Written by Devin A.C. Dadah | Mar. 24th, 2023
“Nobody owns anything but everyone is rich - for what greater wealth can there be than cheerfulness, peace of mind, and freedom from anxiety?” — Sir Thomas More (1478-1535). In the controversial 16th century work, Utopia: More describes a perfect world absent of money and private property. Where all religions are tolerated, education is free, healthcare is free, and citizens only have to work six hours a day. It was a stark contrast from the monarchies of Europe, but beyond Europe, it laid hope and longing for a society like no other. This essay will seek to explore More’s utopian society in comparison to literature from Niccolò Machiavelli (1469-1527), Michel de Montaigne (1533-1592), and artwork from James Wooldridge (c. 1675). We will analyze the European and Renaissance projections of utopia in the Americas, by examining its historical, political, philosophical, and business representations present in that era.
Amerigo Vespucci (1451-1512) in his letters to Lorenzo Pietro di Medici (1463-1503), in the Spring of 1503, coined the term New World; from the Latin mundus novus. The name itself evoked a sense of wonder, curiosity, enchantment, and dreams of a fresh start, or tabula rasa. In Vespucci’s letter he describes the people of the Americas, stating “they have no cloth either of wool, linen or cotton, since they need it not; neither do they have goods of their own, but all things are held in common. They live together without king, without government, and each is his own master” (Northrup, 6). It is here where Europe is inspired by the first accounts of the New World; and where More, just thirteen years later, would author his most famous work.
In Utopia, More speaks with Raphael Hythloday, a fictional old man who traveled alongside Vespucci. Hythloday tells More of this utopian society and criticizes the commonwealth of Europe as being corrupt. He states, “I can have no other notion… than that they are a conspiracy of the rich, who… only pursue their private ends” (More). It is evident that More was tired of the monarchical power struggles in Europe. More, had worked his way up the ranks from undersheriff of London to Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster: England’s second highest cabinet position. He was an esteemed diplomat, with a wide circle of friends, and therefore privy to the politics of Europe. During the Protestant Reformation (1517), he became disillusioned with England’s plan to secede from the Papacy. More, was a devout Catholic, and his refusal to recognize Henry VIII’s annulment would result in his execution in 1535.
Utopia was essentially More’s oblique critique of Europe. It envisioned a society where human vices were checked by strict legal prudence and equality for all its citizens. More’s Utopia harbored no aristocratic class, no monarchy, and a representative democracy similar to the Iroquois Confederacy (1450-1660) in the New World. For More, the New World was to be learned from. The economy, attitudes, and work-ethic of the New World was to be adapted for European society. More remarks that “every person has some particular trade of his own… people wear the same sort of clothes throughout the island,” and that “the Utopians work six hours out of the twenty-four” with the women, the beggars, the rich, and religious men also working (Matthews and Platt, 34). In accounts such as Vespucci, these inclinations were observed amongst the people of the New World. Everyone partook in their fair share of work, and because everyone participated, all would benefit with more free time to pursue one’s individual hobbies. Perhaps, the closest representation of More’s Utopia is that of the aforementioned Iroquois Confederacy. In Utopia, the 54 city-states which composed their society were separate from each other but shared the same values. They were by definition a confederation, which sought to share their resources equally with one another. Political delegates were chosen through election, and the essential political body was the 6,000 households of each city-state. Each household had between 10-16 members. These households would choose a political delegate, referred to in Utopia as syphogrants. There were 200 syphogrants per city-state, and each would oversee 30 households. 20 tranibors administered the syphogrants, and the syphogrants (by secret ballot) elected one person, from four candidates of each city, to oversee the entire confederation of city-states; this position is the princeps (Latin) or prince. The Iroquois Confederacy or Haudenosaunee (“People of the Longhouse”) was eerily similar to Utopia. It was made up of five different tribes: the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, and Seneca. Each tribe was made up of a collection of matrilineal households. These households were known as clans, and members of each clan accepted each other as family even if they were from another tribe. Clans selected 50 male chiefs from each tribe, called sachems, who would sit on a political council. The council met on issues which affected the entire Iroquois Confederacy, and this grand council would formulate smaller councils within each tribe. Clan Mothers oversaw each council meeting to ensure their chief represented the people. The chiefs of the tribes would not move forward with decisions until all tribes agreed. Both More’s Utopia and the Iroquois Confederacy were representative democracies who elected political delegates based on households. In turn, those delegates were expected to represent the people fairly or they would be ousted from their seats. The relationship between these two political systems arose as a reaction to oppressive European political systems. Utopia is More’s fictional remedy, meant to instill the notion of a better world. Whereas the Iroquois Confederacy was born out of necessity to preserve one's way of life, in direct opposition to the ever encroaching Europeans way of life. It is this juxtaposition which is indicative of More’s criticism. The European need to consume its neighboring brethren, and for what reason? More, presents a mirror, which all of Europe is to reflect on. He asks Europe: what is the point? It is pointless to fight, if in the end result society is worse for it.
