Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Jul. 17th, 2026
In 1798, the French military officer, Napoleon Bonaparte, led an invasion fleet consisting of 400 ships and 36,000 men to Egypt’s shores. Outnumbering the Mamluk army, Napoleon crushed what was once considered one of the strongest militaries on the planet, sending shockwaves throughout Africa and Asia. When the invading French army entered the city of Cairo, Napoleon declared that he was there to “liberate” the people from the “oppressive rule of the Mamluks.” The people of Cairo looked at each other in confusion. Were they being oppressed? Did they need to be liberated?
In his proclamation, Napoleon declared that he was Muslim and more devoted to the ways of Islam than the Mamluks:
People of Egypt: You will be told by our enemies, that I am coming to destroy your religion. Believe them not. Tell them that I am coming to restore your rights, punish your usurpers, and raise the true worship of Mahomet. Tell them that I venerate, more than do the Mamelukes, God, His prophet, and the Koran. Tell them that all men are equal in the sight of God; that wisdom, talents, and virtue alone constitute the difference between them (Jabartī 24-26).
French Orientalists, the main advisors to Napoleon, were convinced that Muslims were a simple-minded people who could be convinced of sincerity by evoking the Qur'an. French occupation of Egypt lasted until 1801, with Napoleon secretly abandoning his army in 1799. A month before his departure, Napoleon wrote to his brother:
Egypt is richer than any country in the world in corn, rice, vegetables, and cattle. But the people are in a state of utter barbarism (Jabartī 145).
During the end of occupation, the French army resorted to indiscriminate bombing of city centers along with the targeted desecration and destruction of churches and mosques. In the ensuing battles, chroniclers from the era reported witnessing masses of dead bodies floating down the Nile River.
The historical significance of Napoleon’s invasion of Egypt in relation to Bishop Mariann Edgar Budde’s address may be lost on some readers, but for West Asians and North Africans it is quite apparent. Napoleon’s failed invasion of Egypt marked the beginning of European colonialism in the Middle East (West Asia and North Africa). It was the start of Europeans talking at what they deemed to be their inferior colonial subjects. To be Arab, or Amazigh, or Persian, or Palestinian, or any of the many ethnic groups that extend from Iberia to the Bactrian mountains, is to exist in a centuries long debate over the autonomy of our own neurological systems: whether the functioning of our human minds have been subverted by the cultural ties of our birth and the Islamic influence on our societies. The consensus for the European is the obvious answer of, yes, our neurological systems have been hijacked and therefore our minds function on the basis of fanaticism first, rationalization second. This is at the heart of the Western perspective when it engages with our societies. One need only watch a few American, British, or French films before they inevitably hear a quip degrading and dehumanizing Arabs, or Muslims. It exists at the foundations of nation building for the West, for to be of “the West” there must be an “East,” just as for the colonizer to colonize there must be a “Native.” These otherized societies and peoples must be stripped of their individuality and labelled in a system which allows for a militarized subjugation. People cease to be people, and instead their indigeneity is demonized to justify the implementation of supremacist systems by their colonizer.
I am American, I was born in the United States - but my ancestors hail from Iraq, a very old society which still upholds many of the linguistic and cultural attributes from over 7,000 years ago. Ethnically, I am a mix of Arab, Iraqi Turkmen, Kurdish, and Persian. My great-grandfather spoke Arabic, Ottoman Turkish, Iraqi Turkish, and Kurdish. My great-uncle, a famous poet whose statues litter the country’s North, wrote his poetry in Turkish, Kurdish, and Persian. This was the expectation of educated individuals living in Iraq towards the end of the Ottoman Empire. You spoke four or five languages and participated in the pluralism that was the privilege of living in such a society for thousands of years. Maybe your first language was Turkish like my father’s family, maybe it was Arabic like my mother’s family, or maybe it was Aramaic like that of Jesus and his Disciples; whatever it was it mattered little to the broader society, as everyone existed under a coherent Iraqi culture and recognized each other as such.
By the time I was born, at the cusp of the following century: Arabic, English, and French were the dominant languages spoken in my home. Arabic is the dominant language of Iraq, the one language you need to know for traversal and communication in the country. English operates in the U.S. the same way Arabic does in Iraq, it is the dominant language of the country. But why French? It is not a common language in California or New Mexico, the states which I grew up in. Nor is it a common language in Iraq. French, and its existence as a spoken language in my home is the product of the past 200 years of colonialism, beginning with Napoleon. The existence of French in my home is a prime example of the regression of modern society in relation to its former-colonies. Despite my Turkish name, I was not exposed to Turkish, Kurdish, or Persian in my home. Instead, above the languages of my great-grandparents, I was exposed to French due to its pervasiveness across the Arab world. These are the aftershocks of colonialism, that a 21st century child several generations removed from the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, a generation removed from the collapse of the French colonies, and an ocean apart — is to speak French.
Today, I am more an Arab from Iraq, than a Turk from Anatolia, or a Kurd from Persia. The languages of Turkish, Kurdish, and Persian are foreign to me, and thus too are the subtle intricacies of their societies built upon such linguistic superstructures. If the British did not colonize our lands and force my grandparents to leave, then such societies would feel more integral to my character — but such are the scars that history has presented to us.
Colonialism is not a distant memory of the past, for us it is our present and our future. The old guard of colonialism exists in its last vestiges in West Asia and North Africa. At the heart of this colonial endeavor, this final remnant of a dead world, is Israel. They are the last society on the planet enacting traditionalist forms of colonialism on indigenous populations. Israel is directly dominating Palestine, Lebanon, and Syria through political, military and territorial control by the establishment of settlements, the exploitation of resources, and the genocide of indigenous populations. In our communities Palestine is not a question, it is an answer. It is the answer to liberating ourselves from the pervasive systems which have infiltrated and upended our existence.
Now that the context of being Arab has been presented, the following text will focus on analyzing the content of Bishop Budde’s speech. It will prove that the only correct way to engage with Palestine is through the perspective of the colonizer and the colonized; and that the Bishop presented a paternalistic, tonally patronizing and ultimately duplicitous lecture that hid itself in civility politics while denying the self-determination of the Palestinian people.
The Book Of Esther
On October 29, 1948, the Israeli military unleashed Operation Hiram in the Upper Galilee region of Palestine. The military objectives of Operation Hiram were to occupy and depopulate Palestinian villages that the Israeli military deemed to be an “Arab enclave.” In the first 48-hours, the Israeli military carried out massacres in the villages of Safsaf, Jish, Aylabun, Majd Al-Kurum, Saliha, Sa’sa, and the Khirbat Arab al-Samina. By hour 60, an estimated 45,000 people were forcibly displaced. Many of them fled to Lebanon, some to Jordan, others were taken in by relatives and friends in neighboring villages. By the end of October, a total of nine massacres were carried out by the Israeli military during Operation Hiram.
In the Upper Galilee, along the border with Lebanon, was the Palestinian village of Kafr Bir'im in the Safad District. Written records of the village dated back to the Middle Ages, however in the village’s northern neighborhood lived the ruins of an ancient Roman temple accompanied by the remnants of a paved Roman square. The village name was believed to derive from the Canaanite name, Periyam, meaning “abundant with fruit.” Kafr Bir’im was the only Christian village in the Safad District and home to over 1,050 people.
