Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Jun. 12th, 2025
Mexico, as one of the most influential nations in the Americas, is important for understanding the post-colonial context of our modern world. From its pre-Columbian inception to the Spanish Conquests, the Mexican Revolution, and the neocolonialism of contemporary history — Mexico delivers unique insights into the functioning of the Americas. That is to say, the importance of engaging with Mexico's history is made clear when analyzing modern society through a post-colonial lens. As someone who is studying to specialize in post-colonial studies, learning the history of Mexico was crucial for me in understanding how colonialism has formed modern identity.
The name Mexico stems from the Aztecs (1300-1521 CE), who referred to themselves as the “Mexica.” These same reflections of Mexico’s ancient past can be found in the flag with the Mexican coat of arms in the center of the flag referring to an Aztec legend. The legend states that the Aztec people would find their home when they spotted an eagle eating a snake on top of a cactus growing from the crevice of a rock; and it is this legend which is proudly displayed on the Mexican flag (Miller 42). Similarly, the Mexican flag portrays Lake Texcoco and the Aztec capital of Tenochtitlan, which would later become Mexico City: the capital of modern-day Mexico. A variety of ancient civilizations influence modern Mexican society and culture. These civilizations include the Olmec (1200-300 BCE), Maya (300-900 CE), and Toltec (950-1200 CE) along with the aforementioned Aztec. The Olmecs are believed to be the “mother-culture” which informed later civilizations. They did not construct large cities but still benefited from the growing of food and participated in collective hunting practices. Nevertheless, this early society in Mexico was at the forefront of astronomy and mathematics. Centuries later, the Aztecs would emerge from the remnants of the Toltec peoples and the masterful feat of engineering that would become Tenochtitlan. Aztec society was one which valued warriors but also valued education. It was one of the first civilizations to require all male children to be educated through school. This cultural valuing of education is something that still resides in Mexico, as Mexicans are proud to have the second oldest university in the Americas and mandatory secular public education (Agencia Digital de Innovación Pública). It becomes apparent that the Mexican people of today identify with their ancient past even through the brutality which would become Spanish colonization.
Spanish arrival was definitively an apocalyptic event for the indigenous societies of Mexico. Over the course of thirty years, a total of 20 million people would die from disease and warfare. Hernan Cortes was a leading force in conquering the most powerful Mexican society at the time, the Aztecs. Through the help of Malinche, an indigenous translator and companion, Cortes was able to formally introduce himself to the Aztec Emperor, Moctezuma. Early into the Spanish invasion, the Spanish were seen as godlike by the indigenous American Indian population. They harbored superior weaponry, such as canons and also rode horses — a species of mammal which had long since vanished from the Americas. According to Miller, emperor Moctezuma saw the Spanish arrival as a fulfillment of an Aztec prophecy and the arrival of Cortes as divine providence (84). Essentially, what Miller and many of his contemporaries argued was that because of religious beliefs, the Aztec emperor surrendered all power to Cortes. Where this becomes incongruent is in that fact that the Aztec emperor refused to convert to Christianity, which does not align with the notion of Moctezuma believing in the godly might of the conquistadors. If the emperor did believe in the godly powers of Cortes, it is more likely he would have also surrendered all religious beliefs to him and converted to Christianity. What is more likely is the theory regarding Aztec diplomatic traditions and rules of warfare. The Aztecs viewed rejecting any foreign diplomats as an act of war and Moctezuma saw the Spanish as a superior fighting force and did not want them siding with his enemies. Therefore, it was a strategic military decision to welcome the Spanish into his palace.
The details surrounding early Spanish colonization are messy in the sense that much of the source material is from the perspective of the Spanish. It is here were engaging with a holistic approach becomes challenging, as the perspectives of the colonized are ostracized or erased from the historical record. Many historians of the West fall prey to this trap when analyzing the early colonial past. It is in my opinion, that the notion regarding ancient American Indian ways of being, in that they could easily be convinced of a European divinity by virtue of their technology and lighter skin, act as justifications for their initial defeat by Europeans. Human societies globally are neither more or less intelligent and such implications act as a sort of academic laissez-faire to the primary source material. Reading such assertions by Miller was concerning as only one perspective on the subject was given. However, with further analysis it is apparent that the situation regarding Moctezuma’s fall is up for interpretation and more study. It is important that academic institutions give colonized peoples equal regard with relation to their capabilities in self-governance, self-determination, and self-awareness.