Comparably, early European settlers indeed harbored these utopian ideals. Fleeing religious oppression and corrupt monarchy, the Puritans of New England (1630) emigrated to the New World. There they sought to build a new society; however it would prove just as oppressive as the Church of England. Leadership among the Puritans was strict, and religion dictated every aspect of life. While perhaps not a More’s Utopia, it existed in the same headspace. Utopia for the Puritans required the strict instillment of fear akin to that of Machiavelli. A ruler of any government, in the Machiavellian ideal, needs to be loved and feared; and what better ruler than that of God. No exercises in freedom of speech, freedom of religion, or freedom of the press. Those who questioned the government or did not practice Puritan Christianity were swiftly shunned, shamed, and banished. This was life in the Puritan colonies, yet “‘the end justifies any means’” (Matthews and Platt, 18). If the “end” for the Puritans was heaven, then all is justified in reaching it. The New World was the gateway for the Puritans utopia. For some, it is noticeable that the Puritans created “hell on earth,” in the convictions that they would make it to the utopian paradise of Heaven.
Machiavelli, if he lived to witness the Puritans, would likely regard their quest for virtue as foolish. He states that “if a prince wants to maintain his rule he must learn how not to be virtuous” (Matthews and Platt, 19). Machiavelli mocks idealized societies like More’s Utopia and Plato’s The Republic. However, Machiavelli teaches a temperance of the ego and reservation of material pleasures. This is not for the “self-improvement” of the prince, but as to not waste resources. Just as in More’s Utopia, it is for the utilitarian benefit of the many over the few. Machiavelli employs the selfish need for power, but through it helps the many, far more than that of his rivals. This too is virtuous, as it is clear that the Pope would not lament the suffering of his fellow Catholics, which led to the Sack of Rome (1527). In essence, More’s Utopia seeks this same preservation, but employed by the collective. City-states in More’s Utopia would not hesitate to go to war in-defense of their way of life. In fact, they would go as far as to avenge their allies and purge them of tyranny. Enemies captured in these battles were used as slaves, as well as citizens who failed to live by More’s Utopian virtue. It is this same lack of virtue which Machiavelli condemns. Love is granted to those loyal to the state, and if it is a just state, then there is nothing to fear. Machiavelli seeks to create a state which does not alienate its people, he states: “I say that a prince should want to have a reputation for compassion rather than for cruelty: nonetheless, he should be careful that he does not make bad use of compassion” (Matthews and Platt, 19). More’s Utopia is infinitely compassionate, yet also equally cruel. If you follow the standards governed by the state you will live a glorious life, but if you fail them you are forced into a life of servitude. Machiavelli writes The Prince as a reaction to an era where money corrupts and your closest friends cannot be trusted. More does the same, yet instead speaks of a society without money or corruption, and where everyone is your closest friend. The two authors write of the same society, but project upon it their contrasting views of the world. Machiavelli, the realist pessimist, and More, the idealistic optimist.