On November 7, 1948, the village came under Israeli military occupation. Over the course of eight months the Israeli occupational forces conducted several waves of expulsions. In June of 1949, Israeli settlers began to move into the homes of the former native inhabitants as they awaited the construction of a nearby kibbutz on village land. The Jewish settlement would be called Kibbutz Bar’am and was completed in the summer of 1951 for the settlers. In that time, the Israeli settlers vandalized Kafr Bir’im, stole its land, uprooted its olive trees, attacked its church, destroyed its wells, and used the stone from its houses to pave the main street of Kibbutz Bar’am. By 1953, the village was empty with the last of its native inhabitants forcibly relocated to the village of Jish. On the days of September 16 and 17, the Israeli military conducted aerial bombardment operations that destroyed all the houses of Kafr Bir’im, sparing only its church building and former school. From the village of Jish, Sami Zahra watched her once abundant village get bombed:
When the planes appeared above the village, and the houses were bombed, we all went up a hill located in the high area of Jish overlooking Kafr Bir’im. Every time a bomb fell on a house, the people would mention the name of the house owner and cry, and wait for the next bomb which would destroy the next house. They were unable to intervene against the destruction …Ever since that time, the hill has been called the ‘Bir’imites wailing place (Boqai 35).
In conflicting Jewish traditions, the village of Kafr Bir’im was believed to be one of the possible burial sites of Queen Esther, from the Book of Esther in the Hebrew Bible. Today, the village and its surrounding land have been converted into a national park, nature reserve, and tourist zone. A sign describes the village ruins as the site of an ancient Jewish village; there is no mention of its existence as a Christian village. Kafr Bir’im was erased, its history rewritten and its people dispossessed.
When I discuss Bishop Budde’s remarks on the Book of Esther, I am not making a theological argument because Bishop Budde does not make a theological argument. She made a political prescription; thus, my analysis will be both political, historical and rhetorical in nature. Why she chose a chapter in the Old Testament in which God is absent is unknown, but such a decision will be explored in the following section.
Bishop Budde’s retelling of the events evidently, for the sake of brevity, leaves out key details. However, this brief retelling becomes irrelevant for those who know the story well, because the conclusion to the story is quite clear. For those who are unfamiliar with the story, I will begin by relaying it to you in greater detail before analyzing rhetorical inaccuracies and assumptions made in her speech. The translation of the Bible I will be relying on is the New International Version (NIV), due to its accessibility and readability — but I do compare Esther 9:5 with other biblical translations, as you will see later in my analysis.
The story of the Book of Esther begins with Queen Vashti, the wife of King Xerxes of Persia, being deposed after her defiance to King Xerxes’ wishes. She is replaced by Queen Esther, who is chosen among a group of girls in the royal harem. Esther was raised by her first-cousin, Mordecai, who became more of a father-figure to her and who Bishop Budde referred to as “Esther’s uncle.” Mordecai forbade her from revealing her Jewish identity to the king. While the ceremonies were taking place to elevate Esther’s status, Mordecai overheard two king’s guards discussing a plot to assassinate the king. Mordecai told this to Queen Esther, who relayed the information to King Xerxes. Queen Esther and Mordecai gained favor with the king, as the two guards were impaled on poles for their treachery.
In another ceremony, King Xerxes honored Haman, granting him the highest status of all other nobles in Persia. However, Mordecai refused to bow to Haman when all others did. Haman was informed of Mordecai’s Jewish background and decided he would take revenge on all his people for his insolence by convincing the king to issue a royal decree. To convince the king, Haman said as follows:
“There is a certain people dispersed among the peoples in all the provinces of your kingdom who keep themselves separate. Their customs are different from those of all other people, and they do not obey the king’s laws; it is not in the king’s best interest to tolerate them. If it pleases the king, let a decree be issued to destroy them, and I will give ten thousand talents of silver to the king’s administrators for the royal treasury.” [NIV Esther 3:8-9]
King Xerxes issued his decree and Haman dispatched orders in all the kingdom’s languages, across all the kingdom’s provinces, to annihilate all the Jews in the kingdom. Mordecai found out about these orders and petitioned Esther to use her status to save the Jews, saying to her:
“Do not think that because you are in the king’s house you alone of all the Jews will escape. For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father’s family will perish. And who knows but that you have come to your royal position for such a time as this?” [NIV Esther 4:13-14]
Esther petitioned King Xerxes to save her people from the plot to annihilate them. When the king asked who devised this plot, Esther told him it was Haman and thus Haman was impaled on a pole. Queen Esther was granted Haman’s estate and she revealed to King Xerxes her Jewish identity and relationship to Mordecai. She begged the king to put a stop to Haman’s evil plan and he agreed:
The king’s edict granted the Jews in every city the right to assemble and protect themselves; to destroy, kill and annihilate the armed men of any nationality or province who might attack them and their women and children, and to plunder the property of their enemies. [NIV Esther 8:11]
The new edict gave the Jews legal permission to defend themselves from Haman’s edict of extermination. Mordecai left the king’s palace wearing blue and white, a golden crown, and purple robes. As Jews began celebrating in the streets, many nationalities converted Judaism out of fear of the Jews.
The Jews struck down all their enemies with the sword, killing and destroying them, and they did what they pleased to those who hated them. [NIV Esther 9:5]
Mordecai’s reputation became known throughout the provinces. The satraps, the governors, and the court officials worked with him out of fear they would meet the same fate. Haman’s ten sons were killed and impaled on poles for the public to see. In total, the Jews killed over 75,000 people but did not plunder from those they killed despite plundering being permitted by the king. From these events, the Jewish holiday of Purim was created to celebrate the victory of the Jews over their enemies.
Whether the Jews killed 75,000 people out of “self-defense” is a matter of debate. Some scholars cite the lack of indulgence in plunder to signify it was self-defense. However, the text would seem to contradict this narrative as the Jews were so feared that people converted to avoid their wrath in addition to the inclusion of Esther 9:5 which details that the Jews, “did what they pleased to those who hated them,” a phrase which generally implies mutilation or rape in both ancient and contemporary works. Across English-language translations, including the two common translations in the Episcopalian Church (the church of Bishop Budde), the verse comes out the same:
So the Jews struck down all their enemies with the sword, slaughtering, and destroying them, and did as they pleased to those who hated them. [NRS Esther 9:5]
Thus the Jews smote all their enemies with the stroke of the sword, and slaughter, and destruction, and did what they would unto those that hated them. [KJV Esther 9:5]
The most significant difference can be found in the Douay-Rheims Catholic Bible:
So the Jews made a great slaughter of their enemies, and killed them, repaying according to what they had prepared to do to them… [RHE Esther 9:5]
The difference is subtle and one could in fact interpret such a verse as being worse than the previous translations depending on what the enemies of the Jews had intended to do to them.