In the case of many Central and South American countries the discussion around colonization reveals an intricate mixture of culture and tradition. After the near complete annihilation of indigenous art, religion, language, and culture by the Spanish, a new era in Mexico’s history would emerge. This era would be marked by the Spanish colony of New Spain (1535-1821), a massive colonial enterprise which encompassed the entirety of Mexico, much of the Central American to South American land bridge, and a large portion of the Coastal Pacific and Southwestern North America. It is here where Mexico would be defined by a rigid class and racial hierarchy which saw those of Spanish blood as the dominant ethnic group. Miller estimated that within the first hundred years of New Spain’s existence, the American Indian population would decline from 25 million to 1 million people (141). Indigenous religions were suppressed by the Catholic Church and American Indians were barred from participating in universities. A coalition of small groups of American Indians and Europeans would resist the governance of New Spain and push to establish an independent Mexico. It is here where a mixed-race coalition can be observed and a revealing of the complex dynamics in New Spain, which inform Mexico today.
Following the colonization of the Americas a new racial identity emerged known as criollos. These individuals were of European descent but born in the Americas and therefore largely identified more with the colony rather than the heart of the colonial occupation in Europe. Additionally, as Europeans and American Indians intermingled another racial category emerged known as mestizos. These individuals were of a mixed European and American Indian ancestry. While originally a racial category, the mestizos identity would eventually evolve into a national identity that would reflect the majority of Mexico’s citizenry. This push towards recognizing the construction of mestizos as a nationality would begin almost immediately after the declaration of Mexican independence. Such moves towards establishing a Mexican identity were crucial in the stability of the nation. The problems which New Spain faced were unsustainable for the continued wellbeing of the entire society. When the rebel priest Miguel Hidalgo led a resistance movement against the governance of New Spain one could see that new identity organically formed as American Indians, mestizos, and criollos all banded together arms. Miller describes that “the lower classes were taking revenge on generations of oppressive conquistadors” (185). While revenge was definitely a factor, it should also be noted that this was the complete and total end result of such a racialized society. The rebellion consisted of promises such as ending the American Indian tribute system, abolishing slavery, the reclamation of land, and the dissolving of government corruption. These are far from vengeful ideals and in fact a noble approach to reorganizing a society. This is to say that the early days of Mexico showed great promise and a plan towards creating a more equitable society.
The push towards being better than one’s oppressors is not a uniquely Mexican ideal and can be observed in the quest for Haitian independence and even Irish independence. It is evident that in most cases, people placed in an oppressive structure try to work against such oppressive structure for everyone — at least in the initial term. This fervor would eventually be severely limited when Agustín de Iturbide would declare himself emperor of Mexico. A tumultuous era would begin, but nevertheless the foundations for a cohesive Mexico began taking place. The identities which emerged from such a racially stratified society blur the lines in the discussion of post-colonial identities. While the aforementioned figures that Miller cites indicate that the American Indian population declined drastically, it is equally possible that the American Indian identity was absorbed into the mestizos identity either for survival or as natural progression towards an independent and sovereign Mexico. It is here where the mestizos as an indigenous identity still exists even though their pre-colonial indigenous roots may have been lost during the dominance of New Spain. Denying that mestizos have indigenous heritage serves to perpetuate the colonial assumptions that to be indigenous means to be on the edge of extinction.
