Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Dec. 16th, 2021
Art has a way of transforming and inspiring minds. It shows us new ways to view ourselves and challenge our pre-existing beliefs about the world. The machinations of art played a critical role in the French Revolution of 1789 and Russian Revolution of 1917. It inspired uprising, facilitated dialogue, and gave people hope. Freedom and change were powerful ideals amongst the people which pushed these nations into revolution. Here we will compare and contrast Jacques-Louis David, Napoleon Crossing the Alps (France, Neoclassicism, 1801, oil on canvas) with Boris Kustodiev, The Bolshevik (Russia, Avant-garde, 1920, oil on canvas) and Jean-Baptiste Greuze, The Village Bride (France, Rococo, 1761, oil on canvas) with Konstantin Yuon, New Planet (Russia, Avant-garde, 1921, tempera on cardboard); as the artworks which influenced society in the desire for freedom and change.
During the French Revolution art was painted in the Neoclassical style. It was a new art form steeped in old ideas and seeking to resurrect nostalgic feelings of Ancient Greece and Rome. The tone of this art was more serious than its Rococo predecessor and more relatable to the majority of French society. However, the Rococo 'Natural Art’ submovement emulated Classical art in a variety of ways: Neoclassicism was refined using straight lines, minimal color, defined forms and a smooth paint surface, hiding the brush work.
During the Russian Revolution art was painted in the Avant-garde style. Lenin famously said: “art belongs to the people. It must leave its deepest roots in the very thick of the working masses. It should be understood by those masses and loved by them.” Before the revolution Russian artists emulated Neoclassicism and Italian Renaissance art. Lenin believed art should no longer be preserved by the aristocracy, upper class, and bourgeoisie. Classical art was the epitome of aristocracy and while Avant-garde artists drew inspiration from it, the style was believed to be steeped in corruption. When the revolution came, art in Russia drastically changed as artists moved away from tradition. Art became Avant-garde: bold, new and innovative. Russian Avant-garde consisted of several prominent art styles, which were Rayonism, Russian Futurism (Cubo-Futurism), Suprematism, Neo-Primitivism and Constructivism. The term avant-garde derives from military vocabulary as crusaders warning against the traditional school of painting. A fitting term for the Bolsheviks, Avant-garde in Russia eventually faded away in Russia after Lenin’s death, when Stalin state-sanctioned Socialist Realism to control the influence of art.
Jean-Baptiste Greuze (1725-1805) was an artist of the French Rococo art period, but was part of the sub-movement of ‘Natural Art.’ His style looked nothing like many of the famous Rococo pieces. Instead of lifting up the aristocracy, Greuze focused on the non-aristocratic classes in France. He wanted to represent the people that would eventually go on to lead a revolution. For this fact Greuze was placed in the lowest category of artists at Salons and denied entry to the Academy. While this hurt his career it may have also been a blessing. It enabled Greuze to emphasize the righteousness of peasantry with his art, which was in stark contrast to the aristocratic fête galantes of the Rococo.
The Village Bride by Jean-Baptiste Greuze. France, 1761.
Jean-Baptiste Greuze, The Village Bride became a very influential piece amongst the peasantry as it uplifted the righteousness of the peasantry. Greuze, being a proud member of the Third Estate, wanted to humiliate the other estates to get support from the people. In essence Greuze was speaking for the Third Estate and saying that no longer do marriages need to be regulated by the church, but should be a secular business transaction between two families. This followed the Enlightenment ideals of the era which gave people the freedom they desired. The painting also did not display the frivolousness of the fête galantes. In addition, it showed two competent male father figures as enough authority to witness a marriage. This made the upper classes look silly and unfit to rule the country, while the peasant class seemed serious, humble, and grounded to French society: attributes of good leadership. The stylistic choices being a far contrast of Rococo further placed emphasis on these differences. The painting is dark with earthy tones, not adhering to a pastel color palette, there is no elegance, lightness or heavy ornamentation. It is a gritty, relatable, and a realistic interpretation of a peasant marriage. Interestingly, what this does is remove the peasant class away from the ideals of the upper classes. Since the artwork is not in the mainstream Rococo style, Greuze is making a statement; that the masses no longer need the upper classes for approval. These were the first steps of freedom and revolution taken by the lower classes. This piece fed the egos of the peasantry and lamented what needed to be changed in the ideal French society.