God is not present in the Book of Esther. It is the story of how the Jews killed their enemies. It is a story of revenge, of an ancestral catharsis of violence — arguably the least justifiable form of violence. The inclusion of this story in Bishop Budde’s speech at a time when Israel, a state which claims to be the home of the Jewish people, has killed tens of thousands of people in the name of “self-defense,” is incredibly dangerous. In doing so, Bishop Budde affirmed and legitimized the genocidal nature of Israeli actions across the entirety of West Asia.
Before we discuss further what such implications mean, let us analyze what Bishop Budde said in relation to the Book of Esther. She says:
In the Jewish Bible, there’s the story of Esther. The young Jewish woman who, through circumstances beyond her control, finds herself in the court of a Persian king ruling over Israel. And when horrific plans to eradicate the Jewish people from Persia comes to light, Esther’s uncle, as you recall, sends word to Esther pleading with her to use her position for good. She protests, for good reason. She has seen how any woman in the court who dares even to speak up is put to death. And her uncle replies with words that reverberate across time and space: ‘To us, who knows, perhaps you have come to your royal dignity for just a time as this (Budde 00:35:50).
The first point of contention and textual inaccuracy is that “Israel” is not mentioned once in the Book of Esther. The story focuses on the plight of Persian Jews; and though the Achaemenid Empire (550–330 BCE) ruled over Philistia (meaning ‘Land of Peleset’ [Greek: Γη των Φυλιστιειμ]: comprising the cities of Gaza (غزة), Askelon (‘Asqalan: عسقلان), Ashdod (Isdud: إسدود), Tantur (Tantura: الطنطورة), Gath (Jat: جت), Ekron (‘Aqir: عقر) that were mostly depopulated by Zionist forces in 1948), what the Jewish tradition refers to as the ‘Land of Israel,’ the Book of Esther makes no indication that any events happened in these places (Masalha 59). Now one could make the theological argument that Israel lies in the heart of all Jews and is wherever the Jews come together in community, but the phrase “ruling over Israel” signifies a place rather than a feeling. Jews of the Achaemenid Empire, like many of the peoples living in the empire, did not just reside in one place. This is why the story takes place in the city of Susa, a city that was located near the border of modern-day Iraq and Iran. Esther and Mordecai live in Susa as Jews, and the text even mentions how Jews live in the rural provinces surrounding the city and live throughout the empire. This was a common feature of the region, that peoples from different ethnic groups and religions did not feel limited to a single part of the empire because tolerance was an upheld virtue. In fact, this practice lasted up until the decline and fall of the Ottoman Empire (1299-1922 CE) which saw the eventual formal adoption of the European nation-state and the practice of setting distinct borders.
The second point of contention is a matter of unspecificity and a careless use of language which can be easily misinterpreted. This appears in the sentence “and when horrific plans to eradicate the Jewish people from Persia comes to light, Esther’s uncle, as you recall, sends word to Esther pleading with her to use her position for good.” If we focus on “plans to eradicate the Jewish people from Persia” it is clear this sentence can be interpreted in two ways: that there are plans to eradicate the Jewish people living in Persia, or that Persia plans to eradicate the Jews. The use of the word “from” creates vagueness in the meaning of the sentence leaving the audience to attempt to parse out what was truly meant. It is important to note that this vagueness was a constant feature of Bishop Budde’s speech and at times bordered on duplicity, which will be addressed in the next two sections.
Intentional or unintentional, what is presented in Bishop Budde’s oversimplification is a binary steeped in a heavily Westernized interpretation of the Bible. Presenting the binary of “Persia and Israel,” or “Persia and the Jews,” places the people of that region in an occurrence of ahistoricism that removes the pluralism which the people of ancient Persia benefited from. Philistia, or Palaistinê (Παλαιστίνη) in Greek — denoting the land between Phoenicia and Egypt — was a territory of the Persian ruled Achaemenid Empire (Masalha 45). This Persian empire was one of the largest of the Ancient World, with a diverse array of subjects, including: Greeks, Egyptians, Phoenicians, Babylonians, Arabs, Assyrians, Bactrians, Indians, and many other peoples. Aramaic was the lingua-franca of the empire, but administrative correspondence was conducted in Greek. This incredible linguistic pluralism was joined by a cultural and religious toleration which included the Jews. Therefore, the story would not present a narrative of “the Jews versus Persia,” because such a binary would be inconceivable to the people of this time period. Persia acts as a neutral setting in the story and could even be argued that towards the end of the story, transitions into a positive force that grants Mordecai and the Jews the power to enact vengeance upon their enemies. Even the ambiguity of the “enemies” illustrates the unwillingness for the writers to demonize a specific group of people, mainly because the lines between peoples were blurred. Apart from Haman and his family, the enemies are described simply as people who dislike the Jews; something which emphasizes that people's beliefs or dispositions were more important than where they came from. It is Haman who is singled out in the story and punished for his intolerance of a people and abuse of his political prestige.
By drawing up a juxtaposition between Persia and Israel, where none is present in the written-text, Bishop Budde positions herself in a political binary more fit for the modern-age. The great irony of this is that in today’s political climate, Bishop Budde aligns herself more closely with the Evangelical Christian-Right in America on this specific instance, with their literal interpretation of the Book of Revelations, than with Unitarian Universalists or anyone resisting the Trumpian vision of the world. The myth-narrative of Revelations being that in the Earth's final days, Persia and a nameless army from the North will invade the lands of Israel triggering the ‘Second Coming of Christ.’ A central part of the reason why the Trump regime and the Department of War, run by Pete Hegseth (a self-proclaimed Christian Crusader), has declared war on Iran. It is why in March of 2026, independent journalists and the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) reported receiving over 200 complaints from service members across all branches of the U.S. military claiming that commanders had been joyfully telling them that war with Iran is evidence of Armageddon's imminence (Lennard). Bishop Budde’s alignment with these elements of society is likely unintentional, judging from her political views on the United States domestic instability, but this alignment with the Right is nevertheless a fact of subscribing to or flirting with Zionist thought. Liberals who support Israel enter a paradox of ideology in which they become fundamentally illiberal when it comes to Palestine. This illiberalism in the case of Palestine stems from a tradition of a centuries long Orientalism in the West, a lack of reconciliation with the history of colonialism, and in many cases subconscious or conscious racial prejudice towards the “people of the Orient.” In today’s world, the exception of Palestine becomes more than the acquiescence and acceptance of its erasure, but the active participation in a system of silence that, in every historical instance, allowed for the foundations of genocide to be laid. The illiberal exception to Palestine inevitably aligns itself with arguably the greatest enemy to liberalism — fascism.
It is impossible to know Bishop Budde’s intentions, but the evocation of the Book of Esther set the tone of her entire speech. The conclusion to said story is the revenge of the Jewish people on their enemies by the slaughter of 75,000 people. Is it that Bishop Budde was justifying the genocide in Gaza as a benefit of the historical persecution of the Jews? Is it that the state of Israel has come to its "royal dignity,” to continue the command of Mordecai and carry out his massacres into the modern-age? Is it that Iranian cities deserve to be carpet-bombed because of the actions of one biblical character?