When looking at modern-day Mexico the ethnocultural distinctions exist in the framework of two categories: mestizos and indigenous (Navarrete). While the term mestizos has been removed from the modern Mexican vocabulary it still exists as a synonym for Mexican cultural heritage. Indigenous refers to the groups in Mexico who were able to hold onto their culture, traditions, and ancestral land as a distinguished group. Both distinctions also serve as political formations, especially in the context of rights, sovereignty, and self-determination. The specification of indigenous is strict in Mexico when compared to classifications in the United States. It requires individuals to live in a recognized indigenous society otherwise they lose indigenous status and then become mestizos (Indigenous Podcast). This is an interesting discernment and reveals the essence of mestizos in Mexican society. That because of the pervasive colonial discrimination from New Spain everyone must have the opportunity to be considered mestizos as to not reinforce racial hierarchy (especially in the case of criollos and Europeans).
In 1910, before the Great Revolution and during the Porfirio Diaz dictatorship, the ownership of land by the indigenous population was less than 10 percent (Miller 272). For this instance, indigenous refers to the distinct political identity, not within the mestizos national identity. It is during this period that a new problem plagued Mexico well into the late 20th century: the issue of foreign business. When looking at the facts it is a miracle that modern-day Mexico did not dissent into xenophobia like other countries in the region. However, this foreign business did create a justified cautiousness in the laws, regulations, congress, and among the individual populace in Mexico. The destructiveness that became foreign business could be seen in the maquiladora piece worker industry of 1965. Such an industry represented an era by which Mexico would be plagued by neocolonialism in the form of fulfilling loan agreements with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank. The conditions set on these loans forced Mexico to violate its own labor laws leading to horrific delegitimization of the state and mistrust from the people (Funari and Torre). This neocolonialism does not just take part in the form of foreign businesses who decide to set up in Mexico as an exploitative force, but also in those who benefit from destabilized nation-states. Manufacturers of firearms in the United States benefit from the drug trade along Mexico’s northern border. A relationship exists in which firearms manufacturers sell armaments to Mexican cartels and in turn the cartels destabilize the north of Mexico in a cycle of violence which consequently benefits firearms manufacturers (VanSickle). Such a relationship means that the gun lobby in the United States pushes politicians away from the total normalization of relations with Mexico. It is here where a neocolonial operation can be observed in that northern Mexico serves a unrecognized proxy colonial outpost by which firearms manufacturers can not only make money, but in which politicians benefiting from such gun lobbies can scapegoat their domestic Mexican-American citizenry and simultaneously fearmonger about violence along the United States border with Mexico.
In final discernments, it is important to take into account such factors when analyzing historical and modern Mexico. Pre-Columbian societies, Spanish colonization, the push for Mexican independence, the formation of identities and the effects of contemporary Mexico all intersect. Observations regarding these factors can only be viewed with a rich learning of Mexico’s history, which I have enjoyed. The study of such an important post-colonial society is crucial for understanding the formations that have taken place globally. It is these factors which make Mexico a highly unique and dynamic society to study.
Work Cited
Agencia Digital de Innovación Pública. “Primera Universidad (Real y Pontificia Universidad de México).” Ciudad de México: Lugares Históricos, https://mexicocity.cdmx.gob.mx/venues/royal-and-pontifical-university-of-mexico/.
Funari, Vicky, and Sergio De La Torre. “Maquilapolis.” YouTube, California Newsreel, 2006, https://youtu.be/C3EGupx8u18?si=_syppWwNmKzqTbC5.
Indigenous Podcast. “Are Mestizos Native American? (w/@New Amauta).” YouTube, 3 May 2021, https://youtu.be/CfMBwq5BfEo?si=iL-ni31xsz6TsavV.
Miller, Robert Ryal. Mexico: A History. University of Oklahoma Press, 1985.
Navarrete, Federico. “EL MESTIZAJE Y LAS CULTURAS REGIONALES.” Programa México Nación Multicultural de la UNAM: Las Relaciones Interétnicas en México, 2005. Pontificia Universidad Católica del Perú, https://red.pucp.edu.pe/ridei/files/2012/02/120203.pdf.
VanSickle, Abbie. “Supreme Court Blocks Mexico's Suit Against U.S. Gun Makers.” The New York Times, 5 June 2025, https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/05/us/politics/supreme-court-mexico-gunmakers.html.
Image courtesy of Ricky Esquivel