Konstantin Yuon (1875-1958) was an Impressionist from Moscow who traveled to Paris often to study the landscape of the city's nightlife. Yuon was in support of the revolution and post-revolution, he became the First Secretary for the Union of Soviet Artists. Later in his life Yuon became strict in the Socialist Realism art style.
New Planet by Konstantin Yuon. Russia, 1921.
“People of the future,” this is what the Konstantin Yuon, New Planet brings to mind and is the aestheticism Avant-garde wanted to revolutionize. Taking from the Futurism style this piece depicts the birth of a new world as a representation for the birth of a new nation, the Soviet Union. Not only does this piece take from Futurism in it's worship of a new idealized industrious society and glorification of war, but it experiments with lightning like the Impressionists and features the same dramatic dynamism as Classical works. New Planet not only breaks rules within Classical art, but breaks rules with other art movements by creating a fusion of Modern art. The piece depicts an old gray earth with people nude, wearing tattered clothes, and animal skins: either worshiping or running from the rise of a blood red planet. It is symbolic of the people leaving an ancient primeval way of life and entering a new era. This piece was referencing the October Revolution, a civil war in which the Bolsheviks overthrew the Czar monarchy. It is estimated that 9 million people died in the revolution as is shown with some bodies lying immobile on the ground. The inspiration from the Classical genre is further emphasized in the thematic message of the red planet being Mars or Ares, the Greek god of war. While Ares was not a popular god of worship in Ancient Greece, here the people worship him as war being a necessity for the freedom people desire. People reach up to the celestial bodies in the sky and bow down to their power. The change is terrifying for the “primitive” people as some shield themselves from the light rays of the transforming earth. It is quickly compared to an apocalypse, but they have yet to realize that it is instead a metamorphosis.
The Village Bride and New Planet are in complete contrast with each other in terms of form, style and depictions, but underline the same themes of freedom and change. Unlike with The Village Bride and it's dark earthy tones, New Planet bolsters bright innovative exclusionary light contrasting amongst the darkness. It does not value smooth clean brushstrokes like in Greuze’s piece and instead mixes contrasting tones to emphasize chaos. Geometric shapes such as triangles and circles which take up a majority of canvas are akin to the Constructivist or Cubo-Futurist art movements of that era. New Planet was used to not only inspire the people into the new era, but commemorate the October Revolution. When the Bolsheviks took power in 1917 they usurped a democratically held vote which the Socialists won. This created a faction of other left-leaning groups, who turned on the Bolsheviks and created the White Army. Other armies formed such as the Green and Black Armies, but Yuon was in support of the Red Army. The red of the new planet served to gain favor among the unaffiliated and affiliated people to support the Bolsheviks and the Red Army. Similarly, Greuze’s piece served to get the masses to appreciate the Third Estate. It was meant to assure the people and demonstrate what the Third Estate would bring if they were in power. The piece was to lay the catalyst for revolution and make sure that there was a unified front against the upper classes.
These two pieces focused on the positivity of change as a revolutionary force that progresses society. The Village Bride showed the value and serenity in the joining of two families free from the eye of clergy. New Planet symbolically cemented the joy, passion, security, and sheer might the new Russia promised to bring, while simultaneously recognizing everyone's fears. Both were perfect pieces for their audiences and masterpieces for the burgeoning faith in the ideas of freedom and change.