The interpretations seem ludicrous, but how else are we supposed to interpret this story within the wider context of her speech. There are real consequences to this story that we are seeing happen in real time. In 2025, Pennsylvania State University conducted a poll in which Israeli Jews were asked if they support the forced expulsion of Palestinians in Gaza, and 82% said yes. When those same Israelis were asked if they agreed that “when conquering an enemy city, the Israel Defense Forces should act as the Israelites did in Jericho under Joshua's command – killing all its inhabitants” a total of 47% said yes. 65% said they believe in a modern-day Amalek (the biblical enemy of the Israelites that God commanded to be annihilated in Deuteronomy 25:19), and 93% said the commandment is still relevant (Hazkani). It is clear that the myth-narratives of Israel’s founding and continued existence are reliant on the narratives of the Old and New Testament. These myth-narratives do not exist in a vacuum and cannot be treated as such. They continue to stoke the flames of both Christian nationalism and Jewish supremacy. In these biblical texts, both Christian Zionists and Jewish Zionists find the justifications for the enactment of genocide on an indigenous population. Some of the same justifications that were once used in the genocide of the Americas by Christian settlers, long before the creation of the state of Israel. Bishop Budde gave no in-depth analysis of the story, nor did she take the care to include such a story with the tact that was deserved. By being uncritical and vague in her evocation of the Book of Esther, she participated in the proliferation of said myth-narratives and affirmed the beliefs of individuals in the audience who espouse them.
Napoleon Returns
In 1923, a Russian Jew by the name of Ze’ev Jabotinsky wrote an essay which planted the seeds for the modern Israeli-state. The essay, titled “The Iron Wall,” articulated that the only way for Zionism to fulfill its aims was through the use of military force. He argued that Jews in Palestine must create an “iron wall” which the native population cannot penetrate. This show of military force would subdue and coerce the native population, ultimately deterring them from resisting against the formation of a majority Jewish state. He described the anatomy of the wall as the following:
Zionist colonisation must either stop, or else proceed regardless of the native population. Which means that it can proceed and develop only under the protection of a power that is independent of the native population – behind an iron wall, which the native population cannot breach (Jabotinsky).
Shortly after writing the essay, Jabotinsky founded the Revisionist Zionism movement and a few years later founded its political arm: the Union for Revisionist Zionists, or Hatzohar. The term “revisionist” was in reference to the belief that the World Zionist Organization was too permissive of British policies in Palestine and therefore needed to be revised. While many Zionist leaders debated on what Zionism should be, Jabotinsky was clear with what Zionism is:
Every native population, civilised or not, regards its lands as its national home, of which it is the sole master, and it wants to retain that mastery always; it will refuse to admit not only new masters but, even new partners or collaborators. This is equally true of the Arabs… They feel at least the same instinctive jealous love of Palestine, as the old Aztecs felt for ancient Mexico, and their Sioux for their rolling Prairies (Jabotinsky).
The citing of European colonization in North America resonated with a lot of Zionist Jews in Europe. It was an honest portrayal of a future successful Jewish occupation of Palestine, a piece of the European colonial machine which European Jews could finally call their own. This militant sketch of what Zionism meant for Palestine attracted many to the Revisionist movement as it became a chance for young Jewish men to test their mettle in an expansionist project.
The wall was to be created by Jewish soldiers or with the help of the British military. Jabotinsky had co-founded the Jewish Legion, which were a series of battalions led by Jewish soldiers serving under the British during World War I. They were battle-hardened and assisted in the conquering of Palestine for the British during the war. Fearing an independent Jewish military force, the British disbanded the battalions in 1921, undermining Jabotinsky’s plans for the wall. Members of the recently disbanded Jewish Legion were quickly absorbed into the newly formed Haganah: a paramilitary organization which sought to defend Jewish settlements in Palestine. By the early 1930s, Jabotinsky’s movement began aligning itself with Benito Mussolini’s fascist Italy, in opposition to the British. The alliance with Italy was short-lived as Mussolini grew closer to Adolf Hilter, however, Jabotinsky still saw fascism as the only viable option for most countries. He was a fervent anti-socialist and believed that democracy had only worked in England, thus he concluded fascism to be the solvent for many nation-states around the world.
In 1931, from the ranks of the Haganah, adherents to Jabotinsky’s ideals of Revisionist Zionism formed a splinter paramilitary group called the Irgun. Intent on establishing Jewish supremacy on both sides of the Jordan River, the Irgun carried out attacks on Palestinian villages and British military installations across the region. The most famous of these attacks were the bombing of the King David Hotel (1946) and the Deir Yassin massacre (1948), both organized by Irgun leader and eventual Prime Minister of Israel, Menachem Begin. The Haganah, Irgun, and other Zionist paramilitary organizations were then later absorbed into the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), following Israel’s Declaration of Independence after the ethnic cleansing of over 750,000 Palestinians in the 1948 Nakba, or “Catastrophe” in Arabic.
Ze’ev Jabotinsky’s would cease command of the Revisionist Movement after his death in 1940, but his teachings would live on in his mentee, Benzion Netanyahu (the father of Benjamin Natanyahu) and his self-proclaimed disciple, Menachem Begin. The militant legacy of the Irgun along with the political power of the Hatzohar, would be institutionalized and legitimized in the right-wing Herut party, founded by Begin, and the Likud party, co-founded by Begin along with former-Prime Minister and Israeli General Ariel Sharon, often called “The Butcher of Beirut" for his role in the Sabra and Shatila massacres.
Beginning in 1945, British Labour Party MP and Anglo-American Committee member, Richard Crossman, became a staunch advocate for the Zionist cause. He attributed Zionism to being akin to the American “‘frontier mentality’” and that “‘Zionism… is merely the attempt by the European Jew to rebuild his national life on the soil of Palestine’” similar to how “‘the American settler developed the West’” (Kaplan 20). Crossman continued in detailing South Africa and Australia as fulfilling similar projects yet noticeably does not mention Britain’s first settler-colonial invasion, that being Ireland. Use of the term “develop” revealed Crossman’s support for Zionism; however his observations present a look into early American dispositions. The novel turned film, Exodus, by Leon Uris, further inseminated the frontier narrative into the American psyche. Selling over 20 million copies, the novel had “a profound impact on the Americanization of Israel’s origins” by comparing American Indians to Arabs, rejuvenating Jewish masculinity after the perceived emasculation of The Holocaust (similar to how Westward Expansion rejuvenated American masculinity after industrialization), and portrayed Jewish settlers as civilizing the “dark, chaotic regions” of the world. By 1967, and Israel's violent expansion of territory, Israel was seen as an imperial force which assisted America in Soviet containment and against the revolutionary movement of Third World nations. Israel had become, what Theodore Herzl had intended, a strategic military outpost for the U.S. and Europe, or as the 1968 South African government put it: “‘defending an outpost of western, white civilization in a sea of uncivilized hordes’” (Kaplan 60, 75, 95, 115). In this construction the Palestinian or Arab is the “uncivilized horde” who stops at nothing to destroy civilization.
