Rousseau also shared the belief that slavery was in direct opposition with the natural order of the world. Rousseau lacked in guiding humanity on how to practically return to that natural state, whereas Vodou prided itself in the appreciation of nature and presented traditions on how to become in touch with nature. In this case, it is evident that Rousseau was still limited by the structures of European society. Vodou was a necessary factor in producing true liberation for all oppressed Haitian people. Affranchi could not find true liberation within the frameworks of European thought, because European society served the dominant racial group.
Marx was not alive to witness the Haitian Revolution. However, the Marxist lens presents a bipolar view of the ideological and class struggle in Saint-Domingue. It is presented to us in contradictory circumstances of the ruling European or Afro-European Christian classes and Haitian African Vodouyizan slave class. In this framework we see competing individualist and collectivist societies. European Christian society had a strong emphasis on industry, materialism, property, racialism, and status. Haitian Vodou society emphasized utilitarianism, subsistence living, social collectivism, social justice, and harmony. The revolution wasn’t just an uprising, but a clash of two competing ideologies. In many ways, the revolution represented a war between Europe and Africa. Coincidentally, it is the Haitian Revolution which would spur Pan-Africanist movements and sentiments across the African diaspora. Marxism also equivocates the false consciousness among the affranchi. Vodou theology served as a reminder or admonition of what it meant to be African for the affranchi. It would prove so powerful that the affranchi would use their class status, military training, and education to further the revolutionary cause.
We see this in the engraving by Girardet depicting the Battle of Ravine-à-Couleuvres (1802). The battle was one of the Haitian Revolution’s major battles during the third phase of the revolution in which First Consul of France, Napoleon Bonaparte (1769-1821), sent a military expedition to retake the Saint-Domingue colony. During the battle L’ouverture led an army of 3,000 against the French but was eventually forced to retreat after losing 800 men. In Girardet’s depiction we see that he shows the French winning the battle, with mixed-race affranchi struggling to survive. Interestingly, the affranchi are positioned as protecting the Haitian lower classes as to give them an opportunity to retreat. This detail indicates to us that Europeans viewed the affranchi as the primary leading force in the revolution. The slave class is infantilized and seen as incapable of delegating a revolution. While some aim their firearms at the French, the majority seem stricken by fear and are fleeing the scene. In the distance, a marching line of thousands of French soldiers’ traipse through the Haitian jungle. Girardet shows his biases very clearly but gives us insight into the racial and class dynamics of the era. It is likely Europeans viewed slaves as incapable due to their non-mixed-race status. In the European view, African slaves did not have the blood of the Whites and therefore did not have the same intellect. The affranchi, however, are somewhat European and therefore touched with “the purity” of the White European race. Girardet’s engraving perfectly encapsulates the race and class struggles that where prominent in the Haitian Revolution.
The characteristics that define Haiti are steeped in its people’s dynamic fortitude to pursue equality, liberty, and resistance in the face of unending hardships. To perceive the workings of Haiti is a privilege afforded to the generosity of time. The ideals of Rousseau served as a guiding force in the courage of one class of society. Still, in all recounts, it was the collective solidified by Haitian Vodou that would prove in inspiring revolution. In the Marxian sense, Haiti is the offspring of two competing ideologies vying for control under entrenched class structures. Haiti teaches that revolution is never just a desire for freedom, but a grand vision of possibility.
Work Cited
Garrigus, John D., and Laurent Dubois. Slave Revolution in the Caribbean, 1789-1804: A Brief History with Documents. Bedford/St. Martin's, 2017.
Matthews, Roy, and DeWitt Platt. Readings to Accompany Experience Humanities Volume 2: The Renaissance to the Present. Edited by DeWitt Platt and Roy Matthews, McGraw-Hill Education, 2013.
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. The Major Political Writings of Jean-Jacques Rousseau: The Two "Discourses" and the "Social Contract". Edited by John T. Scott, translated by John T. Scott, University of Chicago Press, 2012.
Image of the Public Domain