The works of Jacques-Louis David (1748-1825) were seen as the epitome of Neoclassicism. He pioneered the art style and would go on to attract over 300 students to his studio at the Collège des Quatre-Nations, Paris. David was a committed revolutionary serving as the Minister of Propaganda for the Jacobins. Despite this he still took commissions from the monarchy and would eventually become Napoleon's right hand man post monarchy.
Napoleon Crossing the Alps by Jacques-Louis David. France, 1801.
Jacques-Louis David, Napoleon Crossing the Alps was a nationalistic piece that served as propaganda for the post-revolutionary regime. It became a symbol for Napoleon’s assertiveness and power as leader within the new France. David was a nationalist and believed “those marks of heroism and civic virtue offered to the eyes of the people electrify the soul, and plant the seeds of glory and devotion to the fatherland.” He embodied that in paintings such as these, devoting himself to the perceived embodiment of the French Empire, Napoleon. David was usually used to creating heroes of the past to spur national glory. He does retain some of these with references by etching the names of Hannibal and Bonaparte in the stone. Essentially, he is comparing Napoleon to great leaders of the past. Freedom as Napoleon viewed it was only found through the state and its imperialistic expansion into other countries. Napoleon believed, "Europe thus divided into nationalities freely formed and free internally, peace between States would have become easier: the United States of Europe would become a possibility." Such as with the anxiety of other independent nations around France, Napoleon believed that France could not be truly free and only under a united Europe could the French Empire experience “true freedom:” with Napoleon atop his horse like the equestrian statues of Rome and moving up a treacherous cliff with storms surrounding him like that of Odysseus, he would bring about that freedom. The earthy tones, quick brushstrokes and dynamic posing take inspiration from some of the most iconic Renaissance pieces. Napoleon dressed in military attire and movement of soldiers inspire strong civic nationalist duty within the painting. The scene calls to arms a strong leader who can fight for your freedoms.
Boris Kustodiev (1878-1927) was a very talented painter according to his colleagues. He loved to repaint famous Classical pieces with a culturally Russian and modern flare, such as with his re-paintings of Pieter Bruegel, Peasant Dance and Hans Holbien, Portrait of Georg Gisze. A big theme in his artworks was to show that no matter how many centuries went by, people still had the same aspirations. As a result he painted the peasant classes eventually joining the Mir iskusstva: an influential pro-revolutionary magazine in Russia.
The Bolshevik by Boris Kustodiev. Russia, 1920.
Boris Kustodiev, The Bolshevik was an iconic artwork during the Russian Revolution. Like the New Planet, it was also created during the Russian Civil War, and was a tribute to the Bolsheviks Red Army. It is a nationalistic representation of what Russia was like at the end of the October Revolution when the Bolsheviks overthrew the Czar monarchy. In the piece we get to see the immensity of the Russian revolution with a Bolshevik giant waving a red flag parading through the streets. While the giant resembles Lenin, the giant is a simple Russian of the working class, the same as everyone on the streets below him. We see that all sorts of classes celebrate in the street: soldiers, peasants, and the upper class. The piece is Avant-garde with bright illuminating colors that move away from the dark Neoclassical art style. We find no conflict in the art piece, just a pure celebratory bliss. The giant only finds one obstacle before him, a church, the last authority loyal to the monarchy. But the giant does not acknowledge its presence, instead he shows his willingness to stride through it.