Israel has always been a colonial project with deep ties to fascism. The idea that it is only the current regime committing genocide or that the majority of Israelis are against what is happening to the Palestinians, as if it has not been tolerated for the past 78 years, is a comforting lie that modern liberals tell themselves. It is a false assumption that exists to preserve the facade of Western superiority, because if genocide could happen in a democracy with Western values, then what makes the West better than the rest of the world?
The answer was always that nothing made the West better. Economic dominance and wealth was built on the backs of colonies in Africa, Asia, and the Americas. When you read Jane Austen or watch your favorite show about the English aristocracy, does it ever occur to you how they accrued their wealth? Likely not, because an entire system perpetrated on the violent exploitation of people is ignored for the drama and romance of the English countryside. Wealth during that time was only such due to a global militarized occupation that turned human beings into spreadsheets of collateral damage in the ruthless pursuit of capital. When the French colonized Vietnam and forced its population onto the rubber plantation, two different descriptions for rubber were adopted. The French called it “white gold,” but the Vietnamese called it “white blood.” Where Europeans saw wealth and profit, the people of their colonies watched the blood-soaked hands of their kin labor away at gunpoint. The genocide does not die with Netanyahu, because he is a product of Israeli colonization: an intention set out since the first brick laid upon the very first kibbutz.
While there are many similarities with Palestine and other colonial projects around the world, one must recognize that the prejudice or racial animosity from Europeans towards the people of West Asia and North Africa is one of a specific kind. It is a prejudice reliant on abstractions and the ignoring or sheer dismissal of the people who live there. Early I mentioned that Napoleon was accompanied by French Orientalist scholars who informed Napoleon’s view of Egypt. But what does it mean to be an Orientalist?
The term Orientalism was coined in 1978 in the seminal 20th century work, Orientalism, written by the Columbia University professor, Edward W. Said, who was among the founders of post-colonial studies. In his book, Said articulated that The Orient was first categorically manufactured on the page, culminating into an estimated “60,000 books dealing with the Near Orient… written between 1800 and 1950” (Said 204). These fantastical written “accounts” created a self-reinforcing and entirely internal body of work which interacted with each other. While these often-paternalistic scrutinizing fantasies about the Orient were completely falsifiable, they eventually etched their way into consequential material realities. He observed that by the 19th century the “slow process of appropriation by which Europe, or the European awareness of the Orient, transformed itself from being textual and contemplative into being administrative, economic, and even military” (Said 210). Towards the end of his book, Edward Said denoted a “Last Phase” in contemporary Orientalism under the guise of a U.S. hegemonic power. It deals with media representation and the policy wonks who work off the premise of Orientalist literature. He specified that “the principal dogmas of Orientalism still exist in their purest form today in the studies of the Arabs and Islam” (Said 300). The first of the dogmas being the West is “rational, developed, humane, superior” compared to the "aberrant, underdeveloped, inferior” Orient. Second, that abstractions are preferable to “direct evidence drawn from modern Oriental realities.” Third, being that the Orient is “incapable of defining itself,” existing in an eternal and uniform state. And the fourth exists under the premise that the Orient is to be feared and therefore must be kept under control, pacified, and ultimately contained (Said 301). These abstractions and dogmas are used to justify Western intervention in the Orient, Near East, Middle East, or whatever other pejorative can be conjured up.
In the modern era, this phase of Orientalism has inhabited the foundations of a symbiotic relationship between the United States and Israel. The U.S. provides Israel with weaponry, financial support, and protection from international pressure. For Israel, the U.S. symbolizes a framework and inspiration for fulfilling their genocidal aims throughout the Middle East. For the U.S., Israel is not only a forward military operating base — but also a testing site for new weapons of war, surveillance technology, law enforcement tactics, and totalitarian methods of control. In the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq, the U.S. occupation applied “counterinsurgency tactics that the Israeli military used in the occupied territories [of Palestine]” (Kaplan 246). A boomerang effect has occurred in which the “Americanization of Israel” has now become the “Israelification of America.” Beginning with Bush, the U.S. created the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), signed the Patriot Act, and with it, rolled out a massive government surveillance network under the guise of “counter-terrorism.” Today, law enforcement continues to train with Israeli soldiers, massive training centers called “Cop Cities” are being built, DHS agents are snatching suspected immigrants off the street, killing “domestic terrorists,” and a pervasive surveillance network is being expanded upon through Flock systems, AI tracking, license plate readers, and face scanning technology, all in the name of “Homeland” as the U.S. and Israeli governments work towards fulfilling plans to integrate their militaries together.
Everything in the modern world is intersectional, what is permitted to occur in Palestine will eventually be permitted in Europe and North America. The genocide in Gaza, the ethnic cleansing of the West Bank, the invasion and systematic destruction of Lebanon, the annexation of Syrian territory, the bombing of Iran and Yemen, have all become the West’s primary testing grounds for the modern systems of oppression that Western leaders are itching to use on their domestic populations and in many avenues, already have. This boomerang has already occurred in human history before. It was the great Martinican scholar Aimé Césaire, in his essay “Discourse on Colonialism,” who explained that The Holocaust of World War II was colonialism reflected back onto Europe. He articulated that the many holocausts Europe had perpetuated throughout the world had finally come to Europe, resulting in the systematic annihilation of over 14 million people by the Nazi regime. Césaire writes:
First we must study how colonization works to decivilize the colonizer, to brutalize him in the true sense of the word, to degrade him, to awaken him to buried instincts, to covetousness, violence, race hatred, and moral relativism; and we must show that each time a head is cut off or an eye put out in Vietnam and in France they accept the fact, each time a little girl is raped and in France they accept the fact, each time a Madagascan is tortured and in France they accept the fact, civilization acquires another dead weight, a universal regression takes place, a gangrene sets in, a center of infection begins to spread; and that at the end of all these treaties that have been violated, all these lies that have been propagated, all these punitive expeditions that have been tolerated, all these prisoners who have been tied up and "interrogated," all these patriots who have been tortured, at the end of all the racial pride that has been encouraged, all the boastfulness that has been displayed, a poison has been distilled into the veins of Europe and, slowly but surely, the continent proceeds toward savagery.
And then one fine day the bourgeoisie is awakened by a terrific boomerang effect: the gestapos are busy, the prisons fill up, the torturers standing around the racks invent, refine, discuss.
People are surprised, they become indignant. They say: "How strange! But never mind—it's Nazism, it will pass!" And they wait, and they hope; and they hide the truth from themselves, that it is barbarism, the supreme barbarism, the crowning barbarism that sums up all the daily barbarisms; that it is Nazism, yes, but that before they were its victims, they were its accomplices; that they tolerated that Nazism before it was inflicted on them, that they absolved it, shut their eyes to it, legitimized it, because, until then, it had been applied only to non-European peoples; that they have cultivated that Nazism, that they are responsible for it, and that before engulfing the whole edifice of Western, Christian civilization in its reddened waters, it oozes, seeps, and trickles from every crack (Césaire 35-36).