Montaigne in Chapter XXXI, “Of Cannibals,” Book I — of the Essays, takes these same ideas, but with his own philosophical twist. Montaigne argued that Europe had strayed from nature, surrounded itself with artificiality, and as a result, corrupted its society. He notes, in reference to Mother Nature, that “we have so overloaded the beauty and richness of her works by our inventions… Yet wherever her purity shines forth, she wonderfully puts to shame our vain and frivolous attempts” (Matthews and Platt, 39). Montaigne sees utopia in the purity of the New World. He uses an anthropomorphic view of the natural world: Mother Nature. This asserts that nature is the birther of life. As a result, the European suppression of nature has resulted in only death and despair. The remedies for Europe’s torn society are found in the way New World people live. They embrace nature, and through this they create utopia. Europe’s fixation on suppressing humanity's true nature results in only misery. In mocking Plato’s ideal society (The Republic), Montaigne writes “this is a nation… in which there is no sort of traffic, no knowledge of letters… no custom of servitude, no riches or poverty… lying, treachery, dissimulation, avarice, envy, belittling, pardon—unheard of. How far from this perfection would he find the republic that he imagined: Men fresh sprung from gods [Seneca]” (Matthews and Platt, 40). Montaigne illustrates that Plato’s The Republic and More’s Utopia are remedies for a “broken” society. It is to address the injustice from which civilization cannot escape. Seneca is used to illustrate that utopia lies within, and that it is the impurities of civilization imposed upon humanity which create injustice. Utopia can only be found when one’s intentions are pure, and purity is found in the submission of the natural order by which things live. Therefore, civilization, and with it, humanity's inability to give up control, results in the suffering of being. It is humorous for Montaigne, that in the petty European struggle for control, there is an undiscovered world by which people have submitted all control; and as a result discovered the peace that philosophers thousands of years prior struggled to find.
In 1675, James Wooldridge painted Indians of Virginia for Edward Conway, the 1st Earl of Conway (1623-1683). Wooldridge painted an indigenous American village that was likely the 1st Earl of Conway’s commission to encourage business in the New World. In the painting, purple and orange colors of the sunset sky draw our eyes to the infinite expanse of possibilities in the New World. Villagers sit unified in a circle. Their community is doing well, with an abundance of food. Under the sunset, around the bonfire, and amongst friends the people convey a peacefulness. It is the utopian vision of the New World placed upon the canvas. Wooldridge painted a world where the appeals of freedom, democracy, and infinite abundance were meant to lure people from the oppression, monarchy, and scarcity of Europe. The depictions of the longhouses and indigenous peoples elicit notions of an already existing utopia. However, in the context the painting was utilized, it would be a talking piece in the 1st Earl of Conway’s business decisions. Utopian ideals were bastardized in an effort to accumulate profit. In other words, the criticisms of Europe from More, Machiavelli, and Montaigne were prophetic. Utopia was just another business venture. In the arrogance and greed of Europeans, the New World was made into a New Europe; but where utopian visions could be used as a tool to conform society.
The projections of utopia were an integral part of Renaissance thought. More, living in the chaos of the Reformation envisioned a society which embraced order as the highest virtue. Machiavelli, contemplating how to traverse the brutal European political reality, ironically foretold of a virtuous society born out of the sacrifice of leadership. Montaigne, plagued by his own ideations, and quite possibly born in the wrong era, philosophized that utopia exists within the purity of being. More, Machiavelli, and Montaigne outlined the three elements needed to bring utopia to Europe: order, sacrifice, and pure intentions. But it is Wooldridge who proved their criticisms right, that the suffering of Europe was indeed, all encompassing. However, these ideals of utopia, these desires for something better, would lead Europe into a new era. An era of enlightened thinking and boundless innovation.
Work Cited
Wooldridge, James. Indians of Virginia. 1675, Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art, Arkansas.
Matthews, Roy, and DeWitt Platt. Readings to Accompany Experience Humanities Volume 2: The Renaissance to the Present. McGraw-Hill Education, 2013.
More, Thomas. Utopia. Translated by Gilbert Burnet, CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, 2017.
Northrup, George Tyler, and Phillips Academy, Oliver Wendell Holmes Library. “Internet Archive.” Mundus novus. Letter to Lorenzo Pietro di Medici; by Amerigo Vespucci, Princeton University Press, 1916, https://archive.org/details/mundusnovuslette00vesp/page/n15/mode/2up. Accessed 22 March 2023.
Image of the Public Domain