Napoleon Crossing the Alps and The Bolshevik are both nationalistic commentaries meant to inspire the people. They want viewers to feel a devotion to the state. The two idealize their leaders, with Napoleon the only bright figure surrounded by a stormy darkness and the Bolshevik giant leading people into a new era. In both pieces the two men are disproportionately large. Napoleon looks as though he cannot and should not fit on his horse, while the Bolshevik towers over the buildings and waves a giant red flag which engulfs the sky. This is to show them as larger than life, strong, powerful, and able to take on the world. They are leaders ready to conquer land for the people of their nation. Napoleon rides up the Swiss Alps to expand the French Empire. The Bolshevik embodies its party's motto of “Peace, Land and Bread” where people finally see peace in the streets, they stride into new territory whether physical or ideological and are abundantly fulfilled with happiness. David painted five versions of Napoleon Crossing the Alps, the Charlottenburg Palace and Versailles versions both depict Napoleon with a red cape surrounding him. Red is a power color, and like in The Bolshevik, the color red represents courage, war, vigor, love, and the blood which regulates life. The ideologies of Napoleon's French Empire and the Bolshevik Soviet Union both emphasised freedom through expansion. Immediately after overthrowing the Czar, the Bolshevik Red Army began military excursions into Europe. This created political turmoil across Eurasia as countries scrambled to establish themselves in response to the new and hungry nation. The trailing of the red flag across the sky in The Bolshevik symbolizes the expansion of Russia across Eurasia, just as Napoleon’s cape pointing with him symbolizes French expansion across Europe. Both pieces harbor many similarities, but a crucial point is that Napoleon is one man and the Bolshevik is many. The Bolshevik giant is meant to represent a collective of people under the ideas of communism. Freedom from the class struggle is found through communist ideals, not one defining leader. Napoleon is, but one man, who is in many ways just like the monarchs he overthrew.
These two pieces articulated the nationalist fervor that led the people into revolution against oppressive monarchical rule. Napoleon Crossing the Alps glorified French imperialism as the necessity for freedom of the French people. The Bolshevik not only showed the excitement of change, but prosperity and liberties that a new Russia would bring.
While freedom is not what the people got, it was the ideals of freedom that led the people to revolution. For many in the U.S.S.R. and French Empire, life was much better than under monarchical rule. The people had a new invigorated willingness for life as working conditions got better in the U.S.S.R., whereas in the French Empire Napoleon’s hate for feudalism, civil inequality, and religious tolerance, led France into a new era. Oftentimes freedom and change comes at the expense of others. In Russia, pogroms and mass executions were conducted following the October Revolution and in France, Napoleon reinstated slavery and conquered new territory. Oppression sometimes shifts from one person to another and one could argue that we are not free, until all of us are free.
References
Chandler, Meghan M. Reframing Art History: A New Survey of 15th-19th Century Western European Art for 21st Century Learners. Great River Learning, 2019.
Listen to the Revolution: The Impact of the Russian Revolution on Art and Culture. Culture Matters, 2017.
Demidenko, Lulia. “The scattering of art in revolutionary Petrograd.” From the Center of Baltic and Eastern European Studies (CBEES) Stödertörn University, vol. 12, no. 3, 2019, pp. 58-67
Shashkevich, Alex. “New exhibition at Hoover Institution and Cantor Arts Center marks centenary of 1917 Russian Revolution.” Stanford News, https://news.stanford.edu/2017/11/15/new-exhibition-marks-centenary-1917-russian-revolution/
Gleboca, A. “UCI Art History Course Descriptions (Avant-Garde Russia).” UCI Department of Art History, https://www.humanities.uci.edu/arthistory/courses/courses.php?sort=instr&term=W16&dept_name=ART%20HIS&sort_ord=asc&course_level=u
Newman, James. “Socialist Realism: Stalin’s Control of Art in the Soviet Union.” The Collector, https://www.thecollector.com/soviet-realism-stalin-control/
“Avant-garde.” Arthive, https://arthive.com/styles/avant_garde#works
“New Planet.” Arthive, https://arthive.com/artists/2042~Konstantin_Yuon/works/251647~New_planet
Cumming, Laura. “Revolution: Russian Art 1917-1932 review - when anything was possible.” The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2017/feb/12/revolution-russian-art-1917-1932-review
Zarzeczny, Matthew D. “Napoleon and the Unification of Europe.” The Napoleon Series, https://www.napoleon-series.org/research/napoleon/c_unification.html
Images of the Public Domain