Europe did not learn its lessons from World War II, instead the boomerang was vaulted once again and now it is returning with an even greater force than before. The genocide in Gaza, the most documented genocide in human history, has revealed a sadism never before seen. It is these disturbing avenues and the unquestioning defense of it by the West which has only reiterated Césaire’s thesis. Tolerance in Europe or North America only exists for people who have been included in the racial construction of Whiteness. Europe will gladly tolerate genocide by a European nation onto a non-European nation, but they will not tolerate Muslim immigration into their borders. It is this tolerance which directly led to the formation of fascism and the Nazi regime. It is this tolerance which has given Israel a blank check to repeat the crimes of the 19th and 20th centuries.
James Baldwin, in a 1969 interview, articulated the paradox of Western tolerance beautifully when he said:
When the Israelis pick up guns, or the Poles, or the Irish, or any white man in the world says “Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death!” the entire white world applauds. When a Black man says exactly the same thing, word for word, he is judged a criminal and treated like one… George Washington is not one of my heroes, neither is Booker T. Washington. What the American public has always tried to do is to accommodate me into a system which has always meant my death. They want me to become an accomplice to my own murder, that is what you really mean by integration ("James Baldwin’s Prophetic Warning to America").
The tolerance of the West is a deception. It is not universal by any measure because it decides before the fact that its boundaries will not go beyond the white man. Israel is the extension of Europe, it is the white man’s fist that is meant to keep the Muslim hordes at bay and when it fails to do so, Europe silently wishes for a campaign of extermination.
Bishop Budde preached this same form of tolerance. She was fundamentally telling the colonized to have a conversation with their colonizer, knowing full well the power structures that are in place. How are you supposed to have a conversation with a person who does not view you as human, who sees you as less than their pet dog?
It cannot be done, as Ghassan Kanafani would say, this is a conversation between “the sword and the neck” (Carleton). To not understand this element of the discourse reveals that she prioritizes conversation with Zionists and the colonizer, rather than conversations with Palestinians and the colonized. But let us not belabor this point until we analyze the content of her speech.
Since some of you may not have watched, listened to, or read the speech, I will continue including the excerpts where Palestine is mentioned, then we will pick it apart piece by piece. Here she compares herself to the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King:
You may recall how Martin Luther King expressed frustration in his letter from the Birmingham jail address to Christian leaders in Birmingham, including an Episcopal Bishop who criticized him for going too far, too fast; in his efforts to eradicate segregation and other institutional expressions of racism. And speaking as an Episcopal Bishop, I’ve been on the receiving end of that same frustration from some of you and members in my own faith community who want me to take stronger stands on all sorts of issues; and especially against our country’s support of the state of Israel’s war against the Palestinian people, the horrific use of starvation, and the indiscriminate bombing of an entire population (Budde 00:46:25).
The mention of Dr. King brings about an uncomfortable thought; that the comparisons were related to Dr. King’s stance on Zionism. Bishop Budde seamlessly transitioned from self-comparison to Dr. King, to criticisms regarding her stance on Palestine. It is possible that Bishop Budde was presenting an avenue of exculpation through the mentioning of Dr. King, who was in support of Zionism and the Israeli state. If anybody criticized her on her stance regarding Palestine, she could easily say that she is following the legacy of Dr. King as a means of deflection. If this was her intent, said perspective clearly lacks a historical understanding of the era. Despite Dr. King's support for Israel, it is likely that it would not have lasted long. Cornel West, in his book articulating the revolutionary spirit and democratic socialism of Dr. King, describes King’s stance as such:
The radical King looked at Jews through the lens of precious peoples terrorized, traumatized, and stigmatized for more than two thousand years. His radical love embraced Jews and their fragile predicament—here and abroad. There is no doubt King supported Zionism—the Jewish quest for self-determination—yet he did not live long enough to witness a vicious Israeli occupation that terrorizes, traumatizes, and stigmatizes precious Palestinians (King and West, Introduction).
While I am not in complete agreement with Cornel West’s perspective on Palestine, he raises an important analytical frame. Dr. King’s theology was founded on the Bible being a liberative text and scripture to be interpreted into the framework of liberation theology. In the Old and New Testament, this theological frame heavily features the persecution of the Jews and invariably primes Christian theologians to be in support of the state of Israel, which claims to be the fulfillment of the biblical myth-narratives regarding the “Land of Israel.” This claim sits at the center of Christian Zionism, which sees its largest contingent of supporters from the United States.
Dr. King’s perspectives were more the result of an American-centric focus centered on Christianity in the States. There is little to doubt he would change his mind on Israel after seeing it first-hand, much like James Baldwin after his first visit to the country. King already had reservations about the country and was at the very least obscurely aware of how Israel was viewed in many Asian and African nations. Following the 1967 war, Dr. King cancelled his visit saying, “I just think that if I go, the Arab world, and of course Africa and Asia for that matter, would interpret this as endorsing everything that Israel has done, and I do have questions of doubt” (Kestenbaum). Before his assassination, Dr. King was becoming more aligned with the internationalism of Third World Nations, due to his conversations with Malcolm X and pressure from the political left. The anti-Arabness of Dr. King, once referring to the Arab world as “in a state of imposed poverty and backwardness that must threaten peace and harmony,” would have been shunned by the Non-Alignment Movement (NAM) of Third World Nations who sought to build a collective of colonized peoples resisting the unjust North American/European Western hegemonic colonial structure (King and West, The Middle East Question). If he wanted to position himself as an internationalist like NAM leaders, such as Jawaharlal Nehru of India, Gamal Abdel Nasser of Egypt, Sukarno of Indonesia, Kwame Nkrumah of Ghana, Nelson Mandela of South Africa, Zhou Enlai of China, Fidel Castro of Cuba, Ho Chi Minh of Vietnam, Sékou Touré of Guinea and Ben Bella of Algeria, then Dr. King would have needed to embrace the anti-colonial struggle of Africa and Asia. Malcolm X had famously adopted a more internationalist frame after witnessing the Bandung Conference of Non-Aligned Nations (1955), which prove to inspire him, stating that:
At Bandung, all the nations came together. There were dark nations from Africa and Asia. Some of them were Buddhists. Some of them were Muslim. Some of them were Christian. Some of them were Confucian — Confucianists. Some were atheists. Despite their religious differences, they came together. Some were communists. Some were socialists. Some were capitalists. Despite their economic and political differences, they came together. All of them were Black, Brown, red or yellow. The number one thing that was not allowed to attend the Bandung Conference was the white man. He couldn’t come. Once they excluded the white man, they found that they could get together. Once they kept him out, everybody else fell right in and fell in line. This is the thing that you and I have to understand. And these people who came together didn’t have nuclear weapons. They didn’t have jet planes. They didn’t have all of the heavy armaments that the white man has. But they had unity (Democracy Now!).
Malcolm X also had the benefit of traveling to Mecca for Hajj in 1964, where he witnessed the pluralism of the Muslim world. He visited Palestine twice, first to Al-Aqsa Mosque in 1959, and later in 1964 to the Khan Younis refugee camp in Gaza. There he dined with the Gazan poet, Harun Hashim Rashid, who told Malcolm X how he just barely survived the 1956 Khan Younis massacre. Inspired by his visit to Palestine, Malcolm X returned to Cairo and famously wrote his essay “Zionist Logic” that was published in an Egyptian newspaper. In the essay he identified Zionism as a colonial project intent on dividing the Arab from the African, and the African from the Asian. This internationalist philosophy would continue to develop in a speech entitled “Not Just an American Problem, But a World Problem” just four days before his assassination.
The accomplishment of ending racial segregation in the U.S. was just the beginning for Dr. King and that his building of relational ties to Malcolm X would have necessitated a movement centered around international solidarity. That future was stripped away due to the murder of Dr. King and Malcolm X. If both men were alive today, they most certainly would be outspoken on the genocide in Gaza.
If it was Bishop Budde’s wish to evoke Dr. King in following his upright push for liberation, then would it not follow to speak out in support of Palestine? However, considering the nature of her speech it is likely she opts for the Zionist legacy of American Christianity. The quote following the mention of Dr. King in Bishop Budde’s speech further reveals her Zionist leanings:
And speaking as an Episcopal Bishop, I’ve been on the receiving end of that same frustration from some of you and members in my own faith community who want me to take stronger stands on all sorts of issues; and especially against our country’s support of the state of Israel’s war against the Palestinian people, the horrific use of starvation, and the indiscriminate bombing of an entire population (Budde 00:46:25).
There are several problems with this rhetoric. First, she does not call what is happening a genocide, instead calling it a “war against the Palestinian people.” She either doesn’t believe it is a genocide or is afraid of alienating her Zionist colleagues. If the Bishop is still on the fence of whether it is a genocide, I encourage her to go to ArchiveGenocide.com and watch just a few of the tens of thousands of videos uploaded to the digital archive, by over 300 journalists, documenting the genocide in Gaza. Second, the term “Palestinian people” in this context is a rhetorical device meant to further dehumanize Palestinians by positioning Palestinians as a disparate and homeless people who do not desire their own self-determination through the formation of a nation-state. This is what NGOs and Western newspapers did for years by listing Palestinians as displaced persons (DPs) or internally displaced persons (IDPs). Through the lack of acknowledgement of a place called Palestine, organizations and politicians do not have to provide Palestinians with equivalent legal rights or status. Palestine is a place that exists and has been called such from the past 4,000 years. Third, not specifically saying that Israel is weaponizing starvation opens up the rhetoric for interpretation. For example, the Zionist belief is that Hamas is starving Gazans by stealing all the food. This belief is a product of Hasbara propaganda: which is the Israeli state’s propaganda strategy for justifying its actions usually in the context of state violence. Fourth, is that there is ample evidence that Israel engages in discriminate bombing, not indiscriminate bombing. The specific targeting of homes, schools, hospitals, universities, journalists, and the families of journalists has been widely documented. Further, the use of AI systems in targeting individuals proves a structured response to killing void of any randomness. Israel for the most part knows exactly who they are killing and when they will be killed through a mass network of surveillance that is acquired from cellphone data to satellite imagery to drone footage to the reports of Israeli soldiers on the ground. By referring to Israel’s war crimes as only “indiscriminate,” one ignores the true extent of sadism which has been unleashed on Gaza and its very targeted discriminant nature.
I will be kind to note that her rhetoric follows the parroting of politicians and leaders trying to play the “both-sides” false equivalent. But we do not need our faith leaders to sound like politicians, we need our faith leaders to relay the wisdom of the world’s great prophets. A Christian should open the Bible and find guidance in the teachings of Jesus, not the soulless agents of capital who stand on their podiums with boldfaced lies. Faith leaders are meant to pull deep from the wisdom of the ages and translate it for the modern age. Christ would say to feed the beggars, the starved, the orphaned, the maimed, regardless of the color of their skin or whether they are Jew or Samaritan, Palestinian or Israeli. This is the theology that I would assume Bishop Budde would claim, but perhaps I assume with too much New Testament fervor. Perhaps her theology is one of Christian Zionists who weaponize anti-Semitism and the Old Testament for political gain — because that was the only theology that was present.
Bishop Budde then continues, and it is here that we enter into the realm of patronizing rhetoric where the Bishop lectures the colonized on how they should have a conversation with their colonizer:
... And I want you to know I hear you and I confess that I struggle with how best to engage what has become, without question, the most painfully divisive issue among the faith leaders on the progressive wing of our country; and that it lives right alongside the rise of anti-Semitism here and around the world and you and I know that there’s a difference between the policies of the Israeli government and the Jewish people. Just as the Trump administration does not speak for us, but that distinction can be lost in the cacophony of our time. I’m not saying it’s right, I’m just saying it’s true. And all I can tell you is what I already know, and you know, that social change requires people occupying different positions in a movement ecosystem. Some are called to be out in front. Others are needed for relationship building and bridge work… I, alongside the office of our presiding bishop, have chosen the relationship path. Has a lot to do with my relationships, interfaith relationships in the District of Columbia… We all need to remember the core principle of your first spiritual principle: the inherent dignity of every human being, even those with whom we vehemently disagree and the greater the polarization, the higher the stakes, that harder it becomes to treat other people, those with whom we disagree, with dignity. I tell you, in the Episcopal Church, both on the convention floor of our diocese and in our national assembly when we gather, the debate of Israel-Palestine becomes so heated, I feel like we need a peace process within ourselves. Now, I have been influenced by the work of Tim Shivers and others, who point out that we are living in a culture saturated with contempt, that is fueled by an outrage industrial complex, incredibly well-funded, and designed to keep us all really mad and unable to work constructively across differences. Shriver and others believe, as I do now, that the only viable antidote to contempt is an unwavering commitment to treat every person, no matter who they are or what they stand for, with dignity. Because just as hate cannot drive out hate, contempt cannot drive out contempt. Only dignity can do that (Budde 00:46:25).
It is in these words where Napoleon returns to once again tell us how to feel, how to think, how to be civilized. This is not some “issue” that we can pick up and put down like a school decathlon trophy; this is our life, our livelihood, these are the stories we tell our children when they go to sleep, this is the food we eat, the languages we speak, the dress we adorn ourselves with. Our resistance to the very ideologies intent on our annihilation is not the product of “a culture saturated with contempt,” it is the product of blood on pavements, of blood in the rubber plantations, the cotton fields, of centuries long crime scenes covered up and memories erased, people buried in unmarked graves that humanity will uncover a hundred years from now and say, “this was humanity’s most evil era.” What is a “painfully divisive issue” for you, Bishop Budde, is a fight for our very survival. But, of course, alas, it does not matter, because we refuse to be civilized. We refuse to sit down and talk with the very people who call us the “children of darkness,” or “The Curse,” or here, my favorite, “the modern incarnation of Amalek.” And there lies the Western liberal, buried for the last time under the rubble of bombed homes. Gaza has laid out everything to bare, in the Christian tradition, it has separated the wheat from the chaff. The Messiah’s return was not Jesus on a winged horse, it was the Gazan child whose screams fell silent to those who looked away, and those who looked away failed their judgement before God. Christ has shown us clearly the wheat from the chaff and it is the righteous who have gained the right to judge the wicked: and they, the wicked, have been found wanting.
Advocating for a free Palestine does not live “right alongside the rise of anti-Semitism here and around the world.” Being pro-Palestinian does not make you anti-Semitic, nor does criticizing Israel come at the expense of Jewish people. That is a fantasy constructed by a narrow world view propagated by the likes of Jabotinsky. To suggest such a thing is to admit that you prioritize the rights of one people over another, the antithesis to universalism and New Testament prophecy. One person's rights do not come at another's expense, because that, my friends, is fascism.
Well, I for one refuse to adhere to such a narrow perspective. Israel does not need to exist as a genocidal and segregationist state, but for a variety of political and historical factors it exists as such today. By parsing through the fluff and vague duplicity of her speech, we have found that Bishop Budde has made her views clear, and that her speech was injurious, nauseating, and untoward.
Conclusion
At the end of Bishop Budde’s speech the Rev. Dr. Sofía Betancourt, tenth president of the Unitarian Universalist Association, challenged the Bishop on the contents of her speech. Bishop Budde ignored the question, instead opting to reiterate her relationships with Zionist Jewish clergy. She followed it up by stating how when she brings up Palestine, it makes life harder for her Episcopal colleagues in Israel.
There is a great irony in defending the ideologies that wish to keep you in a state of fear. It is both a cowardice of ethics and in the case of Jewish people (perceived to be the world’s ultimate victims) a deference to an imposed European infantilization. Life becomes harder for Episcopalians in the Holy Land, because Israeli settlers make it harder — just as Catholic nuns and priests are attacked when the Pope even dares to utter the word Palestine.
Why is there so much fear for that which is unjust? Was it not Jesus who said: “Do not be afraid of those who kill the body but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell.” [NIV Matthew 10:28]
If we fear our own persecution and the persecution of those who journey alongside us, so much as to not voice our discernments for that which is unjust, then we have sincerely forgotten the point of Jesus’s crucifixion.
Bishop Budde wrote the speech for a predominantly white denomination and centered whiteness rather than those of us who exist on the margins. Unitarian Universalism for decades now has had a problem with the Other, and especially if that Other prays five times a day. It was not always that way. Centuries ago, it was the Ottoman Muslims who protected the Unitarians from the persecution of European Christians who held the trinitarian view. Unitarians were persecuted because their theological belief in the Oneness or Unity, of God, was more closely tied to Islam than the dominant Christian faith traditions. Trinitarians accused the Unitarians of following a “‘Turkish Christ’” and being “‘more Mahometan than Christian’” (Meggit 50-51). This accusation was commonly levied at Unitarians, more than any other group in Europe. For a time, the Unitarians were seen more so to be Muslim rather than Christian. They were like the Muslim immigrants of today that Europe rejects, such that if the Unitarians were to have been subjected to a genocide, the West would have just as equally said “good riddance.” It stands to reason we were an Islamo-Christian religion, long before we called ourselves a Judeo-Christian one. There sits the irony which history forces us to reconcile with time and time again.
This month, the largest Presbyterian Church in the United States voted overwhelmingly in the declaring Israel’s assault on Gaza a genocide. And still, Unitarian Universalism peddles backwards, where we are forced to have this conversation once again. Unitarian Universalism is having an identity crisis, it has been doing so for decades, long before I was a little boy climbing over the chairs in the worship hall. That crisis of identity was accelerated by the genocide in Gaza. The most morally transparent issue of our time became the subject of debate. Some UUs justified the genocide, some UUs condemned it, and some stayed silent. It is sorrowful that a faith claiming to be the most progressive and universal in its acceptance of peoples, is to break at such a moment, but alas, here we are and here we shall remain until key questions in this faith are solved.
Devin A.C. Dadah is an Outreach Coordinator for the Unitarian Universalist (UU) people of color and anti-racist centered ministry known as Diverse Revolutionary Unitarian Universalist Multicultural Ministries (DRUUMM). He has been raised in UU congregations since the age of five and is currently a student at the University of California, Berkeley. There he focuses on post-colonial studies and has trained under the mentees of the late Edward W. Said.
Bibliography
Boqai, Nihad. Returning to Kafr Bir’im. Edited by Ingrid Gassner. Translated by Khalil Touma and Simon Boas. BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights, 2006. p. 35.
Carleton, Richard. “Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine Spokesman Ghassan Kanafani Interview.” (Beirut), 1970. https://youtu.be/Veoy32G7trY?si=og3lJX78DDdz1uG4.
Cavett, Dick, dir. “James Baldwin’s Prophetic Warning to America.” The Dick Cavett Show. American Broadcasting Company (ABC), May 16, 1969. https://youtu.be/hcYTpKHsWpY?si=TowUEiJ0b7VWsPBl.
Césaire, Aimé. DISCOURSE ON COLONIALISM. (JSTOR), n.d. http://www.jstor.com/stable/j.ctt9qfkrm.4. p. 35-36.
Democracy Now! “How Historic 1955 Anti-Colonial Bandung Conference Inspired New Era in Global South.” April 22, 2025. https://www.democracynow.org/2025/4/22/1955_bandung_conference.
Dr. Martin Luther King. The Radical King. Edited by Cornel West. Beacon Press, 2015. ch. Introduction, The Middle East Question.
Hazkani, Shay. Yes to Transfer: 82% of Jewish Israelis Back Expelling Gazans. May 28, 2025. https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-05-28/ty-article-magazine/.premium/yes-to-transfer-82-of-jewish-israelis-back-expelling-gazans/00000197-12a4-df22-a9d7-9ef6af930000.
ʻAbd al-Raḥmān Jabartī. Napoleon in Egypt: Al-Jabartī’s Chronicle of the French Occupation, 1798. Markus Wiener Publishers, 2004. p. 24-26, 145.
Jabotinsky, Ze’ev. “The Iron Wall.” Essay. Razsviet, November 4, 1923. https://en.jabotinsky.org/media/9747/the-iron-wall.pdf.
Justin J. Meggit. “Early Unitarians and Islam: Revisiting a ‘Primary Document.’” Unitarian Theology II, no. Faith and Freedom (2018): 48–59. https://doi.org/10.17863/CAM.21403. p. 50-51.
Kaplan, Amy. Our American Israel: The Story of an Entangled Alliance. Harvard University Press, 2018. p. 20, 65, 75, 95, 115, 246.
Kestenbaum, Sam. Martin Luther King Jr.’s Pilgrimage to Israel That Never Was. April 3, 2018. https://www.haaretz.com/us-news/2018-04-03/ty-article/martin-luther-king-jr-s-pilgrimage-to-israel-that-never-was/0000017f-db2f-db5a-a57f-db6f89ca0000.
Lennard, Natasha. Military Leaders See Iran War as “God’s Divine Plan” — a Chilling Turn for Trump’s Fascism. March 5, 2026. https://theintercept.com/2026/03/05/iran-war-end-times-christian/.
Mariann Edgar Budde. The 2026 General Assembly Ware Lecture. Unitarian Universalist Association, 2026. 00:35:50, 00:46:25,
Masalha, Nur. Palestine: A Four Thousand Year History. Bloomsbury Academic, 2023. p. 59, 45.
Said, Edward W. Orientalism. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, 1994. p. 204, 210, 300, 301.